To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03217)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 12
- Tricia Marwick 10
- Kezia Dugdale Lab 6
The record
28 contributionsGiven that today is world cancer day, I take this opportunity to thank all our health and social care staff and those in the third sector who work tirelessly to deliver our cancer services. I know that every member in the chamber is acutely aware of the devastating impact that cancer has on people here at home and around the world, and it is therefore important for all of us to mark world cancer day 2016.
Later today, I have engagements to take forward the Government's programme for Scotland.
I associate myself with the First Minister's remarks in their entirety.
Last night, the First Minister voted against Labour's plans to use the powers of this Parliament to stop cuts to education and vital local public services. The Scottish National Party and the Tories stood shoulder to shoulder to impose hundreds of millions of pounds of cuts on schools and communities. That goes against everything that the First Minister has ever told us that she stands for. Last year she said:
“we will use the powers we have in the Scottish Parliament to pursue a different approach”,
and she promised to halt the deeply misguided march to further austerity. Yesterday, she had the chance to stop school budgets being slashed and thousands of people losing their jobs. Why did she not take it?
Presiding Officer—[Interruption.]
Order.
In this chamber, we have a Labour Party that wants to increase taxes for low-income and middle-income earners, and a Tory party that wants to cut taxes for high earners. They are both wrong, and they are as bad as each other.
Last night, I and my colleagues voted against a proposal that would have seen every single person in Scotland who earns above £11,000 a year paying more tax. That is a fact, whether Labour likes it or not. One could argue that, in doing so, I was only following the advice of Kezia Dugdale herself. She stood up at her party conference last October and said that
“A fairer Scotland isn’t one where everyone pays more tax”
and that we must
“stop ... tax rises on working families.”
I will concentrate on protecting—[Interruption.]
Order.
I will concentrate on protecting our vital public services and delivering pay rises for people across Scotland. I will leave the Labour Party to defend why somebody on £11,000 a year should be paying more tax.
Of course, the First Minister did not stand shoulder to shoulder with the Tories in the chamber only yesterday; she was in the newspapers this week using phrases such as “tax grab” and “punitive tax rises”. What about punitive service cuts and punitive job losses? She imposed £500 million-worth of cuts on local communities across Scotland yesterday.
It is always the same with the SNP: “It can’t be done,” and “We don’t have the power”—the same pathetic excuses that we heard when the party was pressed on tax credits.
The reality is this: it can be done, and we have the power. The budget process has a long way to go. We can still stop these SNP cuts to schools. At the stroke of a pen, the First Minister could stop hundreds of millions of pounds-worth of cuts and thousands of job losses. She says that education has been protected, but it was revealed this week that spending on children in our primary schools has been cut by £561 per child since she was re-elected. That is before the latest round of cuts. If she will not stop cuts to local school budgets, how on earth can she claim that education is her priority?
In point of fact, total revenue spending on schools has risen under this SNP Government by at least £208 million, or 4.5 per cent. That is the reality.
However, let us just focus on what Kezia Dugdale is proposing. Local authorities in the next financial year are facing a reduction of £350 million, which is offset by an investment in social care of £250 million. Instead of saying to local authorities, “Let us work together to find a 1 per cent reduction in a budget of £15 billion,” Labour wants to increase tax for every single person in Scotland who is earning more than £11,000. That is the reality.
Let me spell out to Kezia Dugdale what that means to a public sector worker. Someone who is working in our national health service right now—[Interruption.]
Order.
—and earning £21,000 is looking forward to a £100 increase in the minimum pay rise as a result of John Swinney’s decision. That minimum pay rise will go up from £300 to £400 in April. Every single penny of that extra £100 will be taken away by Labour’s proposals. As Gordon Brown once said, there is hardly a nurse, teacher, policeman, or council worker who will not be hit hard by an increase in the basic rate of tax.
Therefore, we will continue to take the decisions—even though the Tories are cutting our budget—to protect our NHS, to invest in social care, to pay a living wage to every social care worker in our country, to maintain teachers in our schools, to invest in attainment and to protect household budgets. I will leave Labour to defend why low-paid workers in this country should pay Labour’s extra tax.
Every one of the arguments that the First Minister just deployed was used by David Cameron at Prime Minister’s questions yesterday—every one of them. It is true.
The First Minister stands there and says that Labour’s plans are unfair and workable. She should explain why union after union has come out over the past few days to say that they are fair, and council leader after council leader has come out to say that they are workable.
In the limelight of the general election, Nicola Sturgeon sent a reassuring message to voters in England. She said:
“We will demand an alternative to slash-and-burn austerity.”
Let us take a look at what one of her old advisers had to say about that today. Alex Bell said—[Interruption.] He is one of their own!
Order. Let us hear Ms Dugdale.
Alex Bell said:
“If you spend your life shouting ‘fire, fire’, at some point you have to use the extinguisher. If not, then you just look like an arsonist.”
The First Minister, who built her celebrity on being the anti-austerity alternative, is now leading the attack on the only alternative to austerity. [Interruption.] Faced with the choice between using the powers of this Parliament and hundreds of millions of pounds’ worth of cuts, why did the First Minister choose austerity?
Order.
Do you know what? Tax rises on the lowest paid in our society is not—[Interruption.]
Sit down. There is far too much shouting across the chamber. Please let us hear the First Minister, and please let us hear Ms Dugdale.
Tax rises on the lowest paid in our society is not standing up to Tory austerity; it is transferring the burden of Tory austerity on to the shoulders of those who can least afford it.
Kezia Dugdale wants to trade advisers. Well, let me give her one. I was struck by the comment earlier this week by an economist who was commenting directly on Kezia Dugdale’s proposals and who said that she disagreed with them and that tax rises are just “another name for austerity.” That economist was Ann Pettifor. She is a member of Jeremy Corbyn’s economic advisory committee, and that is her view. Labour is not proposing an alternative to austerity but transferring the burden and proposing austerity by another name. We would not—[Interruption.]
Order.
The reality—the reality that Scottish Labour cannot and never will escape—is that we would not be facing Tory cuts right now if it had not campaigned with the Tories to keep us locked into Tory cuts.
I see Iain Gray sitting next to Kezia Dugdale. [Interruption.] Let me remind the people of Scotland what Iain Gray told them before the referendum: if Scotland was independent, John Swinney would have to increase taxes. Thanks to Labour, the Tories are in charge of our budget and now we have Labour proposing an increase in taxes. They are an utter disgrace. [Interruption.]
Kezia Dugdale. [Interruption.] Ms Dugdale. [Interruption.] Let us hear Ms Dugdale.
Experts from the University of Stirling, the Institute for Fiscal Studies, the House of Commons library and the Scottish Parliament information centre all say that Labour’s policy is fair because the poorest are protected and the richest pay the most. That matters, because Nicola Sturgeon has built her career on telling us that more powers would mean fewer cuts but she refuses to use the powers that she has when it really matters. She has staked her reputation on improving education but she cuts school budgets rather than using those powers. She has sold herself as the radical alternative to Tory austerity but yesterday she sold out the people who needed her the most.
This is the week that Nicola Sturgeon was found out. People throughout Scotland are left asking why, with all her power, the First Minister could not just do the right thing.
There is a difference here. It is clear that Kezia Dugdale thinks that making somebody who earns £11,000 a year pay the price of Tory austerity is the right thing to do. I do not; I think that giving those people a pay rise and getting them on to the living wage is the right thing to do.
Kezia Dugdale says that her proposals are fair. She cannot explain the detail of her proposals, as we saw very clearly from Jackie Baillie. Apparently, the rebate, which is a total con, has all been worked out. I do not even know whether Kezia Dugdale knows how much it costs to administer housing and council tax benefit schemes every year. [Interruption.]
Order.
A scheme that caters for half a million applicants costs £41 million, yet Labour expects us to believe that a scheme that would have to deal with a million applicants will cost £1 million. It is absolute incompetence.
Kezia Dugdale says that her proposals are fair. Under Labour’s proposals, the amount of tax that I pay would go up by 2.7 per cent, but the amount of tax that a nurse, a teacher or a care worker would pay would go up by 5 per cent. That is not fair in the slightest. [Interruption.]
Order.
I leave Labour to argue for tax rises for the low paid to compensate for the Tory cuts that they kept us locked into. I will continue to argue for fairness, pay rises and the protection of our public services. That is the difference between us.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 4 Feb 2016 →- Mental Health Patients (In-patient Facilities) Questions · 6
- NHS Lanarkshire (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Scotland’s Schools for the Future Programme Questions · 6
- Common Financial Tool (Personal Independence Payments) Questions · 4
- Medical and Home Care (Older People) Questions · 4
- Major Trauma Centres Questions · 6
- Scottish Strategy for Autism Questions · 4
- NHS Lothian (Chair and Chief Officers) Questions · 4
- Flooding (Barnett Consequentials) Questions · 8
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 28
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Drug Assessments (Review) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Breast Cancer First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fiscal Framework (Discussions with United Kingdom Government) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- New Global Goals Members’ business · 6
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Carers (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 94
- Carers (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 30
- Alcohol (Licensing, Public Health and Criminal Justice) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 41
- Decision Time Decision time · 5
- Correction Procedure · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.