Thank you, convener. I am grateful for the opportunity to address the committee in respect of the motion that was lodged by the Deputy First Minister on 9 December 2015.
The UK Enterprise Bill was introduced in the House of Lords on 16 September 2015 and is progressing through the UK Parliament. The bill includes a wide range of measures that are aimed at promoting economic growth and the UK Government expects it to remove what it regards as unnecessary impediments to business.
The majority of the provisions in the bill are reserved to the UK Parliament. What we are concerned with today are those provisions that fall within the devolved competence of the Scottish Parliament and that require a legislative consent motion to allow the UK Parliament to legislate on those matters. The LCM covers two areas: the establishment of a small business commissioner and the capping of public sector exit payments.
I will outline briefly each of those areas. The UK Government intends to establish, as a statutory appointment, a small business commissioner with powers to offer advice, guidance and a complaints service to small businesses. The UK Government’s aim is to tackle poor payment practice across the UK whereby a small business is subject to unfavourable contract conditions yet is keen to maintain that vital commercial relationship with a larger company.
Extending the provisions to Scotland will place Scottish businesses on an equal footing with those across the UK. Payment practices that disadvantage small businesses are a common complaint, and the small business commissioner offers an opportunity to address those issues that are a challenge for many of Scotland’s small businesses that do business across the UK. My officials are in discussion with the UK Government to ensure that Scottish interests and delivery processes are represented as the UK Government develops regulations for operational procedures. The proposal is seen as generally welcomed by the small business community and as adding to existing mechanisms. The provision falls within devolved competence because it affects business support policy. Therefore, the consent of the Scottish Parliament will be required to extend the measure to Scotland.
The second measure outlined in the LCM is the provision of regulation-making powers for Scottish ministers in respect of the cap on public sector exit payments. The UK Government intends to limit public sector exit payments to a maximum of £95,000. The measure provides for Scottish ministers to make similar regulations in respect of devolved Scottish public bodies. It would be for Scottish ministers to determine whether and how they wanted to take forward such proposals.
My officials have sought views on the measure across the Scottish public sector and trade unions. Most respondents were in favour of ensuring that proper consideration could be given to Scottish circumstances should there be any prospect of such a cap being introduced but commented that the UK proposals were overly prescriptive.
Ministers therefore have an idea of the range of issues and concerns but have not made any decision as to how the cap might apply to devolved Scottish public bodies. We have committed to consulting fully before making regulations to enact the power, including on such issues as exemptions from the cap and the delegation of decision-making powers.
In his correspondence with the UK Government in October 2015, the Deputy First Minister indicated his support for those measures, subject to two revisions: first, that the £95,000 figure be unspecified in the bill, as Scottish ministers want to have full flexibility over the powers to set the level of any cap from the outset as well as to vary it; and, secondly, that the delegated authority be extended to allow Scottish ministers to make regulations around the capping of public sector exit payments in relation to civil servants working for the Scottish Government. Both those revisions would be more consistent with the devolution of responsibilities for public sector pay, terms and conditions and exit payments.
Her Majesty’s Treasury officials finally offered a response last Friday. They are clear that Scottish ministers could determine their own level of exit payment caps and, if they chose a different figure, that figure could be set out in the Scottish regulations from the outset. From a presentational viewpoint, it may have been better if there had been something express in the bill. However, legally, the position is fine and we are content.
In relation to the issue of Scottish civil servants in the Scottish Administration being covered by the UK regulations, although the Cabinet Office has already delegated to Scottish ministers authority over terms and conditions and voluntary severance, the power to make regulations in relation to those civil servants remains with UK ministers. HM Treasury officials have not said whether they intend to provide that delegation now, although it remains something that could be done at any time. We will continue to press them on the issue.
The potential benefits to the Scottish public sector of ministers holding regulation-making powers are such that we would want to progress the LCM even if UK ministers were not content to agree the points that were raised in the Deputy First Minister’s letter. The Scottish Government recognises that the current position on voluntary severance may not always provide the best outcome for the Scottish public sector, and the powers that are proposed under the bill provide sufficient flexibility to allow them to be adapted to suit the Scottish public sector landscape. Once the regulation-making power was vested in Scottish ministers, it would be for the Scottish ministers to determine whether and how they wanted to take forward such proposals. The provision will affect the executive competence of Scottish ministers, and the consent of the Scottish Parliament will therefore be required to extend the measure to Scotland.
On 14 October 2015, an amendment to repeal the Green Investment Bank provisions of the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013 in support of privatisation was introduced to the bill. Given the lack of consultation and reassurance on that privatisation process and the UK view that no Scottish legislative consent was required, the in-principle support for the Enterprise Bill that was offered to the UK Government in early October 2015 was rescinded until further notice. Following constructive dialogue between the UK and Scottish Governments, reassurances were received from the Secretary of State for Business, Innovation and Skills and from Lord Smith of Kelvin, the chair of the Green Investment Bank, in relation to the protection of the “green” purpose of the bank and the importance of the bank’s Edinburgh headquarters and employees. All correspondence on the matter has been made available to the Parliament. On that basis, the strategic decision was taken not to pursue an LCM in relation to amendments concerning the Green Investment Bank, and the previously expressed in-principle agreement to provide legislative consent was reinstated.