I do not dispute the need for new housing. New housing is not replacing existing housing, except in exceptional cases, but we need it because of population growth and changes in household size. There is a desperate need for new housing for everybody to live in, but the vast majority of the stock that will be here in 2050 has been built—more than 80 per cent of that stock exists.
11:15
You referred to low-hanging fruit, but probably only the lowest of the low-hanging fruit has been addressed. The figures are probably slightly better than you say for lofts and cavities, but we need to consider how to overcome the issues with lofts. A lot of the issues with hard-to-treat lofts are not actually that difficult and are to do with access. Many tenement lofts still have not been insulated, but that is not because of technological difficulties; the issue is engaging with multiple householders. We should make use of the Tenements (Scotland) Act 2004 to get that done. There are lots of practical things that can be done, but we need organising of the market as much as anything to make those things happen.
We have done very little on our pre-1919 stock, but that does not mean that things cannot be done on that stock. The vast majority of tenements and older houses are good housing and there are things that can be done. Historic Environment Scotland is looking at new approaches. There are issues with ventilation in such houses and there are things that prevent double glazing from being put in historic properties, but there are ways of overcoming those issues.
Things can be done that are not all that difficult to do, although they are not quite as easy as insulation of standard lofts or cavities. Those things would not involve a step change in the level of expenditure that is required. Some properties are in such poor condition that we should not consider insulating them and they should not continue to be lived in. That is a very small proportion of houses, but there are some. In particular, some houses have been extended numerous times and have never had proper work done to them. There are things that need to be done.
On your question about valuing energy efficiency, one of the reasons why energy efficiency is not valued and so does not add to the price is that there is so little housing. That is the real difficulty. With rental properties, people just need a house or a flat to rent, and so they cannot put a value on energy efficiency. There are also issues about house prices, which are very much driven by location. If someone could choose between two houses with all the same factors, energy efficiency might come into it but, because of the way that the market currently operates, there are too many conflicting demands and there is not enough supply to allow people to make such choices.
Some of the housing in the private rented sector is in the worst condition. There are real issues about the return that private sector landlords are making from letting substandard housing. We need minimum standards to ensure that, at the point of rent or sale, those properties are brought up to what should be considered as an acceptable level of housing for people to live in. Unless we introduce minimum standards, that is not going to happen. It is not just about energy efficiency. There are issues about disrepair in a lot of our private rented stock. It is the worst stock in Scotland and there is a need to improve it. Given the returns to private landlords and the low interest rates, there is little justification for them to say that they would have to charge higher rents to support that improvement. They can afford to do it and there is a need to ensure that that happens.