I welcome members to the fourth meeting in 2015 of the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee. As usual, I remind everybody to switch off mobile phones, as they affect the broadcasting system. We have received apologies from Cameron Buchanan, so again we have John Scott with us as a substitute.
There is only one item on today’s agenda, which is consideration of a note by the clerk regarding chapter 9B of the standing orders: “Consent in Relation to UK Parliament Bills”. I hope that we can discuss that in short order by keeping fairly well focused.
I do not usually do this, but I am going to exercise my prerogative as the convener to speak first on the matter. I have been wrestling with what Mary Fee has entirely properly brought to us and have come to some personal conclusions that my political colleagues and committee colleagues might or might not agree with. I will just put them out there to see whether they help at all.
I have come to the conclusion that what Mary Fee is trying to do is, in a sense, restricted and too narrow. Underlying the issue that Mary’s proposal quite properly addresses is the broader issue that, from time to time, the Scottish Parliament will wish formally to inform another Parliament, generally Westminster, of a view that we take on a subject that might or might not be within our legislative competence. I offer the example—not for any particular political reason—that if we felt strongly about it, we might wish to make a comment to Westminster about the Scottish Parliament’s view on a defence matter, which would clearly and absolutely be outside our legislative competence. Mary Fee has given us the opportunity to think about the processes by which we might do such a thing.
Paper 1 makes reference to the National Assembly for Wales’s recent activities on a legislative consent memorandum. Indeed, that illustrates that what I am talking about, and what we are wrestling with, is not necessarily a matter just for the Scottish Parliament but is for Wales and Northern Ireland, too. It could even be a matter for the jurisdictions of Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man. I happen to know from a meeting that I had that Guernsey is wrestling with difficulties regarding how its views are dealt with.
My starting position is that Mary Fee has suggested something that I do not think I am willing to support in its present form. However, I think that Mary could be asked—this is entirely for her to consider—to work with the clerk and others on the committee to bring forward a stronger proposal that would be a stand-alone provision that our successor committee in the new parliamentary session might consider. In the meantime, we could consider asking the Presiding Officer to meet or correspond with her opposite numbers in other jurisdictions to establish a Parliament-to-Parliament protocol that would be quite different from what we currently have and which would mean that there would be a formal way in which the Parliaments could inform other jurisdictions of their views on important matters of the day that might or might not be within their competence.
That is merely my thinking on the matter, and it is not set in stone. I am not taking a position on Mary Fee’s proposal; I have just tried to think of where we are in that regard. Having exercised my prerogative, I now resume a position of absolute impartiality in relation to the discussion that we are about to have and invite committee members to address what the clerk has outlined in paper 1. Do you want to start, Mary?