The first item of business is consideration of continued petitions, the first of which is PE1319, by William Smith and Scott Robertson, on improving youth football in Scotland. Members have a note from the clerks and copies of the submissions. I welcome Chic Brodie to the meeting. He has shown an on-going interest in the petition, and I invite him to comment.
Official Report · Committee
Continued Petitions
Youth Football (PE1319)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael McMahon Lab 5
- Chic Brodie SNP 3
- Angus MacDonald SNP 2
- John Wilson Ind 2
- Jackson Carlaw Con 1
The record
13 contributionsThank you for allowing me to attend and to speak on the petition. Before I do so, I would like to comment briefly on the letter from the Scottish Professional Football League, which I have just seen. It reflects the answer to a letter that I wrote to the Scottish Football Association and the SPFL about one individual’s transfer and payment, although there are several other cases. The letter states, in paragraph 2:
“We are often told of these payments but, to date, we have been provided with no evidence and it therefore is of great concern to us that there is continuing allegation and innuendo without any actual substantiation.”
I wrote to the SPFL highlighting the name of the individual, whom I will not mention here, in a transfer between two of Scotland’s senior clubs for a sum in the region of £40,000, we believe, of which £8,000 went to an agent. The SFA and SPFL said that they were not aware of that but, lo and behold, the front page of the agent’s website declared that they had registered the individual for whom we sought information. We will go back to them and we will highlight not only that case but the others of which we are aware. It is stretching it a bit far for the SPFL to say that it has
“been provided with no evidence”,
when the agent has declared publicly that the individual has been registered. I have to question the registration competence of the bodies concerned.
That said, I am delighted to be able to address the substance of the petition, and I will be brief. There are two real tests to the petition, which I was happy to speak to before, and I am happy to have been involved with those who brought the petition to us. The most important aspect, reflected in the report by the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland, is the potential exploitation of children, some of whom, I am told, are as young as six years old. The commissioner’s reports are invaluable in opening a window on what he believes is necessary and what he thinks has been happening.
The second important aspect is the outcome for, and the performance of, Scottish football generally. It is not good. Failure at international level, European level and world level is evidence of national performance. The sport is too centralised, takes too much of a short-term view and is skewed toward the larger clubs, and that does not help with the expectations of young people who are brought into that environment. I believe that it needs a major overhaul and reorganisation, with stronger emphasis on Scottish youth. In my opinion, we need only one national organisation to do that, and I have to ask which of the two organisations is truly fit for purpose with regard to the creation of a youth and elite academy that reflects the size of the Scottish population and does not try to emulate a disproportionate level of involvement in an elite academy that is almost equivalent with that of Germany.
The overhaul of young people’s football in terms of the role and qualification of agents must also be considered, particularly with regard to children, and of course there must be emphasis on the role of parents. There should be clear guidelines and penalties for agents, and consideration should also be given to how some parents might be seduced into signing their children up to professional football clubs. There is a wider role for clubs in social and other local sports and community activity.
Lastly, we must ensure that in no way is there a detriment to the education of boys and girls who are involved in trying to fulfil the expectation of being good professional footballers, and in some cases, great professional footballers. That can only be done if football is brought meaningfully to schools, communities and grassroots boys and girls clubs to ensure that we begin again to believe that not only should football be competitive, but also fun for children. Children are not for sale.
On that basis, I support the petition and I applaud the petitioners for lodging it. We ask the committee to consider the appropriate action that the Parliament can take. I have spoken to the Minister for Sport, Health Improvement and Mental Health several times on the matter. Now is the time for action.
Thank you for an interesting speech, Chic. Do members have any comments?
Thanks to the petitioner, the SFA and the SPFL have taken the issues concerning youth football reasonably seriously. The petitioner has stated that the petition is moving the clubs and the governing bodies in the right direction. We have also seen the Children and Young People’s Commissioner say that it is clear that there have been some improvements in the approach taken to children involved in youth football.
However, there are still matters that are outstanding. I note the commissioner’s comment that he no longer believes that the matters that remain outstanding can be dealt with by self-regulation. He recommends that the Public Petitions Committee refers the matter to the Scottish Government to consider how the issues may be dealt with through external regulation. That suggestion was backed by the petitioner.
In light of those responses and taking on board Chic Brodie’s comments this morning, I suggest that the committee close the petition, but also write to the Scottish Government asking for it to consider regulation through legislation to prohibit controls over young people that would not be permissible in any other walk of life, as the petitioner put it.
Unlike Angus MacDonald, I do not think that we should close the petition, although I agree that we should write to the Scottish Government to seek its views regarding regulation. The Children and Young People’s Commissioner has indicated that there are concerns. Having listened to some of the evidence from the SFA and the SPFL, it is clear that they do not seem to be taking the issue as seriously as the general public and the petitioners do.
It is only right that we write to the Scottish Government seeking its views on the matter and that we include that as part of our legacy paper for the next committee. There are still issues that need to be addressed. Hopefully our successor committee will get some response from the Scottish Government about what action it will take.
Too often we hear about self-regulation not being regulation at all. If organisations such as the SFA and the SPFL are not prepared to regulate or accept and acknowledge that there are some issues out there in relation to youth football, we must consider a form of regulation that encompasses and protects those young people and their families from what could be seen as abuse by unscrupulous agents or clubs.
I am also minded to keep the petition open and include it in our legacy paper. The SFA and the SPFL are entities in their own right and like any other commercial organisations they have the right to make rules to govern themselves. Equally, they take public money and they recently asked the Scottish Government to contribute to initiatives that they have been pursuing. They cannot have it both ways; they cannot make the argument that they are of such cultural and sporting importance that the Scottish Government has a responsibility towards them, but then say that they do not have any responsibility to act in a way that those who represent the general public would consider to be appropriate.
They have not been pushing hard against having a discussion around the matter and they have indicated that they would be prepared to sit down in a round-table discussion. We could suggest to the successor committee that it could pursue such a round-table discussion. It could see whether any constructive discussions could be had, leading to some consensus being achieved as to how to go forward.
11:15
Convener, Mr Brodie will be able to testify that the SFA and SPFL resisted the first attempt to get them to a meeting of the Public Petitions Committee. They felt that they were not accountable to the Scottish Parliament for their actions. Although I agree that it might be useful to invite them to a future committee meeting, I advise any successor committee to look back at the initial responses from the SFA and the SPFL to the original invitation. It took some persuasion to get those two bodies to sit in a committee meeting to discuss and answer some of the issues that were raised by the petitioners. I just wanted to make you aware of the fact that they have given evidence in the past but they did so reluctantly.
I had meetings at Hampden Park with the SFA and the SPFL. Some encouraging things are happening in Scottish football. For example, fans’ involvement in the role of Hibs and Hearts in widening the involvement in the franchise is encouraging, but that is at the senior level.
The need for an evidence base was reiterated at the meeting at Hampden. I think that that evidence has been produced but having a round-table discussion and certainly continuing the petition with that information and with the involvement of parents would be good. Parents have come to me with problems that they were having with the major clubs in Scotland and the impact that it was having on their children’s education. There is the binding “contract” in relation to how the parents have signed up children to be involved and they are tied very much to one specific club, hence the issue that we raised about transfer fees.
I would be encouraged if the petition were to carry on as part of the legacy paper and if a round-table discussion was held, certainly with more evidence than we had the first time. Perhaps the committee could bring in parents who would be willing to comment on their experience of what happens.
It would be for the next committee to determine what to do but we can certainly suggest that it considers such an action if we keep the petition open. I take on board John Wilson’s request to write to the Government and get a response in relation to that specific point. I think that we can do both. Do members agree?
Members indicated agreement.
If the general consensus of members is to keep the petition open and to include it in the legacy paper, I am content with that, so long as John Wilson’s suggestion about writing to the Scottish Government is included.
With regard to a further evidence session, clearly we have tried that in the past. However, Chic Brodie’s suggestion that parents should be part of that round-table discussion is certainly a good one if we are going to go down that route because it is good to hear straight from the horse’s mouth, as it were.
I reluctantly concur with the consensus to keep the petition open. It has been going since 2010 and I am not sure that we will make any significant further progress as a committee at all. That is my view. However, I note what the commissioner says, which is summed up in John Wilson’s recommendation that we ask the Scottish Government whether it has any will to intervene. I agree to keep the petition open on that basis.
That is a fair enough point to make. I think that there is a consensus that we will try to keep the petition open and try to pursue it a bit further. I thank Chic Brodie for his contribution.
Thank you for allowing me to speak, convener.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 Mar 2016 →- 11:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 13
- 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
- 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
- 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
- 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
- 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
- 11:30 Annual Report Committee business · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.