As the convener has rightly pointed out, this is a negative instrument and there have been no motions to annul. I have some points to put on the record for passing on to the cabinet secretary.
The regulations are fine as far as they go, but there is a big gap in that there is no reference to or substantial action on tax dodging. I support the moves by Christian Aid, the Scottish Trades Union Congress, Unison and others to restrict from Government procurement companies that avoid paying tax. I draw members’ attention to my entry in the register of interests, which shows that I am a member of Unison.
It is difficult to ascertain the unpaid tax for the UK, but the estimate from the group that I have just mentioned is that there is around £25 billion in unpaid tax because of aggressive tax avoidance. We probably all want to secure tax justice, and I believe that the regulations before us today have a big gap in that regard.
Europe has had a lot of positive things to say about tackling tax avoidance and I would support Europe-wide tax reporting to ensure that large companies such as Amazon do not get round domestic tax laws. I believe that Scottish firms are losing out because of tax dodging because, unlike multinational firms, they are less able to use aggressive tax avoidance, and we would not want them to do that.
There is clear economic, social and community benefit in companies that want to benefit from the public pound paying their fair share of tax.