I recall sitting in front of the committee in January or February, when the rates had just been announced. The feedback that we had from our members at that time suggested that there was some concern that the rates on the higher end of the market could dissuade people from transacting, which would obviously have an impact on the tax take and could cause stagnation. I also recall mentioning that a fully functional market, with movement up and down the chain, is absolutely key; the concept of the ladder, with people going up and down it, is important. The feedback that we have had from our members in advance of today’s meeting has confirmed that. There has been no comment from our members that their concerns have been found not to have a basis.
The impact of the tax at the top-tier levels, where the higher tax bands come in, has been quite significant. Anecdotally, we are hearing a number of our members saying either that sales have been stalled or that they have not gone through. In our submission, we include feedback that shows how the delays in transactions have impacted on the situation, and statistics that show that there was activity to get sales of higher-value properties completed before the new tax came in, and a delay afterwards.
Also anecdotally, we hear that there has been lots of pressure on developers to help customers to absorb that tax by forms of incentive. Some developers can afford to do that, but others cannot. There is a question about the on-going viability of that assistance.
We have also detected, particularly in the north-east, a combination of “perfect storm” conditions. It is well known that the prices of oil and gas have tumbled. That has had an impact on employment, property prices and the market in general in the area. The uncertainty in the north-east, the new higher tax bands and the loss of the help-to-buy scheme have combined to create very difficult trading conditions in that part of the market.
A quite interesting comment in the editorial on the opening page of a Herald supplement from two or three weeks back caught my eye. It says:
“LBTT is becoming interesting. This week revealed news that business is booming for an upmarket Edinburgh bathroom company as owners in the million-pound plus price bracket opt to spruce up their homes rather than move.”
I am delighted for Mr Ronnie Scott’s bathroom company, but I think that that example shows in a nutshell the behavioural reaction to the tax. I am not saying that people in million-pound properties need assistance, but it is important to point out that purchases at that level are, on the whole, largely discretionary. In lots of instances, people probably do not have to make that move or that purchase.
I will give you an example of the impact of such a decision. If someone who was considering buying a £750,000 property decided to have their bathroom upgraded instead, 81 additional sales at £175,000 would be required to make up for the loss of that tax revenue—in other words, 81 additional sales would be required just to stand still. That brings into focus the high dependency on the high-tax levels, which we think not only is risky with regard to tax take but has a disproportionate impact on higher-value property levels.
I will go back to an earlier submission that we made, in which we argued for smoothing of the tax bands. We think that that would be a far more sensible approach to allocating the tax.