To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03284)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 7
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 3
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
The record
17 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
The First Minister was rightly congratulated on securing the fiscal framework deal that protects the long-term future of the Barnett formula for Scotland. Central to the deal is the principle of no detriment. That principle means that the transfer of financial responsibilities to this Parliament should never leave Scotland worse off. Yesterday’s “Government Expenditure and Revenue Scotland” figures showed that Scotland’s deficit would be twice the size of the United Kingdom’s. Does the First Minister seriously still believe that there would be no detriment to Scotland leaving the United Kingdom?
It is interesting to recall that, in the last year of the previous Labour Government, the United Kingdom’s deficit was £153 billion, which amounted to 10.2 per cent of the UK’s gross domestic product. I maybe just missed Kezia Dugdale telling the then Chancellor of Exchequer, Alistair Darling, that the UK could no longer afford to be an independent country.
The truth of the matter is that countries the world over have deficits. Let us remember this about Scotland’s deficit: it was not created in an independent Scotland; it was created on Westminster’s watch. It is rather strange for any self-respecting politician to argue that we should stick with the system that created the deficit instead of taking more powers into our own hands to do something about it.
Lastly, is it not so typical of Labour that we hear nothing about the strong Scottish economy and its underlying strength? I will leave Labour to do what Labour loves best, which is to knock Scotland; I will get on with the job of building this country up.
Presiding Officer, that was about as convincing as Brian Souter’s tax return. The First Minister is in complete denial.
Hear, hear.
Members: Oh!
Order.
It is just 24 hours since the First Minister’s own figures devastated the case the independence and she wants to carry on as though nothing has happened. The economic case for independence has always been dubious, but even her former adviser, Alex Bell, tells us today that it “is now dead.”
The GERS figures do not just raise constitutional questions; they also give us an insight into the Scottish National Party Government’s spending priorities. Investing in education is fundamental to growing the economy, yet the GERS figures showed that the SNP has cut education and training by 10 per cent since it took office in 2007. If education is the First Minister’s number 1 priority, why has her Government cut the budget by 10 per cent?
Before I come on to education, which I will do in just in second, is it not worth noting that the better together alliance came alive in that previous question? Is it not the case that all we get from Labour is a miserable talking down of Scotland and its prospects? Let us not forget that, in the years when Scotland’s fiscal position was stronger than the UK’s, Labour still criticised the case for independence. The truth of the matter is that Labour prefers Scotland to be run by the Tories than to have Scotland run by this Parliament. For as long as that remains the case, Kezia Dugdale’s party will remain on political life support.
The GERS figures yesterday actually showed an increase of 1.7 per cent in Scottish education spending between 2013-14 and 2014-15. As we have outlined—[Interruption.]
Order.
As we have outlined, our attainment fund, which is over and above core education budgets and was doubled by the Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy in the budget, will ensure that we do even more to tackle the issues of attainment in our schools.
As I said, I will leave Labour to whinge from the sidelines and knock Scotland. I will get on with building the country up.
The First Minister cannot escape the facts. The figures that I used are hers. She has cut education and training by 10 per cent. I can throw a number at the First Minister and she can throw another one back from the big book of excuses that she has in front of her, but behind all those numbers are people whose lives are being turned upside down by SNP cuts to schools and other vital public services.
Just this week, I spoke with three women who have been directly affected by SNP cuts. One uprooted her whole life to pursue a career in education only now to be told that she will soon be out of a job. Just yesterday, I met a school librarian who was on the verge of tears and begged for my help to save her job. A classroom assistant in Clackmannanshire—the place where the First Minister told me job cuts were exaggerated—told me that she was at a loss to understand the First Minister’s denial of the extent of job losses.
The First Minister says that the figures on education cuts are wrong. Are those three women all wrong as well?
Let me point out the facts to Kezia Dugdale. The average spend per primary pupil has increased by 9 per cent—£411—since the SNP took office. The average spend per secondary school pupil has increased by 11 per cent—£670—since the SNP took office. The average spending per pupil in primary and secondary schools is higher in Scotland than it is in England.
That is the SNP Government’s record, but we are determined to build on that record. That is why we have prioritised education and tackling educational attainment. It is why the finance secretary doubled the funding for attainment in the budget just two weeks ago.
When I speak to people across Scotland, as I do day in and day out, they ask me why, if Labour is sincere about its commitment to education, it voted just two weeks ago against a budget that maintained teacher numbers and doubled the fund for attainment in our schools. That is the question to which people across Scotland want to know the answer.
We voted against a budget that ripped £500 million out of our schools and vital public services. The reality is that we could not believe the First Minister’s figures in 2014 and we cannot believe them today, because people are losing their jobs and the staff who remain face even greater pressure. Our young people will lose out because of the Government’s cuts to education.
For years, the First Minister said that independence was the only way to stop the cuts, but that argument is now dead. Labour has set out a plan to use the powers of the Parliament to stop the cuts but, on the 50p tax, the higher rate threshold and the 1p plan, she has voted it down at each and every turn. If GERS has confirmed that independence is not the answer and the First Minister refuses to use the powers of the Parliament to end austerity, what exactly will she do to stop the cuts?
Actually, if we think back—[Interruption.]
Let us hear the First Minister.
If we think back to the referendum, Kezia Dugdale and her colleagues said to people throughout Scotland that they had to vote no to avoid cuts. Now, they go around Scotland telling ordinary people that their taxes have to go up to pay for the Tory cuts that Labour made us stay subject to. That is the sheer and utter disgrace of the Scottish Labour Party. To add to that disgrace, two weeks ago, Labour voted against a budget that maintained teacher numbers, doubled funding for attainment in schools, and delivered the living wage to social care workers across our country.
Apparently a vote Labour event was held in Edinburgh last night. Kezia Dugdale should read the reports about it because, apparently, her name was not mentioned once in three hours, although speaker after speaker lined up to praise the SNP. If Kezia Dugdale cannot even enthuse her own side of the argument, is it any wonder that she has already resigned herself to coming second in the election in May?
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 10 Mar 2016 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Higher Education (Widening Access Scheme) Questions · 4
- Sex Offenders (Monitoring) Questions · 8
- Higher Education (Funding) Questions · 4
- St John’s Hospital (Children’s Ward) Questions · 4
- Less Favoured Area Support Scheme Questions · 6
- Drugs Strategy Questions · 4
- Flood Mitigation Measures Questions · 4
- Budget 2016 (Oil and Gas Sector) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Domestic Abuse Victims (Rehousing) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Ferry Services First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Visitor Attractions (Visitor Numbers) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Electric Car Rapid Charge Points Members’ business · 20
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Lobbying (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 189
- Lobbying (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 25
- Point of Order Procedure · 3
- Scottish Fiscal Commission Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 43
- Scottish Fiscal Commission Bill Bill debate · 20
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.