The comments made by the Law Society in its response will be taken into consideration as part of the implementation of the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 2015 and the wider review of criminal legal assistance, which we have committed to carrying out. As part of the review of the legal aid system to achieve a simpler, more efficient system, we have asked the Scottish Legal Aid Board to look at the management and administration of court duty schemes, including fee structures and the required standards of service.
As in any area of legal aid work, we will work with the Law Society of Scotland and justice partners to ensure that the system fairly rewards the work that is required in the round. I emphasise that point. There is a lot of focus on the individual elements of legal aid fees, but we are looking at the overall cost of and payment for taking forward a case on behalf of a client. We want to incentivise practices that promote clients’ best interests and the effective operation of the wider justice system.
We have already made it clear to the Law Society that we plan to work with it and the Scottish Legal Aid Board to review legal aid provisions as a whole in order to achieve a simpler and, I hope, more efficient system. That is the theory at least—it is difficult to deliver in practice. We want to manage expenditure effectively, while maintaining access to justice and ensuring that Scotland has a sustainable legal aid system.
Block fees will feature in that discussion. There are advantages in terms of simplicity for the legal adviser because it cuts down on the bureaucracy and the need to specify the time committed to individual clients. However, we need to have as much evidence as possible to inform that discussion about what the appropriate block fee would be.
Perhaps I can bring in Denise Swanson to talk about the level of discussion that we have had with the Law Society on block fees.