Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”

Wednesday 18 November 2015 Public Audit Committee About 09:00–12:45 Evidence session 1,116 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

1,116 contributions · showing 1–200
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Agenda item 2 is an oral evidence session on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report entitled “The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”. I welcome the first panel of witnesses: Derek Banks, former director of finance, Coatbridge College; and Lorraine Gunn, former director of human resources and board secretary, Coatbridge College.

As we are tight for time, we will move straight to questions. I understand that there are no opening statements.

Mr Banks, will you confirm the period in which you were the director of finance at Coatbridge College?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

From 1 August 2006 until 31 March 2014.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Obviously, during that period, the matter was your responsibility in your role of director of finance. Is that correct?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

In particular, you were the director of finance during the period that the Auditor General referred to.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I was.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Were you responsible for the financial arrangements that surrounded the severance agreements that were reached? Were you ultimately responsible for ensuring that those arrangements were signed off financially?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I was responsible for agreeing that the funds were available, yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So you were personally responsible for the financial arrangements around the severance arrangements for John Doyle, the former principal, in particular.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Will you clarify what you mean by “personally responsible”?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Maybe you want to explain what your role as the director of finance was when such a severance arrangement was put before you on behalf of the board.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

It was only to ensure that the funds were available for that payment to be made.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Okay. So you did not have any responsibility for ensuring that the external and internal auditors were made aware of the arrangements that had been reached for Mr Doyle.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

No. It would have been the responsibility of the audit committee to inform them. The guidance that the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council issued in 2000 clearly states that the accountable officer is charged with informing the auditors of the approach. That would normally be done through the audit committee.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

When the audit committee or whoever reported to you and advised you that a sum of £304,000 had to be paid into the bank account of someone who would very shortly be a former employee, did it never occur to you that you should at least have contacted the internal and external auditors? As an experienced director of finance, would you not have considered that?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

We discussed with the chair of the audit committee, Mr Keenan, our approach to bringing in internal and external audit. It should be borne in the mind that, at the time, the college was merging, and then it was not. Up until 7 October 2013, the college did not believe that it had any liability for any severance payments, because the decisions that were made by the committee back on 28 January 2013 were nullified by Coatbridge College withdrawing from the merger on 25 February 2013. Therefore, there was no liability up until 7 October. The merger management committee met and discussed the severance arrangements, which were brought up under due diligence. At that point, I discussed with Mr Keenan the approach that we should take. By then, Mr Doyle and Mr Gray had already agreed to bring in Biggart Baillie to fulfil the internal audit role, particularly because of its experience in HR and legal issues.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So you were aware of the guidance that was available from 2000. Let us forget about the audit committee arrangements. You were ultimately responsible for signing the cheque to ensure that that money was provided.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

That is not correct.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What was your role as director of finance?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I was not responsible for authorising that payment. Because it was in excess of £250,000, the scheme of delegation meant that it had to be signed off by the board.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So it was signed off by the board. What was your role after the board agreed it? As the director of finance, could you not say, “Look, I think that you should refer this to the internal and external auditors”?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Obviously, I queried the payment with Mr Keenan.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Why did you query it?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Because of Mr Laurence Howells’s attendance at the 23 October board meeting. After that meeting, I asked Mr Keenan whether I should stop the payment, because I was aware that it would be made on 25 October. I was told not to stop it because the committee had agreed it.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So on the basis that Mr Keenan was the acting—

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

He was the newly elected chair of the board, although that would have been effective only from 1 November.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So the board took the decisions. Are you telling me that you were not in a position, as the director of finance, to at least say, “Look, I think this should be referred to the external and internal auditors”?

You are a man of significant experience—I can see that from your biography—and you had been at the college for all those years. Did you not, given the integrity that you should have had as director of finance, say, “I’m really sorry about this, Mr Keenan, but you’ve asked me to make this payment and it’s a significant sum. The guidance says that the external and internal auditors need to be made aware of this. Regardless of the audit arrangements in the college, I want to refer this to the internal and external auditors.” You advised the internal auditors some weeks later in an informal conversation, did you not?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So it must have been troubling you during that period.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Paragraph 36 of the guidance details the requirements of external audit and it recognises that, normally, they would pick it up, post event.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Yes, so let us stick with internal audit.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

The external audit was fine. There is an issue with the internal audit. It is clear that internal audit should have carried out an audit needs assessment when they found out that the college was going through a merger. It is interesting that they did that for New College Lanarkshire from January 2014, but they did not pick that up for Coatbridge College when they were internal auditors for both Coatbridge College and Cumbernauld College.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Let us stick to the point here. You were the director of finance. For the record, can you clarify your annual salary?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

At Coatbridge College at the time?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I think that when I left it was £82,000.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So it was a significant salary and you had significant responsibilities. You were not there just to make payments without at least questioning them. Previously, had you never questioned payments that were put forward to you?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I think that I have already demonstrated that I did question whether the payment concerned should be made.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

But why did you question it? All that you said is that Laurence Howells attended the meeting, but he had attended other meetings before. Were you concerned that the internal auditors were not aware of the situation? Your concern was not just that Mr Howells attended the meeting. I am sure that he attended other meetings, but that did not prevent you from making payments. What was the specific reason for your concern?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

We were not at the initial remuneration committee meeting, and we only attended the board meeting after Mr Howells had left. However, Mr Keenan fed back to us what Mr Howells’s concerns were. At that point—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What was the feedback?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Specifically, it was that there would have to be a justification for any agreement above the 13 months.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What was the justification?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

You would have to ask the remuneration committee for that, because I was not involved in making that decision.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Right. So you were the director of finance and you just decided to make a payment. Is a director of finance there just to make payments? Is that all that you do?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

No.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What was your role in the organisation? Did you not have to make people aware of the finances available to the college? I understand that the college faced significant financial challenges. Did you not make people aware of that as well?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Not in the financial year 2012-13. We actually made a surplus in that year. For anything before this, it would have been fine to make payments. However, I challenged the payment and asked whether it should be made.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Right. So you challenged, but you have still not told us what the basis of that was, have you?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

It was on the basis of the concerns raised by Mr Howells.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What were the concerns that you were aware Mr Howells had raised?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Around the amount that was to be paid—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

—over the 13 months.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes. Obviously, the concerns were that there was no business case for that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I have a final couple of questions. During the period concerned, were there any exchanges with anybody, either verbally or via email, in which somebody said, “Look, maybe this should go to the external and internal auditors. Maybe we should have a discussion about that”? Do you recall any such emails during that period?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Nothing specifically about bringing in internal or external audit.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

No. Do you look back now and say, “Maybe I should have called the internal auditors”?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Hindsight is always a great thing, but I think—I have not discussed this with Tom Keenan, who was the chair of the audit committee at the time—that bringing in Biggart Baillie was more effective than bringing in internal audit at that point in time.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I put it to you that the £304,000 that was paid into somebody’s bank account was a significant sum of public money. You were the director of finance and you must have known somewhere along the line that somebody would say, “Derek, why did you make that payment? What is the justification for it?” Clearly, the issue has now been questioned by the Auditor General for Scotland. Do you not feel some sense of responsibility and that maybe you should have probed the matter to a greater extent?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I think that I probed it as far as I could. Obviously, the remuneration committee made the decision about the award to Mr Doyle and its timing. I questioned it, and we went through a process with Biggart Baillie to identify that we had followed guidance and that the remuneration committee had all the information that it required to make that decision. Therefore, it was not my decision to make that payment.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Yes, I understand that, but the guidance is very clear about the role of internal and external auditors, regardless of what committee the matter is referred to. I would have seen that. Do you not accept that it was your responsibility as director of finance to have seen it? That was why you were paid £82,000 a year—you were paid that so that you would at least say, “Listen, there’s an issue about this payment, Tom. We’ll need to look at this, but so will the internal auditors.”

Were you in constant contact with the internal auditors? How often were you in contact with them?

09:15

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

It depended on the audit programme that was in place. Obviously, I was the main liaison with the internal auditors in terms of their work programme, which was set by the audit committee.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Finally, just to confirm, were quite a lot of discussions taking place during September and October, but particularly during October, about the severance arrangements?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Through the board, yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you have any discussions with the internal auditors during that period?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

The only time when I had a specific conversation about the issue with internal audit was on 28 October 2013.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So you never at any stage during those two months said, “Why don’t I have a chat with the internal auditor and tell them that significant sums of money are going to be paid out of the college bank account? I need to have a chat with the auditor to make sure that whatever payment I’m making is going to be accepted or at least that they’re not going to have any issues with it.” That would particularly be the case for the external auditor, who would have to sign off the accounts.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes, but again, paragraph 36 of the guidance says that, generally, the external audit would be performed after the event.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I understand that, but you still need to put together a set of accounts, make payments to people and satisfy both internal and external auditors. You will know that better than I do, because you are the one who is qualified to do that—I am not. However, here is the issue: should you not have done that? Should you not at least have had a conversation with the auditors? During that whole year, did you have conversations with the auditors?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

In general, yes, there would be conversations, because they attended—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So you would have general conversations with the auditors about other issues. Why did you not want to make contact with the auditors about a really important financial transaction that was taking place at the college? That is incredible, is it not?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

It is not that we did not want to make contact with them. We did not think that it was required, because we brought in Biggart Baillie to do that assessment for us.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So Biggart Baillie is to blame now. People from Biggart Baillie will be giving evidence next.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I am not blaming anyone, but they carried out an assessment for us.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

To be fair, they were not the director of finance—you were. I take it that they were not responsible for appointing external auditors or at least for liaising with internal and external auditors.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

No, but they gave us advice that the remuneration committee asked for in terms of whether the committee could make that payment.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Yes. Let me just clarify this, as Biggart Baillie is giving evidence next. At no time did they say to you, “You don’t have to make contact with the external or internal auditors.”

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I cannot remember them saying that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So why would it be relevant to bring them into the conversation?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Because they were replacing internal audit in the process as they had particular expertise in HR and legal issues that would—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Sorry, but I just want to clarify that you are saying that they were replacing internal audit.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Is that the basis on which Biggart Baillie was appointed?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

As far as I know, yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So there will be paperwork to clarify that Biggart Baillie was appointed and, in effect, took over the role of internal audit.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

That is not what the auditors advised us when they met us last week or the week before. They did not advise us that they were replaced by Biggart Baillie.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

We had a discussion with them on 28 October 2013, when we outlined our processes and what we were planning to do, and they did not disagree with those processes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Okay. I will bring in Mary Scanlon now.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Before I go to Lorraine Gunn, I have a question for Mr Banks. When the people concerned were looking for their generous payments and you were agreeing to them, did you, as the director of finance, confirm to the principal and others that the college could well afford the £400,000 above what the SFC would pay?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Not at that particular time. Again, the process that we went through started in January 2013, where the remuneration committee agreed—

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

There would have been, yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The sum paid out was £1.7 million, of which the SFC paid £1.3 million and the college had to pay £400,000. Did you okay that £400,000?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I would have raised my concerns about it, but ultimately it was not my decision to do it.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But ultimately you, as the director of finance for Coatbridge College, agreed to that payment of £400,000.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I would have told people about the potential risks at the time of not being able to meet that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You told them about the risks of—

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

The potential of not having the funds to do that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am not hearing what you are saying properly—sorry. It is just different accents; I am from the Highlands. Could you speak a bit more clearly? You told them about the potential risks of paying out an extra £400,000, which was more than the SFC guidance allowed.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is nowhere in our evidence, which tells us that you agreed to that extra £400,000, saying “Don’t you worry. The SFC will pay £1.3 million. I can find £400,000 in the college funds for the £400,000 shortfall.” Is that right?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

No, no—

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I communicated with New College Lanarkshire and the funding council about that issue. A standard template had to be completed for a business case; all the figures were in there. I informed both New College Lanarkshire and the funding council about the shortfall.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You informed them? You need to be clear about that. When did you inform them? Did you agree to the £400,000 being paid? Our evidence says that you did.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

It would have been in March 2014 that they were told.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But you signed off the cheque. They were talking about the additional money long before March 2014.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

The only one who went before 1 October was Mr Doyle. After that, there was a process by which most people left on 31 March 2014, so—

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

That is the point at which we knew.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You knew that, on vesting day, Coatbridge had a deficit of more than £1 million. The £400,000 additional—and very generous—severance payments contributed 40 per cent of that deficit. You were fully aware of that, but the advice that you gave was, “Yeah, it’s okay—we can find that.”

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

No—when I left the college, I was predicting a small surplus of £34,000 up to 31 March, including those payments.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

And when did you leave the college?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

On 31 March.

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

But I actually stayed on—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

When did you start your new job with the Scottish Qualifications Agency?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

About seven weeks later.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Seven weeks later—okay.

I am quite surprised that, although the severance that was due to you as a director of finance under the New College Lanarkshire scheme was for nine months, you were in fact paid for 13 months. You got a job seven weeks later, but your payment in lieu of notice was £20,600, with another £5,500 in accrued annual leave. That is not bad money for seven weeks of being unemployed, is it?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

I started with the SQA as a consultant, not as a permanent employee, and I am still not a permanent employee—I have a temporary contract with the SQA.

With regard to my severance arrangements, I was on a retainer to give advice and help to New College Lanarkshire, which I did until May this year.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So why were you paid four months’ more in severance pay than what you were due, in comparison with all the other payments?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Because—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Why were you given more generous payments?

Derek Banks Former Director of Finance, Coatbridge College
link

Because New College Lanarkshire wished me to be on a retainer to give advice and help when required.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I will move to Lorraine Gunn. The 28 January remuneration committee meeting is critical. It is at the heart of the Auditor General’s report, which states that:

“The Chair and Principal ... did not provide the ... Remuneration Committee with advice provided by the SFC”

and that there is

“no evidence that”

the remuneration committee’s members

“were provided with detailed business cases”.

We still have not found a business case from either of you.

The report went on to state:

“the terms being discussed by the Remuneration Committee were not in line with the advice of the SFC”.

Those quotes are all from the Auditor General. I understand that it was your responsibility, as the HR director, to provide the remuneration committee with that advice and information. Is that correct?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

What I provided in advance of the committee meeting was in response to questions from the chair of the board. He wanted to know from me what was available in the sector in terms of known severance arrangements. The purpose of the meeting, when I was told to call it as the clerk to the board, was specifically to address arrangements for senior staff. It was not at that point in time necessarily about payments—the chair wanted to discuss with the committee generally where we were all at in terms of worries about the merger and so on—but I was aware that severance would come up as part of those discussions.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

There is nothing general about the specific discussion of 21 months’ pay for John Doyle, and three months’ pay for taking the college through the merger and six months’ pay plus a £90,000 pension contribution—

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

They did get—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is hardly a general discussion—it is specific to Mr Doyle.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

If you let me explain, I will. When I was first asked to give advice, I was asked for a broad overview of what was available. I believe that it was the remuneration committee’s responsibility to discuss that in some detail, in order to formulate a way forward or come to an informed decision about what it wanted to do. All that I was doing was giving information.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In that broad overview of what was available, did you give the Scottish funding council’s advice, which you had sought and found on the funding council’s website, to each and every member of the remuneration committee in order that they would make the right decision—an informed decision?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I believe that I did that in two ways. Initially, I spoke to the chair of the board and gave him guidance and counsel to engage, in advance of that remuneration committee meeting, with Mark Batho, the then chief executive of the funding council, on that severance guidance. I was specific in drawing his attention to the existence of the guidance, which I was aware had existed historically.

The chair asked me to get him a copy of said guidance beforehand. When I went to the SFC website I could not find anything other than what we now know to be the 2000 document, which happened to be in the archived part of the site. In getting the chair to speak to Mark Batho of the funding council, I counselled that he needed to check that we were operating from the most correct version of the guidance.

Subsequent to that, I was called into the remuneration committee meeting part way through—about 20 minutes into it. John Gray, the chair of the board, explained that the purpose of my being there was to be able to share the information that he had asked me to get in advance, which I did.

I have made available to you a statement, which is publicly—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have read your statement, but you still have not answered my point.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Well, I am—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Just let me finish. You say that you gave the advice to the chair—but we have already had the chair before us, sitting in the chair that you are in. We have also had the remuneration committee before us. The remuneration committee did not see that advice. When you talked to the chair, did you raise with him the issue that the SFC guidance on voluntary severance recommended 12 months’ pay for 14 years’ service—

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

It was not—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

—as opposed to what the remuneration committee was discussing, which was 21 months plus three months plus six months?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

No—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did you point out that the generous terms for Mr Doyle that the committee was discussing were way above those that the SFC guidance recommended?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

No, I did not explain it in that context.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I made the guidance available. There was definitely a conversation at the remuneration committee meeting when I came into the room in which the chair of the board discussed the conversation that he had had with Mark Batho and talked about the guidance that was available.

Subsequent to that, I made the guidance available to—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did you give paper copies to each and every member of the remuneration committee, and say, “This is the SFC guidance”? No.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Mary—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

They did not have any information. I am struggling with this. You had a chat with John Gray, the chair, who then phoned Mark Batho, but what advice—written or otherwise—regarding the Scottish funding council guidance did the remuneration committee, which made the decision, have? How did you furnish the committee with that information?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

At Coatbridge College we did not print off board papers and information in hard copy. We put all the information for board members on their board intranet. That is how I made that information available to them. It is a fully accessible—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So you did not give them information. You left it to them to go and flurry around the intranet.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

They were aware that it was there—they were guided to that information at the meeting.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did you tell them that the Scottish funding council guidance on voluntary severance referred to an amount that was considerably less than—it was less than half of—what they were discussing for John Doyle?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

No.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

As HR director, did you not point out that they were making an agreement that has ended up with us all—including you—being here? As HR director, did you not point out that the voluntary severance guidance from the Scottish funding council referred to considerably less than what the committee members were asked to agree to by John Gray?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I did not specifically point that out, but I believe that I gave them the information, by means of making—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You gave them the advice to look at the intranet when they had the time.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

No, I refute that, because at the end of the day the discussion took place at the committee. The discussion—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did the chair share that information?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

One at a time, please.

09:30

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is very important that we know. John Gray was aware of the Scottish funding council guidance, and you were aware of the Scottish funding council guidance, which was that, if someone had been in post for 14 years, they got 12 months’ pay. The remuneration committee, which made the decision about the 30 months’ pay for John Doyle, was not aware of the Scottish funding council guidance. I am trying to find out where that information is kept.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I am trying to clarify for you that, as both the then HR director and clerk to the board, I believe that the remuneration committee was made aware of that guidance.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

How were its members made aware of it? John Doyle said that they could go and look at the intranet. Was that making them aware?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

The discussion took place at the committee, where John Doyle spoke about the advice that he got from Mark Batho of the funding council.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So, the advice from Mark Batho was that the remuneration committee could pay what the Scottish funding council recommended and that the college itself could pay anything further than that.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I cannot recall the specifics, because it was two years ago.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

It is in the email that he subsequently sent to the chair of the board.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The members of the remuneration committee all sat here in good faith and told us that they did not receive that information.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Likewise, we are sitting here in good faith and doing exactly the same thing—I am giving you the facts as I know them to be, Mary.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You are saying that John Doyle said that the information was on the intranet for the members of the remuneration committee if they wanted to see it. You did not give them a piece of paper that gave them the basic guidance and told them that they could go over that figure but the college would have to pay the additional amount.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

With respect, it was not as dismissive as that. I put it to you that we were very specific. I gave the advice to the chair that the information was available, and I think that the chair fulfilled his role in having that discussion with the remuneration committee. I do not accept what my remuneration committee colleagues have said about their not having that information.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. So, the Auditor General for Scotland has obviously got it wrong when she states that

“it appears that the Chair did not provide the Remuneration Committee with complete or accurate information”—

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

It is not for me to conclude that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Ms Gunn, could you allow Ms Scanlon to continue, please?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Sorry, convener.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am quoting the Auditor General’s report. She states:

“The Chair and Principal ... did not provide the college’s Remuneration Committee with advice provided by the SFC”.

You are saying that you provided that advice, but I am hearing that you provided an arrow and told the committee members to go and look at the intranet; you did not give them a copy of the guidance or a verbal update of what the SFC guidance spelled out.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

They were given a copy. I think that that is probably as important—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is not what they said. You are saying that they were given a copy of the SFC guidance that said that, after 14 years’ service, someone could get 12 months’ pay. You are saying that they all ignored that guidance and that, when they came here, they told us mistruths about not having seen it. You are saying that they disregarded that guidance and that, instead of awarding Mr Doyle 12 months’ pay, they gave him 30 months’ pay. I am sure that they have a different story to tell, because that is not what they told this committee.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

All that I can do is give you the information and facts as I know them to be.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Well, I am sure that we will hear from the remuneration committee.

I have one final question. Ms Gunn, you are probably the only person who had access to John Doyle’s contract of employment. Was the 30 months’ pay—which was hugely generous at a time of a public sector funding freeze—in line with his contract of employment? Was he entitled to 30 months’ pay, which was more than twice what the Scottish funding council recommended?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I believe that any payments that were made to him were in accordance with his contractual arrangements.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I need to know a bit more about his contract of employment. This is a legal point, and we do not have access to that contract. Did it stipulate that he was entitled to far more than was recommended by the Scottish funding council?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Far more in terms of what?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have spelled it out about six times already.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I am sorry, but—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

After 14 years, someone would be entitled to 12 months’ pay, but he got 30 months’ pay—plus, you were willing to give him an extra £90,000 in pension and so on.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Forgive me, but his severance arrangement was in accordance with the arrangement that he was offered by the remuneration committee.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Was it in accordance with his contract of employment?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

There was nothing in his contract of employment about a severance arrangement, but there was a clause about payment in lieu of notice. That may be what you are referring to.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry, convener—I said that that would be my final question.

You say that, when you came to look at the 2 per cent increase in pay for the ordinary members of staff at Coatbridge College,

“The Chair said if the College acted in any other way”—

than giving a 2 per cent increase—

“we would look to being flagrant with funds before merger”.

Heaven forfend. You were happy to agree to a 2 per cent increase in salary for everyone else in the college because anything above 2 per cent would have been being “flagrant” with the funds—that is the word that you use. Why did everyone else get 2 per cent while the severance involved huge amounts?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

You would have to ask the remuneration committee that question, Mary—it is not for me to answer it.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But you are here—it is all about Lorna Gunn.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Forgive me, but it is Lorraine Gunn.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am reading the report of the extraordinary board of management meeting that was held on 6 August, which was attended by Lorna Gunn—

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Lorraine Gunn.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry—Lorraine Gunn. That was the advice that was given.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Sorry—can you repeat the question for me?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You were worried about giving other members of staff a pay rise of 2 per cent in case that might be seen as

“being flagrant with funds before merger”.

Why was a different approach taken to all other members of staff at the college?

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

I do not recall writing anything in my statement to indicate that I was worried about anything. That is why I am looking rather puzzled. Can you clarify exactly what you mean by that question?

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can we just clarify that that is in the minutes?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am reading the minutes of the meeting, which show that the chair said that.

Lorraine Gunn Former Director of Human Resources and Board Secretary, Coatbridge College
link

Sorry, but I need a bit of clarification about the question.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Evidence session · 1116

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.