Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

National Waste Management Plan for Scotland Regulations 2007 (Draft)

Tuesday 6 March 2007 Environment and Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 43 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

43 contributions
Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The second affirmative instrument is the draft National Waste Management Plan for Scotland Regulations 2007. Motion S2M-5621, in the name of the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Ross Finnie, invites the committee to recommend to the Parliament that the draft regulations be approved. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the draft regulations and has not raised any points on them. Before we come to the debate on the motion, we will have a short session to clarify any purely technical matters and allow for any explanation of detail while an Executive official is at the table. I invite the minister to introduce his official and to make any opening remarks.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

I am joined for the discussion on the draft regulations by Simon Stockwell, from the Executive's waste strategy team. The draft regulations require Scottish ministers to have a national waste management plan that sets out policies in relation to the recovery and disposal of waste in Scotland. They lay down that, when we prepare and amend the national waste management plan, we need to comply with public participation procedures as laid down in the EU public participation directive.In line with the directive, the draft regulations also state that we do not need to comply with the public participation procedures contained in the regulations if the plan is being made for the sole purpose of national defence or civil emergencies, or—and I stress the importance of this—if we carry out a strategic environmental assessment. In practical terms, we would expect the national waste management plan and any amendments to it to be subject to a strategic environmental assessment, which would itself include public consultation.The draft regulations also place the duty to have a national waste management plan on the Scottish ministers, unlike the current position, which is that the Scottish Environment Protection Agency has responsibility for preparing a national waste strategy. I should make this important distinction: it is important for us, as Scottish ministers, to be responsible for the policy, which does not mean that we do not have access to SEPA's expertise, including in drawing up the policy. Indeed, as SEPA is the regulatory body, it is likely that it will bring out the policy. We are not suggesting that its expertise should be cut off; we are simply saying that responsibility for the plan and the policy should be vested in ministers. Regulation 3(6) lays down that existing documents, including the national waste plan and the national waste strategy, continue to have effect as the national waste management plan until they are replaced or amended by Scottish ministers. Responsibility will then transfer, but the existing documents will remain in effect until then. As I said, there will be public consultation and participation, the only exemption being when a plan is made for defence or civil emergency reasons.

Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I invite members to ask questions or request any points of clarification.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have one or two points to make about the evidence from the people who were consulted. Did the evidence contain any theme with regard to how the waste management strategy should be managed? Are there any overwhelming concerns about the process of consultation and the consultees' remarks?

Simon Stockwell Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

Two overriding themes emerged from the consultation responses: first, a need was identified for clarity on SEPA's future role in the national waste management plan; and a second need was identified for clarity with respect to the Executive itself having sufficient resources to implement the plan.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Were those comments published on the web or are they in hard copy only?

Simon Stockwell Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

They are in hard copy only at the moment, in the Executive's library in Saughton House.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

On the Executive's approach to working up the plan, how have you assessed the suitability of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department and its staff for taking over what is a major duty?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

The lengthy and detailed discussions about the form and structure of the original national waste plan and strategy and the area waste plans, which came together to form the national waste plan, took place at stakeholder meetings that I chaired. Other organisations were represented, but the proposals were largely supported by representatives of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. Essentially, we are dealing with responsibility for implementing the statutory requirement to collect, which lies with local government. The detailed expertise on certain aspects was provided by SEPA. A series of extensive meetings were held, largely under my chairmanship, regarding the structure, purpose and possible requirements of the area waste plans and related issues. We drew up the national waste plan and the provisions that allowed local authorities to do the work, but the detailed expertise was provided jointly by SEPA and local authorities.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

There are two aspects that I would like to take a little further. I was involved with area plans and so on at a local level as a stakeholder, before my election. People do not always get what they want, or even what the majority want. Modifications are made to plans, which can be somewhat unfortunate if there is a different and overwhelming local view. It could be suggested that you are amalgamating information from local authorities and that your approach is merely to take that information and try to use it in future. Given people's experience of the previous process, what ability will they have at a local level to affect the way in which the national plan is to be developed?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

The motivation behind the area waste plans was in no way to prevent or prohibit local councils or members of the public from contributing fully to their development. How that work was carried out by local authorities is a matter for them. The area waste plan structure came about as a result of the working group's recognition that, as a consequence of the previous system of collecting biodegradable municipal waste—which was perhaps one of our most efficient systems in economic terms, although it was one of our most disastrous in environmental terms—local authorities had almost no infrastructure in relation to waste collection, save for the wheelie bins, wheelie bin collection vehicles, transfer stations and larger vehicles to take waste to landfill. There were also issues to do with local authority expertise, given that the system was relatively simple.The area waste plans were, therefore, an attempt to assist local authorities and were widely discussed with COSLA. At a strategic level, they endeavour to do two things. First, they should ensure that there is no unnecessary duplication across Scotland of reinvestment in equipment and so on. Secondly, they should help local authorities to build up in-house expertise in a different system of collection management. The area waste plans, and the national waste plan that followed them, were an attempt not to stifle, but to assist local authorities, especially in the purchase of the necessary equipment for a completely different system of waste management.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have a final question on this point, and a separate one about the process.

Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Other members still want to ask questions.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

That is all that I intend to ask. We are talking about £1 billion being spent between now and 2020. It is a bit different from the tail-docking issue—it is quite big financial stuff.Given the fact that the minister had an overview in drawing up the waste plans, did the inclusion of waste-to-heat as an alternative to landfill, rather than something that was just the responsibility of local authorities, come from the top down?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Waste for heat was always an issue. Some local authorities—at least, Dundee City Council—had already constructed a heat-from-waste plant before the plan was finalised. The group that put together a strategic view on the area waste plans considered evidence of the very different performances of mainland European states and other member states in reducing, reusing and recycling. That evidence showed that even the best-performing of those states had taken advantage of quite modern techniques of producing heat from waste. That was always considered as part of the plan.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have a small question about the process. Internally, within the department, it has taken a while to get the programme to the stage that it is at. What external assessment has been made of the process that you are going through? Has there been more than one external assessment?

Simon Stockwell Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

We have regular gateway reviews of the process of implementing the national waste plan, involving people within the Executive and an external consultant interviewing some of the key stakeholders, such as local authorities, SEPA and the private waste industry. Somebody from Friends of the Earth or WWF was interviewed the last time, too. That work gives us an update on how we are performing, on what the stakeholders think and on whether there are any recommendations for future changes.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Has the latest of those reviews been successful?

Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Can we move on? Other members are waiting to ask questions.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

My questions will probably be daft-lassie questions, as I found it difficult to understand what the draft regulations were saying. Are we keeping the 11 existing waste areas?

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

Currently, those areas produce their waste plans from the bottom up. Does the national waste management plan take a top-down approach, telling those waste areas what to do?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Scottish ministers are responsible to the Parliament for policy. Therefore, it was anomalous for SEPA to be technically responsible for policy in a major area that has developed in the way that it has developed. I am at pains to point out that I do not want to diminish the role and value of SEPA's expertise in any way, but it is entirely proper to be clear about who should be responsible for the delivery of the national waste management plan and the strategy. The committee tends to call me rather than SEPA to meetings on such matters, which is right. We are trying to remedy a structural anomaly.There are issues to do with having a strategic overview and trying to get the best balance, which largely rests on the expensive capital investment that must be made to transform how waste is gathered and disposed of in Scotland. We have brought about such a transformation in the past four or five years. As I said to Rob Gibson, under the previous system, we completely dismantled almost all the equipment and effectively dismantled the personnel, who had real expertise. We need to build those up. A strategic overview will avoid excessive capacity being put in place or unnecessary joint expenditure by local authorities.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

I am happy with the buck stopping with the minister. I was not clear whether the draft regulations refer to all Scotland's waste or only to municipal waste.

Simon Stockwell Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

They relate to all waste. The national waste plan has, until now, concentrated on municipal waste, although it also covers other waste. The draft regulations cover all controlled waste.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

Were the existing area waste plans only for municipal waste?

Simon Stockwell Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department
link

They had a chapter on non-municipal waste, but they were mainly about municipal waste. We hope to publish a framework on non-municipal waste fairly soon. We recognise that more needs to be done about non-municipal waste, but the plans currently concentrate largely on municipal waste.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

The schedule mentions encouraging"the use of waste as a source of energy"as an objective. Will pressure be put on authorities that do not want to go down that road?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

No. We are clear that the hierarchy of reducing, reusing and recycling waste remains unchanged. We would not want to promote or to support actively any local authority's arguments that it had residual waste that ought to be used for heat recovery unless it could demonstrate that it had met the requirements of the hierarchy.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

Finally, with closer ministerial involvement in waste, can we consider revising some of the sillier definitions of waste?

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

That will depend. We would have to have a more detailed discussion about the matter across the piece. Some definitions of waste are largely the result of slightly older European directives. I am not sure that it is necessarily simply a matter of redefining waste: for example, I have not been persuaded that the definition of waste must be changed as a result of matters that are caught by the animal by-product regulations.There is a powerful case for a new directive in which modern technological developments, whether in transesterification or anaerobic digestion, are specified and which would declassify as waste the product that emerges from waste that is subjected to a specified procedure. That would be an important development, which I would support, as there is a real inhibitor on developing the extent to which certain waste can be recycled.

Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There are no further questions from members, so we move to the debate. I invite the minister to move motion S2M-5621.

Motion moved,

That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft National Waste Management Plan for Scotland Regulations 2007 be approved.—Ross Finnie.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I probed the minister on the process by which the plan was adopted in the department and I was interested to hear about the gateway reviews. However, I was not able to get an answer to my question about the state of play after the most recent review. Was there a glowing report? We are interested in having a Government that takes us forward as strongly as possible. I support the process and am concerned that it should work, so I am interested in hearing answers to other questions. Can the minister share more information with the committee on that aspect of the process? In general, we must believe that the department has the capacity and skills to take the matter fully forward, which is what we have wanted for a long time.

Eleanor Scott Green Highlands and Islands
link

I was most interested, from a political perspective, in the list of objectives for the purposes of the national waste management plan. I am happy about most of the objectives that are listed, but I am slightly concerned that one objective is:"Encouraging … the use of waste as a source of energy."The use of waste as a source of energy should not be an objective; it should be a tool that is available as a last resort for waste that cannot be dealt with in other ways. I was reassured by the minister's comment that the waste hierarchy will continue to underpin our approach, so the inclusion of that objective will not make me vote against the draft regulations. However, I would be concerned if authorities that did not want to use waste as a source of energy were being leaned on to go down that route.

Ross Finnie LD West of Scotland
link

Members should bear it in mind that although we have tried to approach the matter positively by upping the ante on recycling targets and by addressing issues to do with the reduction and reuse of waste, local authorities must comply with the statutory requirements of the landfill directive, concomitant with which is the possibility of strictures on local authorities, which are caught between a rock and a hard place in that regard.We must be satisfied that we are talking about residual waste, after the maximum effort has been made to reduce, reuse and recycle. We have to develop further in that context. The most technically challenging issue in the immediate future is probably food waste. We must not just reduce food waste, for obvious reasons to do with purchasing patterns, we must also address contamination issues, given that a substantial amount—17 per cent, I think—of the current landfill bin is occupied by food waste.Rob Gibson asked about performance but he was, if I might say so, being slightly Delphic, as usual. I am not quite sure whether his probing question was about phase 1 or phase 2. We will not pretend that the process has not been difficult—local authorities have also found the process difficult, for the same reasons. Radical change in the process and pattern of waste collection and distribution has created a requirement for expertise that is simply not in great supply—there is such expertise in Scotland, but it is not hugely developed. The waste industry in Scotland is developing and is very different from how it was during its ghastly history—we do not want to return to those days. There have been difficulties, but there is a review process in the civil service and we are satisfied that we can conduct that. However, I emphasise that, although we wish to take responsibility for the policy, we do not wish to claim a monopoly of wisdom, as we deploy people to implement it.

Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The question is, that motion S2M-5621 be agreed to.

Motion agreed to.

That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft National Waste Management Plan for Scotland Regulations 2007 be approved.

Maureen Macmillan Lab The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I thank the minister for attending. We will now have a short suspension to allow him and his official to leave.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Tuesday 6 March 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 83
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 43
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
  5. Annual Report Committee business · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.