PE1501 and PE1567 are on investigating unascertained deaths, suicides and fatal accidents. PE1501 requests that an inquiry be held where a death is determined to have been self-inflicted or accidental following a suspicious-death investigation. PE1567 asks for a change in the law and procedures in investigations of unascertained deaths, suicides and fatal accidents. We are taking the petitions together because they appear to make similar requests. Both petitions come from family members of persons who died suddenly, and the families are not satisfied with how the deaths were investigated.
In late December, the clerk received communication from the petitioner on petition PE1567, which has been circulated to members. It contains a heart-rending description of the death of a young man. I have every sympathy for the mother of that young man, as—I am sure—does the whole committee.
When we considered the petitions previously we agreed to write to the Lord Advocate, and asked him for additional information regarding the safeguards that are currently in place to ensure that investigations into deaths by the police or procurators fiscal reach robust and sound conclusions. We also asked what powers families have to question the outcomes of such investigations.
The Lord Advocate’s response, which is attached at annex A, to some extent reiterates information that we have already received. However, it also includes reference to the new charter for bereaved families, which sets out the different stages of an investigation process and confirms what information will be provided to bereaved families and when. Page 4 of the Lord Advocate’s letter also outlines the review and complaints processes that are open to bereaved families who are disappointed with an investigation. However, that is not the more formal process that the petitioners appear to be asking for; the Lord Advocate makes it clear that he is not contemplating any major legal changes in this area.
I seek members’ views on the petitions. Options are set out on page 7 of the clerk’s paper.