link
Our final item of business is a report on the recent fact-finding visit to the Basque Country by Richard Baker and me, accompanied by Jim Johnston and Ross Burnside. Members have received copies of a short written report summarising our findings. I am not going to go through it all, but I want to highlight some points. I will then let Richard come in and if there is anything that he wants to add, he is free to do so.
The report summarises the key findings from our visit. The Basque Country is a fascinating part of Spain. It is less than a tenth of the size of Scotland, and it has 2.2 million people. It comprises three very prosperous provinces. The level of productivity per person is 34.5 per cent above the Spanish average. Its human development index is higher than that of Iceland, Norway and Sweden. It has less than 5 per cent of Spain’s population, but accounts for more than 6 per cent of its gross domestic product. It is interesting that the Basque Country’s contribution to the Spanish state is fixed at 6.24 per cent—it is known as the quota—so it pays 6.24 per cent of Spanish state expenditure in areas not devolved to the Basque Country.
Everything has been set up through something called the economic agreement, which regulates the financial and tax relations between the Spanish state and the Basque Country. It derives from historical power held in the Basque territories to regulate, manage and collect taxes. It was drummed into us when we were there that that goes back well into the mists of time and is part of their historical rights, about which they feel very strongly. As such, the Basque Country has a history of a specific Basque tax system with its own Treasury and tax collection infrastructure. Because the economic agreement is bilateral, the intergovernmental machinery provides equal weighting to the Basque and Spanish representatives. The bilateral relationship was considered to be a key element of the economic agreement.
Nearly all the politicians and officials we met were strongly supportive of the economic agreement. It was seen as an effective mechanism for governing, which has allowed the Basque Country to develop a successful and distinctive economic and industrial policy. There was agreement about the strong causal link between the economic agreement and the positive economic and social indicators evident in the Basque Country. For example, on GDP per capita, productivity, employment, research and development spending, inequality and higher education participation, the Basque Country significantly outperforms Spain and the European Union average. A key message was that Scotland’s tax powers must be for a purpose, and usable.
The visit was also interesting in showing a common “team Basque” approach to success. Last week the committee discussed behavioural patterns and the effect of taxation on them, and we asked questions about that. Despite the fact that the Basque Country has higher personal income taxes than the rest of Spain, that was not perceived as an issue, because the quality of the workforce, infrastructure, and research and development investment was seen as more critical.