Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 14 June 2016 Justice Committee About 10:30–10:45 Procedure 20 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Showing Margaret Mitchell only · show everyone

Margaret Mitchell’s contributions

10 contributions
Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The next item of business is our approach to developing our work programme. The clerks have issued members with an approach paper. The main decision before us concerns whether we want to hold a planning day in order to properly work out the way forward with regard to our work programme. We will not discuss specific issues today—that could perhaps be left to our next meeting—but once we get more of an idea of where we want to go, we could use that away day, or business planning day, to put meat on the bones of our plans. I invite comments from members.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

It is up to us where we hold the meeting but, if we hold the meeting outwith the Parliament, that would give us an opportunity to meet the cabinet secretary on a more informal basis and inform him of what we are thinking about and what issues we want to raise and give prominence to.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That is certainly something else to put in the melting pot.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

There are quite a lot of issues there.

First, there is no doubt—John Finnie and I will testify to this—that the previous Justice Committee was really a legislative machine. Our workload of 17 bills was really oppressive, inquiries were squeezed and it was virtually impossible for us to carry out post-legislative scrutiny.

One of the pluses or strong points of the committees was supposed to be their ability to hold the Government to account in order to improve legislation. There really was not any opportunity to do that in the previous session, and there has been no emphasis on that in any session of Parliament. I therefore very much welcome Stewart Stevenson’s suggestion that post-legislative scrutiny should feature in our work programme, and I hope that it will.

Rather than just reacting, it would be excellent if the committees could operate as they were intended to and could look at issues that they deem to be important and worthy of being brought to the fore by being the subject of an inquiry.

Another thing that I will put into the melting pot is that, in the whole history of the committee system, only one piece of legislation has been generated by a committee, although I could be wrong about that. Interruption. Stewart Stevenson, our numerical expert, tells me that there have been two. However, in 16 or 17 years of the Parliament, that is a pretty poor record. Therefore, another thing that our committee could consider is legislation that the Government does not have in mind but which we think is important and should be brought to the fore.

We have some good ideas for the planning day. I do not want bids from all over the country for which part we should visit—no doubt they would be from the Highlands and Islands down to the Borders and Dumfries. Perhaps we can work that out when we discuss the issue more fully on 28 June. I seek members’ agreement to do that, and to have the business planning day.

As regards the issue that Douglas Ross raised, we received correspondence this week from the clerks—we all got it at the same time, so I did not have any prior knowledge of it—indicating that the report into the counter-corruption unit by Derek Penman, which was expected in spring, is delayed and is now expected to be published before the summer recess. I think that Mr Penman has said that it will be published in time to be put before Parliament, but not necessarily in time for the committee to look at the issue. If we want to ensure that it is published in time for us to take evidence on the Tuesday, it would be a good idea if the committee agreed to write to Mr Penman suggesting that he makes the report available on the Monday. If there are good reasons why that is not possible, at least he can give us those reasons.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

My only comment on that is that I presume that, whether we discuss the issue on 28 June or in September, the same legal considerations will apply and we will have to make sure that there is not a problem.

I ask the clerk, Peter McGrath, to comment on the issue. If we write, we will be asking whether there is a possibility that the report will be published in time for us to look at it. We have almost a fortnight until 28 June to sort out any possible legal problems. If HMICS says that there is a particular reason why we should not look at the report, at least we will have pressed the issue and tried to take evidence. If we do not take evidence, the report will be published that week and will then lie until September. We can write to find out whether there is any reason why we should not take evidence and, if there is, at least we will know the situation.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We understand that, but our point is that, as Mr Penman is going to publish his report that week anyway, he should be made aware that we will have a meeting on 28 June. The report will be available and will be laid before Parliament for scrutiny, but I envisage that there will be very little opportunity for it to be scrutinised, other than by this committee. The main point of writing to Mr Penman is to make him aware of that.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Do we agree to write to Derek Penman to point out that the committee is sitting on 28 June, to note that it is likely that the report will be published in the week beginning 27 June and to indicate that, if there are no legal barriers to our doing this, our intention is, we hope, to take evidence at the meeting on 28 June? If there are some legal problems, we will take advice from the clerks and legal officials, and we will find out whether Mr Penman has any reasons why what we have suggested should not be the case. If he cannot do it, he will write back and tell us why, but I think that we have set down quite a strong marker that we want to look at and fully scrutinise this issue.

The approach to our business planning day will also be part of our business on Tuesday 28 June. Do we agree to schedule a planning day for the recess?

Members indicated agreement.

Margaret Mitchell Con The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Before I close the very first meeting of the Justice Committee in session 5, I should say that, at the next meeting on 28 June, we will, in addition to looking at the work programme, consider two negative statutory instruments relating to air weapons licensing and sexual offences legislation.

Meeting closed at 10:53.

  1. 10:30 Interests Procedure · 11
  2. 10:30 Convener Procedure · 5
  3. 10:30 Deputy Convener Procedure · 4
  4. 10:30 Work Programme Procedure · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.