I was aware that there was correspondence from Laurence Howells. The exact content of it was not made available to me, but I had a good reason to know about it. Both Mrs McCarthy and I were on the merger committee, which we attended in September 2013, when the question of severance payments arose. Mrs McCarthy and I agreed to a scheme to provide 13 months’ pay for all staff members in Coatbridge and the wider area. I was accompanied to that meeting by a senior member of staff who was aware that there was a scheme that I did not know existed. I wrote a briefing note and went back to the college. That note was taken by the board secretary and circulated to board members. I said in it that I wanted a report to go on 23 October to the remuneration committee and the board to deal with the issue of a 13-month severance payment. That was issued to the board.
Four weeks later, on 5 October, I received a telephone call from Mr McGuire, who was the principal designate of New College Lanarkshire. He brought to my attention the issue of due diligence and said to me that there was a contingent liability in due diligence of a significant sum that was more than I would have expected. That immediately rang alarm bells with me and, on the Saturday, I thought long and hard about it. I thought, “What do I not know and what am I going to do about it?” That was the thrust of the matter.
I thought about the matter on the Sunday. At 7 minutes to 1 on the Monday morning, I sent an email to Mrs McCarthy that said that I was extremely worried that I had been misled in some way. I was very concerned that we had been misled, and I arranged to meet the depute principal on 7 October to find out what was going on, because the due diligence report told me that, in respect of information coming from the college to the auditor, there had to be some legal or factual basis, or it would not have been in due diligence.
I met the depute principal and was shown a letter that was dated 8 February or around then and which highlighted clearly that there had been an offer to senior managers. In my opinion, that offer did not correspond with the Edinburgh scheme. The letter essentially said, “If you don’t see a place for yourself in the new college, you will get a 21-month pay-off, irrespective of length of service or anything.” I was more than upset when I saw the letter.
I took that up with the board chair, because I had been unaware of that letter, which had significant implications particularly for the merger—it was a wrecking ball that six staff out of 1,000 could have that scheme. I stress that it was not a severance scheme, as a severance scheme presupposes a number of things—folk have to apply to it, it has to be approved and it has to be in the merged college’s interests.
Following that, I understood that Mr Howells was pursuing the college. I was pursuing the college—I was absolutely incandescent that we should have been put in that position. As part of the due diligence process, trade union representatives were—properly—at the meeting. When they heard that senior staff in Coatbridge College had a different severance scheme from other staff, things went ballistic, and I cannot say that I blame them. I was sitting there as a board member, knowing that I had never seen that proposal, never approved it and never considered it to be a part of a severance scheme. It caused a good many problems.
As I said, I spoke to the chair, I wrote to Paul Gilliver and, irrespective of the involvement of Mr Howells in relation to the senior staff severance scheme, when it went to the remuneration committee it was removed. However, it had a number of impacts for the future. I cannot be more candid than I have been today.