I am grateful to the members of the Finance Committee for their work to date on examining the proposals for a fiscal framework, and in light of yesterday’s announcement to the Parliament I very much welcome this early opportunity to provide further detail to the committee.
Paragraph 94 of the Smith commission report recommended that the devolution of further tax and spending powers to the Scottish Government should be accompanied by an updated fiscal framework for Scotland. It is the framework that will determine how the powers proposed by the Smith commission can be used and so it is as important, if not more so, than the Scotland Bill itself.
My overarching aim has been to ensure that the new fiscal framework is fair and workable, and is in line with the principles that were set out in the Smith commission report. On 7 October, I set out to Parliament the areas where we needed to reach agreement as part of an acceptable fiscal framework. Those were the block grant adjustment for tax, the implementation and on-going costs associated with the devolution of welfare benefits, and securing additional capital and resource borrowing powers.
I have engaged constructively in the fiscal framework negotiations and I met the Chief Secretary to the Treasury on 10 occasions, through the joint exchequer committee. Over recent days, the First Minister and I have continued to work with the United Kingdom Government to secure a fair deal, and we have both discussed the detail of the fiscal framework with the Chancellor of the Exchequer.
As a result of those discussions, significant progress has been made across all the key areas of the fiscal framework, and the committee will know from the First Minister’s supplementary statement to Parliament last night that there is on the table an agreement in principle that I believe we can recommend to Parliament. A draft heads of agreement will be published for scrutiny by Parliament by the end of this week.
We sought a fiscal framework that will give the Scottish Government the flexibility that it needs to create a fair and prosperous Scotland, and the ability to use the powers that we have in an effective way. To get to this point we have all had to compromise. There has been give and take as we worked our way through the deal, but I refused to compromise in one key area: the area of no detriment.
Smith said that the Barnett formula should determine the size of the block grant—that is the benchmark against which we must assess the operation of no detriment. The fiscal framework should not seek to undermine the operation of the Barnett formula as the basis for determining public expenditure in Scotland. Crucially, Smith identified that Scotland’s budget should be no larger or smaller simply as a result of the initial transfer of powers.
We have reached an agreement on the block grant that involves using the UK Government comparability model, which will be configured to deliver the Scottish Government’s preferred option of per capita indexed deduction. Under the proposal there will be not a single penny of detriment to the Scottish Government’s budget as a result of the devolution of powers during the transition period, which will be the six years to March 2022. The UK Government will guarantee that the outcome of the Scottish Government’s preferred funding model, per capita indexed deduction, is delivered in each of those years.
Alongside that there will be a review that will be informed by an independent report, which will present recommendations to both Governments by the end of 2021. The fiscal framework will not include or assume the method for adjusting the block grant beyond the transitional period. The two Governments will be required to jointly agree that method as part of the review, and that must deliver results consistent with the Smith commission’s recommendations, including the principles of taxpayer fairness, economic responsibility and, crucially, the principle of no detriment. That secures no detriment now and for the next six years, and we have ensured that there can be no detriment imposed on Scotland at any point in the future.
We have agreed to increase the Scottish Government’s capital borrowing limits to a cumulative £3 billion, with annual flexibility of 15 per cent of that. That increases our annual capital borrowing facility to £450 million to invest in infrastructure in Scotland and so improve economic performance.
We will receive the powers that are necessary to manage tax volatility and economic shocks by increasing the resource borrowing limits that are set out in the Scotland Act 2012, alongside introducing a new Scottish reserve. The borrowing limit for forecast error will be £300 million per annum, the aggregate annual limit for forecast error and economic shock will be set at £600 million, and the overall resource debt limit will be £1.75 billion.
On implementation and administration costs, we have agreed a one-off payment of £200 million to support implementation costs and on-going funding of £66 million per annum.
The committee will be keen to hear that I have agreed that the Scottish Fiscal Commission will produce the official forecasts of gross domestic product and tax revenues. I will lodge appropriate amendments at stage 3 of the Scottish Fiscal Commission Bill to give effect to those provisions.
That forms the basis of a fiscal framework that is true to the Smith principles. The deal will ensure that the funding for Scotland cannot be changed without the Scottish Government’s agreement. It protects the Barnett formula and will allow the powers in the Scotland Bill to be delivered.
I am acutely aware that not all the detail is in front of the committee today. Once the material has been published this week, I will make every effort to be available to appear before the committee to look at the further detail, if that is the committee’s wish.