That method has some attractions. Again, to use the language of risk and reward, it takes out the risk of differential population growth because it works on a per capita basis. One could make the case that Scotland does not control immigration policy and therefore does not have the political levers to fully affect the size of Scotland’s population; a case could therefore be made for making per capita adjustments on that basis.
The third method is the so-called levels method, which is the most symmetric as far as the Barnett formula is concerned. As you know, under the Barnett formula, Scotland gets its population share of spending increases in Westminster.
According to the levels method, the block grant adjustment would increase by Scotland’s population share of the increase in tax revenues at Westminster. That is symmetric with the Barnett formula in the following way. If there was an increase in comparable spending of say £100 million south of the border, which was financed by an increase in income tax of £100 million south of the border, the net effect on the Scottish budget would be zero. Scotland would get its population share of the spending increase, which would be offset by its population share of the tax increase. They would be the same—it would be £100 million in each case. There is symmetry there.
The reason why Scotland might well do worse under that method is that Scotland’s per-head level of tax receipts is lower than levels in the rest of the UK. We keep getting adjustments to the block grant adjustment that do not compensate in the same way as the per capita indexed deduction, which is measured over the whole grant, as opposed to the change in the grant.
One way of thinking of it is that the levels method increases the rate of convergence, which we talk about in relation to the Barnett formula. The levels method would increase that rate of convergence towards level spending per head in Scotland and in the rest of the UK, as opposed to the current situation where per capita spending per head is somewhat higher in Scotland than it is in the rest of the UK.