Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”

Wednesday 4 November 2015 Public Audit Committee About 09:00–12:30 Committee business 655 contributions · 17 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

655 contributions · showing 1–200
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Item 2 concerns the section 22 report “The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”. On our first panel of witnesses we have Pauline Docherty, Paul Gilliver, Thomas Keenan, Carole McCarthy, David Craig and Ralph Gunn, who are all former members of Coatbridge College’s remuneration committee. As we are extremely tight for time, we will move straight to questions.

I advise everyone that, given the numbers of people who are present, the session will be extremely difficult to manage. Therefore, I will clarify the way in which we should proceed. If one former member of the remuneration committee makes a statement, we might best continue without further interjections from other former members on the matter.

My first question is for any former member of the remuneration committee and concerns the meeting that took place in January 2013—I know that some of you might not have attended that meeting. I understand that there was a difference of opinion at that meeting and that, at the meeting in October 2013, there was a further difference of opinion about the minutes of the meeting in January. Does any member wish to refer to that issue?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I was at both meetings. My recollection of the meeting in January 2013 is that we talked in some detail about a severance package for the principal. We were considering going into the merger and it was clear that we had to start thinking about voluntary severance schemes.

We were given information about what was happening in the sector and were told that the Edinburgh scheme, which was in place for the three colleges that were merging in Edinburgh, was being used by most of the sector. We were given information about what principals who had already left had left with. My recollection of the meeting is that we agreed the principal’s package and said that we would want to implement the Edinburgh scheme when we decided that it would be appropriate to create a voluntary severance scheme that applied to all staff, which would have a start date and a finish date.

At that time, we had not seen the Edinburgh scheme—it was not available to us in January. I do not remember exactly when it came out, but it was emailed to us at a later date, some time between January and October.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you oppose the minutes of the meeting in January 2013?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did other members of the remuneration committee do likewise?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I opposed the minutes of the 28 January meeting of the remuneration committee when they were put up for approval at the October meeting.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Were your reasons similar to Carole McCarthy’s?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

My reason was that I wanted equal access to voluntary severance for all staff, and the introduction of an executive scheme would not permit that.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You might have read the Official Report of our evidence session with Mr Doyle last week. He made it clear that he had no involvement with the remuneration committee and had no discussions concerning his severance package. Did any of you have formal or informal discussions with him about the severance package?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

There was no contact at a committee level, and no informal contact with me.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Is that the same for the other witnesses?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I can add a caveat that might help you. Following the January meeting, Mr Doyle received an offer that, at this stage, seems to have contravened the guidance from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council.

Mr Doyle was the accountable officer for the college, so once he was aware of the details of the offer that was made to him, he should have come back to the board; indeed, he should also have reported it to the funding council. That was his responsibility under the memorandum arrangements.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Mr Doyle was in the position that it had been made clear to him that he did not have a future at the college. As the remuneration committee, you had to consider how that would be taken forward.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I think that the timeline is fairly important. In January 2013, the board agreed to enter into a merger of the colleges in Lanarkshire. At that time, Mr Doyle had written a letter—I do not have it in my possession, but I have seen it—in which he suggested that that could make him redundant as the principal of Coatbridge College. Given that it was a three-college merger, there was every possibility that that would occur. Following that, the college’s chair called a meeting. I was in New Zealand at the time, and he phoned to ask me what the situation was in relation to the principal and the principal’s concerns. The advice that I gave him was, “Make sure it’s within the sector norm and complies with all guidance.”

In January 2013, Mr Doyle was in the position of being able to apply for a post in New College Lanarkshire. The information that I have seen subsequently suggests that that happened some six months later. At that time, we were in a merger process and, as far as I was aware, Mr Doyle had the ability to apply for a post in the new college.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I want to clarify something for everyone’s sake. Is it the case that no formal or informal discussions took place with Mr Doyle? Did he pass you in the corridor and say, “Did you hear about the possibility that I could be getting moved on? I’m concerned about the proposed package”? Was there no discussion with him whatever?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

None at all.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

None at all.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So no members of the remuneration committee had any conversations with him in that respect.

I understand that Laurence Howells attended the remuneration committee meeting in October 2013. Is that correct?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

He did not attend the remuneration committee meeting; he attended the board meeting.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Were you aware of the clear guidance that the Scottish funding council gave that any proposed package should be agreed by the external and internal auditors or should at least be brought to their attention?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

We discovered that there were Scottish funding council guidelines, but we did so only in October 2013.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

As members of the remuneration committee, in which capacity you had an important role to play, did you not think that there ought to be guidelines of some kind out there? Did none of you think that it was your responsibility at least to ensure that you had that guidance in front of you?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

That is what we did at the meeting in January—we asked about the norms in the sector and we got information about what was happening in other colleges. We were told that the voluntary severance scheme in Edinburgh—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am sorry—who told you that?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

The chair of the remuneration committee. That is what we were told at the remuneration committee. We were given information at the committee.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What kind of information were you given?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It was information about other colleges in the sector.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes—it was in a paper that came to the remuneration committee. We looked at norms in the sector and at the situation in other colleges, and we talked about value for money. We discussed the need to ensure that there was payback on a reasonable timescale. We asked those kinds of questions at the January remuneration committee meeting.

Laurence Howells came to the board meeting, which was after the remuneration committee meeting. We had a much longer discussion about the minutes of that meeting and absolute clarity about what we approved and did not approve. I believed that Laurence Howells was concerned about a senior management severance package that he was not happy with. We told him that there was no senior management severance package and that every member of the senior management team who was going to leave would do so under the New College Lanarkshire scheme.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So all the information that was provided to you was provided by the chair in a paper, but there was nothing that made it explicitly clear to you that the external and internal auditors should be made aware of any severance packages. Were you made aware of the correspondence that was exchanged with the Scottish funding council? Laurence Howells exchanged a number of emails with Mr Doyle and other members of the college, including Mr Gray. Were you made aware of those exchanges, in which Mr Howells made explicitly clear what the Scottish funding council expected of the college?

09:15

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I was aware that there was correspondence from Laurence Howells. The exact content of it was not made available to me, but I had a good reason to know about it. Both Mrs McCarthy and I were on the merger committee, which we attended in September 2013, when the question of severance payments arose. Mrs McCarthy and I agreed to a scheme to provide 13 months’ pay for all staff members in Coatbridge and the wider area. I was accompanied to that meeting by a senior member of staff who was aware that there was a scheme that I did not know existed. I wrote a briefing note and went back to the college. That note was taken by the board secretary and circulated to board members. I said in it that I wanted a report to go on 23 October to the remuneration committee and the board to deal with the issue of a 13-month severance payment. That was issued to the board.

Four weeks later, on 5 October, I received a telephone call from Mr McGuire, who was the principal designate of New College Lanarkshire. He brought to my attention the issue of due diligence and said to me that there was a contingent liability in due diligence of a significant sum that was more than I would have expected. That immediately rang alarm bells with me and, on the Saturday, I thought long and hard about it. I thought, “What do I not know and what am I going to do about it?” That was the thrust of the matter.

I thought about the matter on the Sunday. At 7 minutes to 1 on the Monday morning, I sent an email to Mrs McCarthy that said that I was extremely worried that I had been misled in some way. I was very concerned that we had been misled, and I arranged to meet the depute principal on 7 October to find out what was going on, because the due diligence report told me that, in respect of information coming from the college to the auditor, there had to be some legal or factual basis, or it would not have been in due diligence.

I met the depute principal and was shown a letter that was dated 8 February or around then and which highlighted clearly that there had been an offer to senior managers. In my opinion, that offer did not correspond with the Edinburgh scheme. The letter essentially said, “If you don’t see a place for yourself in the new college, you will get a 21-month pay-off, irrespective of length of service or anything.” I was more than upset when I saw the letter.

I took that up with the board chair, because I had been unaware of that letter, which had significant implications particularly for the merger—it was a wrecking ball that six staff out of 1,000 could have that scheme. I stress that it was not a severance scheme, as a severance scheme presupposes a number of things—folk have to apply to it, it has to be approved and it has to be in the merged college’s interests.

Following that, I understood that Mr Howells was pursuing the college. I was pursuing the college—I was absolutely incandescent that we should have been put in that position. As part of the due diligence process, trade union representatives were—properly—at the meeting. When they heard that senior staff in Coatbridge College had a different severance scheme from other staff, things went ballistic, and I cannot say that I blame them. I was sitting there as a board member, knowing that I had never seen that proposal, never approved it and never considered it to be a part of a severance scheme. It caused a good many problems.

As I said, I spoke to the chair, I wrote to Paul Gilliver and, irrespective of the involvement of Mr Howells in relation to the senior staff severance scheme, when it went to the remuneration committee it was removed. However, it had a number of impacts for the future. I cannot be more candid than I have been today.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I appreciate that. I have one final issue to raise. I understand that the director of finance contacted you prior to Mr Doyle’s BACS payment on 25 October 2013.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you give authority for that payment to be made?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No. It would be helpful to give the background. Due diligence showed up three things. It showed up an amount of money that I understood that the board had approved, which was at or around two years’ salary. It showed up a pension payment of £91,000, which quite frankly I did not understand. It also showed up a payment that was essentially in lieu of notice.

When I went to the remuneration committee, I spoke at length, particularly about the payment in lieu of notice. A lot of information has been put to your committee about who said what and when. The plain fact is that, when we went into the merger process in January 2013, potentially there was no place for one of the principals—principal A or principal B. When we confirmed on 6 August that we were going back into the merger, it was clear that a principal designate either had been appointed or was in the process of being appointed. The merger process was quite far down the line for New College Lanarkshire. Therefore, as soon as we agreed on 6 August to go into an extraordinary merger, in effect Mr Doyle—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can I clarify something? I am asking you a pretty clear question. I understand that, via the director of finance, representations were made to you as the succeeding chair. I want to clarify that for the record.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No. For the record—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Just a wee second—sorry. You succeeded Mr Gray in the chair.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Well—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Just listen to the question first. Following that, I understand that there was a representation in an email or in some other form—I am not sure. Let us just clarify that. You were asked, “Should this payment be made to Mr Doyle?” I understand that at that point you might have been concerned about some aspects. I am only asking the question; I not asking you to qualify it. Did you advise the director of finance that the payment should be made—yes or no?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

That version of events is not quite right. I am sorry to labour the point.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you arrange for the payment to be made?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No. I think that I need to qualify this. I am sorry; I am not being obtuse.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can you be as succinct as possible?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I knew that there was a problem because of an email that went out on 24 October from the SFC to the chair. I then received a copy of all the correspondence between the SFC, the former chair and Mr Doyle. My position, which may be debated but which I have documentary evidence to back, was that I was to become chair when the then chair and Mr Doyle both left. I phoned to discuss with the director of finance the elements of Mr Doyle’s severance payment. The element that gave me most concern was the £91,000.

Two days before, I had been at a meeting at which the board members unanimously approved a payment in the order of two years’ salary and accepted that the position in relation to the six months’ pay was a contractual and legal obligation. Therefore, on that basis, I did not insist that Mr Doyle’s severance payment should be stopped.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have read so much about the witnesses that it feels like you are characters in a novel who are coming to life. I am grateful for your evidence.

Last week, John Doyle said, in response to a question that I asked him:

“There were no voluntary severance applications prior to 31 October.”—Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 28 October 2015; c 82.

If there were no voluntary severance applications prior to 31 October, why were you discussing Mr Doyle’s voluntary severance application, as I presume that you were doing, on 28 January?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I can explain the situation and clarify a couple of things, which will be helpful. The committee considered Mr Doyle’s request for a severance package—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So he requested a severance package—

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

He wrote to the chair, and the chair held a meeting.

On the number of severance packages before 31 October, the situation was that New College Lanarkshire had a scheme, which was open to all staff and was based on 13 months’ salary. A number of Coatbridge staff applied for the scheme, but none of the senior managers applied for it at that time. Forgive me if I have got the figures wrong, but something like 30-odd staff applied, and they were released as and when it suited the business needs of New College Lanarkshire. Most went in 2015.

To answer your question, a voluntary severance scheme was open for staff members in Coatbridge as part of the merger process, and a number of people applied but, as far as I am aware, and to the best of my knowledge, no payments were made—apart from to Mr Doyle—before 31 October.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Can you confirm that Mr Doyle asked for a voluntary severance application to be considered by the remuneration committee on 28 January? Were your deliberations on that day a response to Mr Doyle asking about voluntary severance? Did he apply?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

That day, the remuneration committee was focused on a letter from the chair, which said that the principal’s position was no longer tenable, it was likely that he would have to leave in the near future and we needed to talk about a severance package for him. At that meeting, we said, “Well, if we’re going into a merger there will have to be a voluntary severance scheme for all staff,” and we talked about the Edinburgh scheme.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

On 28 January, you agreed to one month’s salary for each year, up to a maximum of 21 months. You also agreed to an extra three months’ pay for successfully taking the college through the merger—which the college opted out of two weeks later—plus another six months. If Mr Doyle did not apply for voluntary severance, was the issue brought to the committee by John Gray, the chairman of the board?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes. In the discussion about the severance package, we discussed two years’ pay—21 months’ pay plus three months to take the college into the merger—but we did not discuss the six months’ notice at that stage in January.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did you agree in January that the principal would get 21 months’ pay?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes. Based on the information that we had about what other principals in the sector were leaving with, and based on the Edinburgh scheme, it was 21 months.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Last week, the Scottish funding council confirmed that it issued the guidance in January that would have seen Mr Doyle get 12 months’ pay. Mr Gray and Mr Doyle both had that guidance, which proposed 12 months’ pay rather than 30 months’ pay.

What information were you given prior to that meeting or at that meeting to ensure that you had the SFC guidance? That is what we are really interested in. What information were you given to make that decision? After all, that is the reason why you are all here today. What guidance were you given before or at the committee to ensure that Mr Doyle’s payments were kept within the SFC guidelines? I would like to hear from Ralph Gunn and David Craig in particular—they have both given written evidence to the committee, for which we are grateful—because my understanding is that they were not given that guidance from the funding council.

09:30

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

We were not given the funding council guidelines. We were told about the norms in the sector and given information on other colleges. We were told about the Edinburgh scheme, which was posted to us later. We talked about the Scottish funding council and asked about the connection with it, and we were probably told that there had been meetings with Mark Batho and someone else at the council. That is what we were told. We never had the SFC’s guidelines in front of us.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We have to establish the facts here. The Auditor General’s report talks about information being withheld, and the fact is that you came to a decision on the basis of the information that you had and the voluntary severance decision that you made was much more generous than it would have been had you had the funding council’s guidance. Do any members of the remuneration committee sitting here feel that information was withheld from it so that it would decide to give Mr Doyle a more generous payment?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It seems to me that we had incomplete information. The minute records:

“The Chair ... confirmed that he had spoken to Mark Batho, Chief Executive of the Funding Council, and that these discussions were in line with the Funding Council’s guidance on severance arrangements for senior staff.”

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Is it fair to say that, if you had the Scottish funding council guidance that you are aware of now, you would not have agreed to give Mr Doyle 21 months’ pay plus an extra three and then another six?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It is my conviction—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Would you have kept within the Scottish funding council guidelines if the college chair or principal had ensured that you were given that information?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It is not possible to answer that. The funding council guidelines talk about things like discretion and business cases. It is almost impossible to answer that question with hindsight. We thought that we had made a reasonable decision based on the questions that we asked, the conversation that we had and the information that we had in front of us.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I do not doubt that. However, the Scottish funding council guidance says that someone with 14 years’ service should receive 12 months’ pay. You agreed to 21 months’ pay, plus an extra three and then another six, which was much more generous. If you had had the funding council guidance, would you not have said, “Okay. Here’s the basic payment, according to the guidance,” which would have been 12 months’ pay instead of 30 months? That is my critical question today. Would you have made a different decision if that guidance had been available?

Ralph Gunn Coatbridge College
link

It is difficult to talk for everybody but, speaking personally, I think that, if I had had guidance in front of me that said something markedly different from what we eventually decided, I would not have made the decision that we made.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The Auditor General talks about withholding information. Is that a fair assessment of the situation?

Ralph Gunn Coatbridge College
link

With hindsight, it is. However, at the time, we did not know about anything like that.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

The information that we were given was more up to date. The Edinburgh scheme had 2012 on it, and we got information about the rest of the sector.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Was it John Gray who, in agreement with the principal, developed and put forward to you the principal’s severance package to which you agreed on 28 January?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It was proposed by the chairman and agreed by the committee. I cannot add to that.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

When he proposed it, did he say that he had been discussing it with the principal in advance?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Not to my recollection, no.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Was the decision that you made conveyed to the principal after your meeting?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

The answer is obviously yes. He got a letter offering him a severance deal.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Well, it was then or about then.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So he got the letter right after the meeting.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

That would have been consistent with what happened with the letters that went to the senior staff—that was on or after 8 February.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I want to clarify a couple of things that all of you have mentioned. First, in last week’s evidence session, John Doyle said that he or his office had made sure that the funding council guidance that Mary Scanlon has referred to had been placed on the college intranet. Were you made aware of that at the meeting on 28 January?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

We were not directed to the intranet.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

So you were not directed to that at any time.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

If Mr Doyle seriously thinks that committees are appropriately advised by going to the college intranet, I have to say that that is quite simply nonsense. I repeat: it is absolute nonsense. If there is information that should have been within our domain—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

You must understand that the committee is interested only in the facts. I understand your perspectives on the matter, because you have put them on the record, and we are grateful for that.

I think that Ms McCarthy said this earlier, but I want to get it absolutely right. You said that there was a letter from Mr Doyle—which we have not seen—asking to go and therefore asking the remuneration committee or the board to consider a voluntary package. Can you clarify when the letter was written and when, or if, you saw it?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It was a long time ago—

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I know—I am sorry to ask you about it.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I am almost sure that it was pre the remuneration committee meeting in January. In fact, I think that it led to that meeting. The principal felt that his position was no longer tenable, and he sent the letter to the chair, John Gray.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Was that letter tabled at that remuneration committee meeting?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I think that it was sent out beforehand.

David Craig Coatbridge College
link

A note was sent prior to the meeting, suggesting that the principal would no longer be looking at a future with New College Lanarkshire.

David Craig Coatbridge College
link

It was. It was sent by email prior—

David Craig Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

That was on 25 January, Mr Scott.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I am sorry, but I do not have it in front of me. I think that it said that the principal had decided that his post was not tenable and that he had to go. He circulated the letter and a commentary saying that he hoped that the attached did not come as a shock and that, for him, it was almost inevitable. The meeting of the remuneration committee followed that letter.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is fair.

The minute of the 28 January meeting hardly recognises—indeed, it does not recognise—that point. It seems to me important that you had had a note from your chair in relation to the future of the principal, given that it was the main reason, as it were, for the remuneration committee meeting on 28 January. However, the minutes do not even reflect the fact that that note exists. I know that we are talking about something that happened two years ago.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I recollect that the chairman opened that meeting by saying, “I’ve called this meeting to discuss severance terms for the principal.”

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

And that is how all of you recollect that.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Was it the chair of the board who at the 28 January meeting led the discussion about the terms?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

And Mr Gray proposed the terms that were to apply to the principal.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

As you have clarified to Mrs Scanlon, you were at no time given the funding council’s very clear guidance with regard to giving one year’s pay instead of two.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

During that meeting, were you told that the only way that a college could make a payment above the moneys coming from the funding council was to use its own resources?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Did you ask for a business plan? Were you conscious of the funding council’s clear guidance that any financial agreement above that which the council would fund needed to be accompanied by a business plan?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

We did not have that advice, and we did not ask for a business plan.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I move forward to the October meeting. Mr Keenan’s advice about that earlier was interesting. At any time, was a business plan presented in relation not only to the principal’s package but to other packages that you were being asked to agree to?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No, because we were not being asked to agree to any other packages in October. We had already agreed to create a voluntary severance scheme with New College Lanarkshire. That was what was agreed. We were not agreeing any other packages. People had to apply to the voluntary severance scheme, and that is when their cases were considered.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But did you consider that it might have been appropriate to have a business plan, just to give you some context as to the financial liability that you might be entering into at that time?

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No, but we talked about the financial aspects and the fact that we had reserves that covered the difference between what the Scottish funding council would pay and what the college would pay.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

That is very fair. It was suggested to us last week that the additional resources to be used for the packages would come from commercial income that the college generated. Again, is that something that you were conscious of? Was that explained?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I would not like to place emphasis on that. My view of commercial income was that it went into the common reserve, which was applied to the charitable objectives of the college. I would not make the distinction.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Therefore, how did you assess how the financial packages were going to be paid? Where was the money going to come from?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

The only package that was going to be paid for that we knew about, for which we had a defined liability, was the principal’s severance package. We did not have a defined liability for any other package. We did not have any other package that we knew about. As chairman of the finance committee, I would have wanted a costing of any other proposals.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

If the money to pay for Mr Doyle’s package did not come from the funding council, or only up to a certain level, and did not come from commercial income in any other way, it must have come from college resources.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It came from the common resources of the college, yes.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Those common resources would normally pay for the things that go on in classrooms to help students.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

They pay for everything to do with the college.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Absolutely. Thank you very much for that.

My final question is on confidentiality clauses. Was there any discussion at the remuneration committee in relation to the principal or any other members of staff signing confidentiality clauses?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Not to my recollection.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I can indicate that, in relation to the principal, there was absolutely no such discussion. In November 2013, I sought guidance from New College Lanarkshire, because the college solicitor had asked me about the position in relation to the withdrawal of the severance scheme for the senior staff. I got a response, because the college solicitor was keen on a compromise agreement. However, as I understand it—I have a memorandum somewhere to confirm this—New College Lanarkshire, as a matter of policy, implemented compromise agreements for all the people who went.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Mr Keenan, you said earlier to the convener that you had raised substantial concerns in September 2013—correct me if I have got that wrong—in relation to what you then began to understand was potentially happening in terms of severance payments.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

You obviously have the memorandum that I sent to the funding council. I think that you should correct the date to 7 October, as I have found out that that was the date of the due diligence. I accept that the letter that I sent suggested that it was in September, but it was on 7 October.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

Did you get a response from the funding council directly to you?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It responded to some parts of the correspondence, but not all.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

But there was an exchange between you and the funding council after you had provided it with your concerns on 7 October?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No. To be very clear, I did not go to the funding council. Representatives of the funding council were at the meeting on due diligence. This might be a tricky point, but I will do my best to get it across. They obviously had concerns. They saw a different contingent liability from the one that they expected. I saw a different contingent liability from the one that I expected. What I expected was a contingent liability in relation to the college principal, but what I saw was much more than that.

That goes to the heart of the matter and maybe the heart of my immediate concern. When I read the guidance at a later stage, it became apparent to me that the college’s accounting officer should have informed the funding council if there was anything materially different from the norm—Mrs Scanlon indicated what the norm was. It worried me that the funding council did not know. The only reason why it did not know is that it was not told. There was a parallel process.

09:45

As a board member, I was very concerned about the position because all the guys round the table, including me, had always acted in an open and diligent manner. Until the situation arose, we would all have said that there were no problems. The corporate governance was good, the auditing was good, people did their jobs and everything was good. On 7 October, I recognised that there was a major issue irrespective of what the funding council was doing. I did not know exactly what it was doing, but I know what I did and I know what the remuneration committee did. When we became aware of things, we did not sit there as passive, quiet folk; we overturned the senior severance agreement and took the £91,000 back from the package. That is what we did—you can dress it up however you like. We knew that there was a problem, we were concerned and we tried to act in the best interests of the college.

It was not an easy time; it was an extremely stressful time. When you wake up and realise that you have been misled by people that you work with, you are not a happy man.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I totally understand that. You assumed that, following the discussion that you had had on 7 October, the funding council had written to the principal on 10 October to seek assurances about the arrangements.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I would have expected nothing less, although I never read any of the correspondence.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

One or two appendices appear to be missing from the minutes of the 4 November meeting. Perhaps you could endeavour to get copies of those, as we do not know whether they are germane to the discussion.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I can tell you anything that you want to know about the meeting on 4 November because I was sitting there. Just ask away.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Fine. Appendix 2 deals with mergers in the college sector and background information that Martin McGuire, the principal of New College Lanarkshire, offered. The information is detailed in appendix 2, which we do not have.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I will tell you what is in appendix 2 and will then provide it for you. I think that the auditors have a copy, too.

I was extremely concerned about what had happened, so I called the remuneration committee. I wanted to find out what usually happened in the sector and where I could find demonstrable information to support anything that we were going to do. When the principal was leaving, the board agreed to make the acting principal the principal. It was evident that we needed some form of restructuring to carry us through to reorganisation, which was five months away. I wanted the board never to be in the position that we were in in October. I knew that some allowances would need to be made for people performing additional duties, and I wanted to find out exactly what was happening in the opaque world of the finances of colleges. I decided that I would approach the principal designate, who was eventually going to take over the college. We had a very long discussion about what was the norm in the sector. He had had previous experience in Fife and knew the sort of figures that an acting principal should get. It is very difficult to get information about what happens in the college sector but, from his experience, he gave us specific figures. I stress that Mr McGuire never approved what we did; he gave us advice, which, in the main part, we took.

That is a comprehensive summary of appendix 2. If you have any questions about the other appendices, I would be happy to answer them.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

We will move on to appendix 3. I think that you introduced the report, Mr Keenan.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It was about the SFC. Perhaps you could—

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It was. I was trying to advise board members of the SFC’s absolute position. I wrote the report. I would add that it may not be as accurate as it could be. What was worrying me was whether the funding council had a legitimate concern and what we would have to do to make sure that we dealt with all the issues. The report’s conclusion was that the SFC had legitimate concerns. We were talking about public money. I wanted to bring the rest of the board and the remuneration committee to a common position of understanding. It was not nice to have to write that in the report, but that is what I did.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I will pursue one last appendix, which is a redraft of a letter prepared by Biggart Baillie.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes. I had to write to the funding council and set out what the position was. I had taken legal advice. I knew that I had a requirement to write to the funding council. I had already written informally to it to set out my view of what had happened, but I thought that I needed a formal response. The correspondence was not addressed to me, but I picked it up as the new chair. I wrote to the funding council on or around 11 November 2013 and I explained what the situation was. The letter is contained as part of the evidence in the Scottish funding council’s submission to the committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In his evidence last week, Mr Doyle said that Biggart Baillie was brought in as an independent team to ensure that there was no conflict of interest. Were you are aware that Biggart Baillie was being brought in and of the circumstances in which that happened?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

There was always a conflict of interest. Clearly, a principal sitting on a remuneration committee and who is looking for a severance payment has, under the guidance, a conflict of interest.

There was a conflict of interest on 28 January 2013 and thereafter. The precise reason for bringing in Biggart Baillie is for Mr Doyle to answer; I cannot speculate on that. He has given his views. I have no information or evidence—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Was the issue discussed with the remuneration committee in advance of Biggart Baillie being appointed?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No. I have not questioned Biggart Baillie’s independence.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No, and having dealt with the company, neither would I.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay. Are you aware of the SFC’s circular letter of 20 January 2000 on severance payments?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I am now, yes.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

At the time that you were making decisions, were you aware of that letter?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes, on 23 October 2013.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In October 2013 and also in January 2013. The letter has been there since 2000.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I was never specifically shown it, and I never chose to go on the intranet because I did not know that it was on there.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay. In her report, the Auditor General makes quite a few comments that are very concerning. Among them is a concern about the college not retaining sufficient evidence, including business cases, on whether there was any value for money assessment of severance proposals and salary enhancements. Will you comment on that?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Okay. Four individuals applied for severance arrangements. The applications—for the senior staff—went to a panel. The panel consisted of the chair and the principal of New College Lanarkshire, the depute chair or a member of Cumbernauld College, Mrs McTavish, the regional chair, and me. A meeting was held to look at the severance payments in New College Lanarkshire. The sums of money involved were set out. For one individual who applied at that time, the payment was deemed to be too expensive. She then reapplied. New College Lanarkshire had that information on those four individuals.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Was the committee involved in decisions such as the one to award one member of staff a salary uplift of 19 per cent?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

The principal referred to that in evidence to this committee last week and explained his reasons for that 19 per cent upgrading.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But it did not come before the remuneration committee. Would it normally have done so?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

That is a moot point.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It did not come before the remuneration committee.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do you believe that it should have, in the normal course of things?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I will defer to Pauline Docherty on that.

Pauline Docherty Coatbridge College
link

Remuneration committees would be called if there was a proposal to enhance a salary for a restructure, a change of duties, et cetera; and that would be discussed at various remuneration committees when it happened. That is what would happen generally. Therefore, there would be a discussion about it, but it would not normally be minuted if someone was getting an enhancement to salary for whatever reason. The relevant questions would be asked about why the enhancement was happening and whether it involved a restructure, a change of duties or a change in structure, but that would not be minuted. However, it was discussed at various remuneration committees when it was—

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I must say that I find it extraordinary that it would not be minuted.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Can I just clarify something that might be helpful? The remuneration committee dealt with senior staff and the human resources committee dealt with other staff.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But it was discussed at the remuneration committee.

Pauline Docherty Coatbridge College
link

Yes.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes, on 4 November, but there was a reason for that. I will be very clear. On 2 November 2013, I was advised by the principal that there were letters that emanated from January 2013, which had been exchanged between the principal and the individual concerned, and there was an acceptance by the individual of a voluntary severance package to the tune of 18 months’ pay. That was brought to my attention on 2 November. I then took it to the remuneration committee, where we were dealing with all the issues that had arisen. I then sent a letter to New College Lanarkshire, as that individual had not applied for voluntary severance but had a letter giving her a right to 18 months’ pay.

I thought “I’ll go through the proper process”, so I took it to the remuneration committee, I wrote to New College Lanarkshire and I wrote a report for the human resources committee setting out the circumstances of what had happened. Should that letter to the individual have been written? Unequivocally, no—unequivocally. However, it was written by the principal.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay. Can I just clarify one other thing? I think that you made very clear the circumstances in the January when the principal applied for voluntary severance. In his evidence last week, Mr Doyle said that it was at a meeting on 20 August 2013 that he realised that he would have to go. He said words to the effect that when you meet someone from the SFC and someone from the Scottish Government, you understand without anybody saying anything that that is it. However, that does not seem to fit with what you are telling us.

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Okay. I will give you the information that I have. On 6 August—

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No, no—I think that this will answer your question. On 6 August, at an extraordinary board meeting—I will give you a copy of the minute—when asked by a member of staff, “What will happen to you, principal?”, his answer was, “I would have liked to be part of New College Lanarkshire. However, I’ll not be able to undertake that role.”

That moment, on 6 August when we agreed, as a board, that we were going into the merger, was the day and the hour that Mr Doyle almost certainly had no job. Two situations could have arisen from that: alternative employment could have been offered to him, or he could have rejected it. For all practical purposes, on 6 August, Mr Doyle, was made redundant. Unlike in January when Mr Doyle still had the possibility of having a post, by 6 August, Mr McGuire was in post, so I can say and document that Mr Doyle was aware that he had no job on 6 August. Everything else was a matter of timing.

10:00

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Good morning, everyone. Obviously, more issues have come out of the evidence that you have given today. Thank you for that. Members of the committee are constrained to a certain extent, because we cannot mention certain names or correspondence that we have in our possession. Luckily, we are not constrained in relation to the minutes of the remuneration committee.

My concern, much like everyone else’s, is the fact that there was a remuneration committee meeting in January 2013 and yet through the whole merger situation, there was no other meeting until October 2013. Mr Keenan has mentioned meetings in February, April and August, but I presume that they were board meetings, rather than remuneration committee meetings. Were you, as members of the remuneration committee, not concerned that you had no meetings whatsoever between January and October? Did you have ad hoc meetings, or phone calls and emails? The only records that we have are from January and October and then things really hot up and the next meeting is in November. Did it not raise alarm bells that no meetings were being held?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It did not raise alarm bells with me. It has to be seen in the context of all the merger activity. The merger management committee was extremely busy at the time, the other committees were busy, college life went on and we were waiting to be called. It was originally envisaged that the merger would take place on 31 July, but that then dragged on until 31 March 2014. So, no, I was not all that worried about it—it was all going to take its own time.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

It is my view.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I can see people nodding—if anyone feels differently, please speak up.

Ralph Gunn Coatbridge College
link

One of the reasons why the meetings did not happen was because the proposed merger in January did not take place.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

Yes.

Ralph Gunn Coatbridge College
link

Given that the merger did not take place, there was no real need to revisit the situation, until the situation changed again and the merger was back on.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I take that on board and I understand what you are saying. I just wanted to clarify that point.

Mr Keenan, you mentioned that you had emailed or called Ms McCarthy during the time when no meetings were being held. Was it normal practice to speak to each other that way?

Thomas Keenan Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

People on the board did speak to each other. However, to be specific, by 7 October, Mrs McCarthy and I were aware that there was a due diligence issue. On the afternoon of Monday 7 October, we saw letters and a minute from the 28 January. Mrs McCarthy can tell you her view of the minute. That minute was circulated to members of the remuneration committee that evening for approval. I will leave it to Mrs McCarthy to answer any other questions on that.

Carole McCarthy Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

On 7 October, we were going to a merger committee meeting with the other colleges, and that was where the due diligence—the financial diligence of Coatbridge College going into the merger—was going to be presented. The phone call took place because that was the first time that I saw—in the due diligence—a liability figure that did not make any sense to me. We had no liability like that—we had no scheme for senior staff. That is why the phone call happened—we were going to a meeting that evening, where a report was going to be presented, which said that we had a liability that we did not understand.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Thank you for that information. The point that I am trying to get at is whether that was normal practice. At the end of the day, the remuneration committee is the one that rubber stamps things.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I would take issue with the phrase “rubber stamp”; we were not a rubber-stamp committee.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Maybe that is the wrong phrase. Basically, you had responsibility for severance pay. I wondered whether it was normal for the college sector to have different committees whose members do not tend to meet or talk to each other in-between. That is the point that I was trying to make.

You mentioned 28 January 2013 and issues that arose at the time. Correct me if I am wrong, but I think you mentioned that Mr Doyle had produced a letter to the remuneration committee, for 28 January or before, saying that he was no longer seeking employment. Is that correct?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I do not recall such a letter. I only recall the chairman saying that it was Mr Doyle’s intention to go.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is fine. That is what I wanted to establish. Were you aware that, in January 2013, Mr Doyle applied unsuccessfully for the job of principal of Ayrshire College?

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

No.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

So you were not given that information either.

The remuneration committee met on 28 January. We have the minutes here. I think Mary Scanlon raised the issue that part of the minutes say that Mark Batho, the chief executive of the funding council, was aware of everything and agreed to it. However, in response to Mary Scanlon, you said that that was not what was said at the meeting.

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

The part that I read out excluded the sentence

“He”—

I would certainly interpret that to mean Mr Batho—

“confirmed that the Funding Council had no objections to the Board’s approach.”

I remember the use of the phrase “funding was not a problem”.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Can I read out that paragraph? It may be an accurate minute that you saw but, from what we have heard, there is a question about whether it is accurate. It says:

“The Chair noted that transitional support funding would be made available to the College as part of a merger process and thus the funding was not an issue at this time. The Chair also confirmed that he had spoken to Mark Batho, Chief Executive of the Funding Council and that these discussions were in line with the Funding Council’s guidance on severance arrangements for senior staff, and in particular, any potential arrangements in respect of the Principal. He confirmed that the Funding Council had no objections to the Board’s approach.”

Paul Gilliver Former Member, Coatbridge College Remuneration Committee
link

I believe that to be an accurate minute. The only thing that I took exception to was the second-last paragraph, where it purports to record that “the same model” would be afforded to college senior staff.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 655

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.