The committee will consider two statutory instruments that are subject to the affirmative procedure, the first of which is the draft Farm Woodland Premium Schemes and SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme Amendment (Scotland) Scheme 2007. The Parliament must approve the draft instrument before it can be made. I welcome, with great pleasure, Sarah Boyack, Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development, and her officials. She is here to move motion S2M-5340, in the name of Ross Finnie.The Subordinate Legislation Committee considered the draft instrument and made no comment. Before we debate the motion, we will be able to ask officials to clarify purely technical matters or to explain details, but the officials cannot participate in the debate that will take place after the minister moves the motion. I invite Sarah Boyack to introduce her officials and make opening remarks.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Farm Woodland Premium Schemes and SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme Amendment (Scotland) Scheme 2007 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 8
- James Simpson Forestry Commission Scotland 5
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 4
- Rob Gibson SNP 3
- Jim Johnstone Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 3
- Nora Radcliffe LD 3
- Elaine Smith Lab 2
- Richard Lochhead SNP 2
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 1
The record
34 contributionsThank you. I am accompanied by Jim Johnstone, from the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department, and James Simpson, from Forestry Commission Scotland.The draft instrument is primarily a tidying-up measure as a result of changes to European legislation. It sets out the adjustments that will be made to payments under the Farm Woodland Premium Scheme 1992 (SI 1992/905), the Farm Woodland Premium Scheme 1997 (SI 1997/829) and the SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/209), in the case of land that is set aside from production under the single payment scheme. The instrument also formally closes the SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003 to new applicants.Since 1992, farm woodland schemes have encouraged woodland creation by providing annual payments for up to 15 years, to compensate farmers for loss of income as a result of converting agricultural land to woodland. The 1992 scheme was closed to new applicants in 1997 and replaced by the 1997 scheme, which in turn was closed in 2002 and replaced by the 2003 farmland premium scheme. However, payments continue to be made to agreement holders under on-going commitments. Therefore, the three schemes remain in operation but are closed to new applicants.The first adjustment concerns the relationship between the schemes and set-aside. After July 1995, European legislation specified that woodland used to meet a farmer's set-aside obligations would not attract a set-aside payment. Instead, the woodland would attract payment under the relevant farm woodland scheme. The legislation specified that payment could not exceed the prevailing set-aside rate—in other words, the farm woodland scheme payment rates had to be reduced to the prevailing set-aside rates. Under the new common agricultural policy regime, farmers can continue to use their afforested land to meet their set-aside obligations, but annual woodland payments will be reduced by the amount of the set-aside payments made under the single farm payment scheme for the land in question. The approach in the draft instrument will ensure that there is no double funding, so that the right amount is paid to scheme participants.The second adjustment closes the SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme 2003 to new applicants. Entry into the farm woodland schemes has always been conditional on the woodland concerned being planted with support under the Scottish forestry grants scheme, which is operated by Forestry Commission Scotland, towards planting and establishment costs. As the Scottish forestry grants scheme is now closed, that means that to all intents and purposes the farmland premium is unavailable to new applicants. The draft instrument formalises that closure.I hope that I have explained the background to the scheme and what the draft instrument is attempting to do.
Thank you for your explanation. Can you give us a ball-park figure for the number of people who will be affected by the change? How many people are served by the farmland premium scheme and the other schemes that are to be changed? Will people have their support cut off? What demand will not be met as a result of the closure of the scheme?
There are about 3,000 participants in the scheme, about 90 to 100 of whom use the set-aside option each year—doing so is purely optional.
Do you have any idea how much demand might not be met?
Do you mean demand for the scheme itself, as opposed to demand for the set-aside option?
Yes.
The scheme receives a steady stream of applications—perhaps 30 or 40 per month. Applicants will have to wait until the replacement scheme comes into effect.
I welcome the minister to the committee in her new role. Will the draft instrument simply make technical amendments and not lead to a reduction in the overall level of payment? I want to be quite clear about that.
Yes, in essence the amendments are technical. What happens next is that the Scottish rural development plan will bring in a new opportunity for woodland grant schemes under part 3 of the land management contract concept. The draft instrument that we are considering deals with the existing scheme and will close it to new applications, before we move on to the new system.
Will no one lose out?
No one who is currently getting money will lose out. We will then move on to the new system.
What is the timescale for the move to the new system? Will it have the capacity to cope with demand, given that there are currently 30 applications a month?
Land management contracts are being worked up. Officials from SEERAD, Forestry Commission Scotland and Scottish Natural Heritage are working together to ensure that an integrated package is developed. Our best guess would be for entry late in 2007. We hope to be able to deal with demand, because the amount of money that will be in the pot will be similar to the sums that were allocated in the past. However, the new scheme will be rather different and there will be more competition for it. Priorities might change over time.
The rural development plan will have to be approved by the European Commission. We are not quite there yet; the draft instrument is part of a process.
I presume that the optimum time for planting is the end of the year. Will a season be missed, or is that a silly question?
It is a bit early to say, but practical people might guess that there might be a bit less activity during this planting season—the 2007-08 season—than in previous years.
We will keep an eye on the issue as we move from the current scheme to the new one.
However, if there is a delay, we might end up actually skipping a year.
That is why we need to ensure that the land management contracts are put in place and that we get permission from Europe for the rural development plan. We place a lot of onus on ensuring that those things work.
I, too, welcome the minister to her new role.Further to Rob Gibson's point and that response to Nora Radcliffe's question, I have heard many concerns from forestry industry workers in Moray—which is the constituency that I represent—about the fact that much of the Government's effort on the financing and policy of the scheme seems to be directed at the recreational, rather than commercial, aspects of forestry. Can we be supplied with figures, either today or later, on how the financing of the current schemes is balanced between the promotion of the recreational aspects of forestry and the support of the commercial aspects?
I cannot give the committee those figures today, but I can certainly supply a breakdown of how the Scottish forestry grants scheme has been allocated across the broad priorities of the Scottish forestry strategy.
We will be happy to send that breakdown if the committee will find that helpful.
I have a quick follow-up question. If I heard correctly, James Simpson said that one might predict that the planting rates for 2007-08 will decline. Can he give us a context—what were the planting rates over the past few years? I understand that planting has declined over recent years.
I think that the decline is dependent on the availability of a scheme to which people can apply. At the moment, there is no scheme to which applications can be made. I should point out, however, that we have fully committed our budget for this year on the legacy schemes, so there will still be a lot of new planting under approved schemes that is not dependent on the new scheme being open to entrants.
Following up Richard Lochhead's question about the recreational use of forests, am I right in thinking that, as well as the recreational imperative, there is a straightforward economic benefit to be gained from the recreational use of forests, such as happens at Abriachan, and from all the different ways in which forests are now being used?
Absolutely, yes. In the Scottish forestry strategy, we took the approach that multiple objectives can apply to the use of woodlands. The growing of trees for timber can sit quite compatibly with the use of forests for tourism.
Thank you. Obviously, the committee might wish to keep an eye on some aspects of the issue.As there are no more questions, we will move to the debate on the motion.
The draft instrument is part of our on-going CAP reform process involving the production of land management contracts and the Scottish rural development plan. I hope that members will be happy to support the motion today so that we can get on with that work.I move,That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the draft Farm Woodland Premium Schemes and SFGS Farmland Premium Scheme Amendment (Scotland) Scheme 2007 be approved.
As no member wishes to speak, I will put the question, which is, that motion S2M-5340 be agreed to.
Motion agreed to.
We will have a short suspension while the minister's officials change over.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Jan 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 17 January 2007 Committee business · 1
- Convener Procedure · 5
- Marine Environment Inquiry Evidence session · 127
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 34
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 36
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.