Before we begin, Presiding Officer, I wish you, your staff and everyone in the chamber a very merry Christmas and a happy new year.
To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03130)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
Before we begin, Presiding Officer, I wish you, your staff and everyone in the chamber a very merry Christmas and a happy new year.
To ask the First Minister what engagements she has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-03130)
I also wish you, the Parliament and the people of Scotland a very merry Christmas. I bring with me an early Christmas present for the Opposition: I am losing my voice.
Later today, I have plans to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
For many people, the Christmas holidays are a chance to look back and reflect. One year ago today, the First Minister visited Castleview primary school, not far from here. She pledged that, under her Government, “no child” would be “left behind”. However, after nearly nine years in power, she will find that the gap between the richest and the rest remains as stubborn as ever.
In his budget yesterday, John Swinney announced massive cuts to the local councils that pay for our schools and are key to the education of our children. The Convention of Scottish Local Authorities estimates that 15,000 jobs will be lost as a result of yesterday's budget. Can the First Minister tell us how many of those job losses will come from our schools?
Yesterday’s budget settlement was a tough one for local government—I make no bones about that. However, I want to put it in context. The net revenue reduction for local authorities next year will be £320 million. That amounts to a reduction of 2 per cent in the total expenditure of local authorities. It is a challenging settlement. However, that does not take account of the additional allocation that the Deputy First Minister announced yesterday of £250 million for social care. Previously, of course, it has been the sole responsibility of local authorities to fund social care. That is no longer the case. The national health service will now share that responsibility and, next year, will invest an additional £250 million in it.
Of course, the figures for the core budget of local authorities also do not take account of the additional £33 million that was announced by the Deputy First Minister yesterday specifically to tackle attainment and the attainment gap in our schools.
Yesterday, we set out the choices that we are making in the budget. The total Scottish budget will, over the next few years, decline as a result of cuts from Westminster, but we have set out our priorities, which I will be proud to take to the Scottish people.
If Kezia Dugdale wants to prioritise different things, she has an obligation to say exactly what those alternative priorities would be and—perhaps more important—to say where the money for those priorities would come from.
Our councils are central to the education of our children, but John Swinney’s budget pulled the rug out from under them. The reality is that Nicola Sturgeon cannot guarantee that the budget will not result in job losses for our specialist teachers, classroom assistants, janitors and office staff.
This week, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development published a sobering report on the state of education in Scotland. The rest of the world is catching up with us, and is overtaking us in maths. Furthermore, yet again, the poorest children continue to be left behind. The report warned against a scattergun approach to education, so let us see how that £33 million is being spent.
A few weeks ago, I visited two schools in one building; Cochrane Castle primary school and St David’s primary school in Johnstone share a joint campus. The pupils use the same gym hall, the same dining hall and the same playground. Many of them come from the same streets. However, only one of those schools gets money from the Scottish Government’s attainment fund. One school gets funding to close the gap, but the other is left behind. Does the First Minister agree that that is just not fair?
If she has not already done so, I encourage Kezia Dugdale to read the OECD report in its entirety. If she does so, she will find that it has many positive things to say about Scottish education. For example, it says that we are above the international average when it comes to science and reading; it says that Scottish education is on an “upward trend of attainment”—I think that that is a direct quotation; it says that our schools are inclusive and it says that young people are positively engaged with education.
The OECD report also presents challenges to the Scottish Government and to everybody who cares about education. It praises curriculum for excellence and says that it is “at a watershed”. It endorses the approach that the Government is taking in introducing a national improvement framework with standardised assessment at its heart. Far from how Kezia Dugdale has characterised the OECD report, it is positive and sets out a clear path for further improvement and reform.
I have made very clear my priority when it comes to tackling the attainment gap. The budget that the Deputy First Minister set out yesterday sets aside funds to ensure that we are progressing the work to close the attainment gap. The £33 million that will be invested next year is part of a bigger programme of £100 million that is being invested over and above local authority school budgets to prioritise improvement in attainment. That is the commitment that this Government has made.
I say again to Kezia Dugdale that if she wants to come forward with proposals for the draft budget, suggesting that we spend additional money in any particular area of our responsibilities, she has an absolute entitlement to do so. However, when she does so, she also has an absolute responsibility to tell Parliament and the people of Scotland where in the budget the additional money would come from. I issue her with that invitation.
Scotland used to be able to boast that it had the best schools in the world. Today, the First Minister tells us to be glad that they are “above ... average”. Is that really the extent of our ambition? Under this Government, more than 6,000 children left primary school last year unable to read properly. That is 6,000 children who have spent every year of their primary education under this Government. The new powers that are heading our way give us the power and the chance to do something different; we do not just have to manage Tory austerity as yesterday’s SNP budget does. The First Minister wants a plan, so here is a plan: under Scottish Labour, headteachers would get £1,000 for every pupil from a deprived background. [Interruption.]
Order. Let us hear the member.
We would hand real power to headteachers to decide how to improve the life chances of the children in their schools. It is a plan that would send funds to where they are needed most, and it would end the farce—like that in Johnstone—of two schools on a shared campus not both being entitled to the same support. Will the First Minister make a commitment today to back our plan to use the new tax powers to invest in our young people?
I will point out to Kezia Dugdale what the OECD report said. [Interruption.] I know that Labour members do not like to hear this kind of thing. The report said that, based on the action that the Government is taking through progressing with curriculum for excellence, the new national improvement framework and the introduction of our evaluation and assessment, Scottish education has the potential to become a world leader. That is what the OECD report says. I know that Labour members do not like that because it talks up the potential of Scotland, but it is a fact.
I invited Kezia Dugdale to put forward alternatives, but I also invited her to say where the money would come from. Unless she is going to tell me in her next question where, in the draft budget, the money to fund the proposal that she has just outlined to Parliament will come from, she does not deserve to be treated as though she has any credibility whatsoever.
Yesterday, the Deputy First Minister put forward a fully funded plan to tackle the attainment gap in Scottish education. That is the reality. Kezia Dugdale says that we should use the new tax powers. I ask her to give us a straight answer to this question. Is she saying that, next year, through the draft budget, the Scottish Government should put up the basic rate of income tax? That is a simple question. Let us hear a yes or no answer.
This really gets to the nub of the matter, because—[Interruption.] Yeah. Wait for it. [Interruption.]
Order.
The First Minister tells us that she is a progressive, but every single time she is offered a progressive tax, she votes it down. She has done it four times in this chamber. I will tell her what is not credible. It is governing with a budget one year at a time, with no plan for the future, which is what this Government is doing.
It is clear from yesterday’s budget that this Government’s commitment to ending austerity does not extend much beyond the odd press release. The OECD last reviewed Scotland’s education system in 2007. Since then, the SNP Government has cut the number of teachers by 4,300, the number of qualified teachers in our nurseries has fallen and the gap between the richest and the rest remains as wide as ever. What is the SNP’s response to all that? It is to cut, cut and cut again. Why does this SNP Government appear to be content to let the next generation pay the price of austerity?
Kezia Dugdale said something correct in that last question—we are getting to the nub of the matter. On progressive taxes, as soon as John Swinney had the power, he introduced the progressive land and buildings transaction tax. Yesterday, he outlined plans to raise £130 million in additional revenue from business rates.
Here is the nub of the matter, though. Next year, the only way we could raise extra revenue from income tax would be to raise income tax at the basic rate and for the lowest-paid people in our society. Everybody who watches First Minister’s question time will have seen Kezia Dugdale, when faced with it, duck the question completely. That is the nub of the matter. [Interruption.]
Order.
Labour wants to tell us what it disagrees with, but when it comes to putting forward funded alternatives, Kezia Dugdale and Labour simply run for cover.
We have made our choices in the budget. Those choices are to protect the national health service, to protect social care, to protect educational attainment, to protect colleges, to protect university research and free tuition, to protect the police, to protect free personal care, to protect household budgets and to protect against Tory cuts through the welfare fund and by mitigating the bedroom tax. If the Opposition wants to make different choices, let it tell us what those choices are and—for once—let it tell us where it is going to get the money.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.