Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Modification of Schedules 2 and 3) Order 2016 [Draft]

Tuesday 1 March 2016 Education and Culture Committee About 12:30–12:45 Subordinate legislation 31 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

31 contributions
Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Agenda item 4 is an evidence-taking session on two further pieces of subordinate legislation. I welcome back Aileen Campbell, the Minister for Children and Young People, and her accompanying officials. After taking evidence on the orders, we will move to agenda item 5 and debate the motions, which are in the minister’s name. I should also note officials are not permitted to contribute to the formal debate.

The orders under discussion were covered in the minister’s remarks on the previous subordinate legislation. Do members have any questions?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I was not on the committee during the passage of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill. However, my colleague Liz Smith was, and at the time, she raised some concerns about the implementation of the part of the bill under discussion.

We cannot ignore the SPSO’s concerns. The previous pieces of subordinate legislation will be implemented in 30 days; however, as the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Part 4 and Part 5 Complaints) Order 2016 will be implemented in August, we seem to have a six-month window of opportunity that I hope can be used to make changes that deal with the ombudsman’s concerns.

I am sure that the minister is familiar with the ombudsman’s concerns. He asks for a “simpler approach”—the approach that is currently being used to modernise social work complaints—to be adopted, and he says that if the order were to go through, it could take up to eight years for it to be changed by Parliament, which is something that he probably knows from previous experience. It is therefore obviously better to try to change it within the next six months.

I note, too, that the ombudsman says:

“it would be remiss of me not to note that this particular legislative approach of creating the detail of complaints processes through regulations is now out of line with other areas”.

He also emphasises his

“support for the Government’s aim of aligning the complaints procedure in this order with the model CHP in operation across the public sector.”

I am simply asking the minister to take into account the concerns that the ombudsman has raised in his letter of 23 February to the convener. Given that we have six months until the order will be implemented, such a request does not seem unreasonable. The ombudsman also suggests bringing the procedures in line with other procedures that are already out there, which seems a very sensible approach. Can the order be delayed so that we can look at it again and use the time prior to implementation to take on board what appears to be a very reasonable request by the ombudsman, who has more experience of complaints procedures than anyone around this table?

12:45

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

We have been working closely with the SPSO since the passage of the 2014 act. At the time, all parties agreed to amendments that I moved that left it to ministers to set out these measures in secondary legislation, and we have been working hard to ensure alignment with current complaints policies.

However, given the amendments that were agreed to by everyone in 2014, this particular complaints procedure starts from a different place. It is important to note that the 2014 act places responsibilities on Scottish ministers to develop and implement a complaints procedure for parts 4 and 5 of the act and sets out the issues that we might want to take forward in secondary legislation. That is what I said that we would do, and that is what I have done and what I am bringing to the committee today.

As I have said, we have worked hard with the SPSO. We have taken on board the concerns and issues that have been raised and have tried to ensure that the order that we have set before the committee aligns with other complaints procedures and puts in place something that is clear and transparent and which allows families to access redress if they need to.

I urge the committee not to delay in taking forward the order and to be cognisant of the fact that, even though there is a six-month period before implementation, such a delay would, given the parliamentary timetable, put some pressure on our meeting the August deadline.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

My question is pretty much on the same point. The minister fairly reminds us of the collective will of Parliament in passing the 2014 act; in fact, it might have been remiss of the ombudsman not to highlight at that stage concerns about the process that was being adopted. Nevertheless, we have been presented with a suggestion that the complaints process that is being put through in the order is, as Mary Scanlon says, out of line with procedures in other areas of the public sector. Although six months is not an enormous amount of time, it might be prudent for the committee to at least allow some of that time to be used to establish whether there is a way of bringing the complaints process in the 2014 act into line with other practice. It might be that adhering to the views expressed in the 2014 act remains the desired outcome, but it seems to me that the ombudsman has made a fair and reasonable point and that, with the time available, we might as well explore it in a little more detail.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Do you have anything to add, minister?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Bearing in mind that what we have put before the committee today is as reflective as possible of existing complaints processes, procedures and routes, I am concerned that if we change that as per the ombudsman’s suggestion, we might have to change the act that we passed, which would put the onus on Scottish ministers to come forward with measures on the parameters within which people could make complaints. I hesitate to call that desirable. In fact, in direct contrast, I urge the committee to consider agreeing to the motion on the order, as not doing so would put in jeopardy the existing August starting date.

The SPSO has said in a recent media statement that this is a “technical” and “minor” concern. We therefore have something that aligns with existing complaints procedures, and we think that we have mitigated the ombudsman’s concerns.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

The minister is being perfectly reasonable, and the ombudsman is being perfectly reasonable. Obviously, there are concerns about the volume of legislation that is introduced through secondary legislation. We have an opportunity to come back to the issue, given that there is a six-month period before implementation and that we have more committee meetings before we rise for purdah. Would it be reasonable for the committee to request further discussion between the ombudsman and the Scottish Government and for us to reconsider the matter at one of our meetings later this month?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Hold on a second—Mr McArthur is speaking.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I am simply asking whether we have an opportunity to come back to the matter before the end of this session and agree to the order then. I do not think that the minister is being unreasonable in what she is suggesting. If it transpires that the ombudsman is correct in what he is saying but that the issue should have been raised in evidence to us during the passage of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill, we will just proceed as proposed by the Scottish Government. However, if we have an opportunity to align this better with the complaints processes in other areas of the public sector, it seems remiss of us not to explore that at least.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

The point is that it is aligned. It has been designed and developed to be aligned with existing complaints procedures, and is—

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am sorry, Liam, but please let the minister finish her answer.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

We have endeavoured to make sure that the procedure is aligned with existing complaints procedures; it has been developed in collaboration, conversation and dialogue with the SPSO. If your substantive point is that it is not aligned, I hope that I am giving you some reassurance that what we have in place is transparent and flexible with the potential to be scrutinised by the Parliament, while fulfilling what I set out in my amendments that were agreed to during the passage of the 2014 act, which was supported by everyone in the Parliament. It is an important part of the named person procedure that we give families access to a complaints process, should they need to use it.

James Dornan SNP Glasgow Cathcart
link

No, convener, that is fine. The issue has been covered.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Convener, can I just point out that I am not asking for a delay? Quite often, when we get this kind of legislation, it is already through and we get about 30 days to comment. That is fine but, in this case, we have six months; this particular order is not due to be implemented until 31 August. I want to put it on the record that I am not asking for a delay—I am asking that the six months be used to have discussions with the ombudsman.

My difficulty is that I am no expert on complaints resolution—I am not sure that any of us are. The minister tells us that what is in the order is in line with other complaints resolution processes across the public sector, while the ombudsman’s letter to the convener says that it

“is now out of line with other areas”.

Where we have such a significant difference in opinion, interpretation or whatever, I cannot hand on heart put the order through today. All I am asking is that the six months be used for reasonable negotiations and understanding to be had to ensure that this is right and fit for purpose on the day that it is implemented.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Minister, it is of course a matter for the Government to decide to take the order away, revise it and bring it back.

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

I reiterate that we have developed what is in the order to be in alignment with existing procedures. It avoids the duplication and unnecessary messiness that I think that we all want to avoid. However, the fact is that this is being driven by the 2014 act and the amendments that we moved during its passage, which means that it is being driven in a slightly different way to, say, the social work complaints procedures that others have mentioned.

Regardless of whether we pass the order now or three months down the line, the issue is what we as a Parliament agreed to take forward in the 2014 act. We have developed this to be in alignment with other existing complaints procedures to offer families the opportunity to take forward complaints, should they need to. It delivers the transparency and the commitment that I gave and which we all wanted and shared to ensuring that we deliver for families in this area of policy.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

There are no further questions from members, but I would like to ask a couple myself.

During the scrutiny of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Bill, the committee corresponded with a member of the public who raised concerns about the information-sharing provisions, based on her own experience. Specifically, she wanted to ensure that information shared about a child must be relevant, proportionate and in line with the principles of the Data Protection Act 1998. She also suggested that, in her experience, teachers and healthcare professionals were not properly trained on the DPA and that there was a tendency to share everything without checking or asking whether it was relevant. She also said that professionals do not think to inform parents before sharing information about their child. In light of the correspondence that the committee has received, can you tell us whether disputes about the disproportionate sharing of information or the sharing of irrelevant information fall within the scope for making a complaint?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Yes. Information sharing will be part of the complaints procedure.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Given the comments that I have just made, how will you ensure that decision makers are properly trained to make the correct judgments about what information to share? Do you expect specific guidelines to be introduced at organisational level on the types of information that should be shared?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

Part of the 2014 act is about making sure that the workforce who will be required to be named persons is properly trained in sharing information appropriately. The legislation that we passed two years ago provides a robust framework for sharing information in the most appropriate and proportionate way, avoiding the unnecessary scattergun approach that we had in the past. The legislation strengthens the complaints procedure and, if people feel that there has been a breach, they will be able to take forward a complaint, notwithstanding the local complaints procedure that they can go through before they reach that stage.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Given the concerns that have been expressed in the ombudsman’s correspondence, and which I am sure are shared by other parents, do you agree that it is important to inform parents before information about their child is shared? What more can be done to ensure that that happens? I recognise that that might not be appropriate in some particularly difficult circumstances, but what about outwith such circumstances?

Aileen Campbell SNP Clydesdale
link

The 2014 act says that parents and families should be part of the decision-making process and guidance will ensure that best practice, which is always to work with families on information sharing, is followed. The guidance and the act provide rigour to ensure that families are fully involved with regard to any information that requires to be shared.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you.

We now move to the formal debate on the instruments. I invite the minister to move motion S4M-15464, on the draft Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Part 4 and Part 5 Complaints) Order 2016.

Motion moved,

That the Education and Culture Committee recommends that the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Part 4 and Part 5 Complaints) Order 2016 draft be approved.—Aileen Campbell.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

The question is, that motion S4M-15464 be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Members: No.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

There will be a division.

For

Adam, George (Paisley) (SNP)

Beattie, Colin (Midlothian North and Musselburgh) (SNP)

Brodie, Chic (South Scotland) (SNP)

Dornan, James (Glasgow Cathcart) (SNP)

Griffin, Mark (Central Scotland) (Lab)

Maxwell, Stewart (West Scotland) (SNP)

McArthur, Liam (Orkney Islands) (LD)

Abstentions

Scanlon, Mary (Highlands and Islands) (Con)

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

The result of the division is: For 7, Against 0, Abstentions 1.

Motion agreed to,

That the Education and Culture Committee recommends that the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Part 4 and Part 5 Complaints) Order 2016 draft be approved.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I now invite the minister to move motion S4M-15456, on the draft Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Modifications of Schedules 2 and 3) Order 2016.

Motion moved,

That the Education and Culture Committee recommends that the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 (Modifications of Schedules 2 and 3) Order 2016 draft be approved.—Aileen Campbell.

Motion agreed to.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I suspend the meeting to allow the minister to leave the table.

12:59 Meeting suspended.

13:00 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on these motions that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 10:00 College Reform Evidence session · 157
  2. 12:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 29
  3. 12:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 31
  4. 12:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.