Good morning, convener. I thank you and the rest of the committee for inviting me here to discuss this important order, which is a key component of our wider better environment programme with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency.
Scotland’s environment is a vital natural asset; protecting it is not just a valuable end in itself but is essential for our economic prosperity and the health and wellbeing of people in Scotland. Although everyone in this country has a part to play in helping to look after our environment, it is essential that bodies that have statutory obligations to protect and improve our environment, such as SEPA, have the powers that they need to do that job effectively.
The vast majority of individuals and businesses in Scotland already comply with the relevant environmental regulations. Indeed, a significant number of them go beyond compliance in recognising that waste reduction, resource efficiency and other good practice are not just beneficial for the environment but make good business sense.
However, when individuals or businesses deliberately or negligently harm Scotland’s environment, it is essential that SEPA has the right tools to protect our environment and communities, and to ensure that legitimate businesses are not undercut by criminals. It is simply unacceptable that anyone should profit by damaging our environment.
The order will implement most aspects of chapter 2 of part 3 of the Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 by making provision for a range of new enforcement measures for SEPA, which include fixed and variable monetary penalties, enforcement undertakings, non-compliance penalties and costs recovery notices. Those enforcement measures will provide SEPA with a better range of interventions to tackle poor performance, non-compliance and environmental crime, and will help to create a level playing field for businesses. They will also help SEPA to take a preventative approach by facilitating early engagement and intervention to prevent compliance issues from escalating and becoming prolonged or, through their deterrent effect, by preventing such issues from arising in the first place.
SEPA is well aware of the significance of the additional powers and responsibilities that we propose to give it, and it is committed to ensuring that the measures are used responsibly. In addition to the safeguards in the order, such as the right of individuals to make written representations and to appeal against enforcement decisions, SEPA is putting in place a wider range of safeguards to ensure that the new measures are used proportionately and effectively. Those safeguards include comprehensive training on the intent behind and the use of the new measures for SEPA officers, and the establishment of a robust internal review process that is designed to ensure appropriate and consistent use of the new measures within SEPA.
In addition, SEPA has recently completed a public consultation on its new enforcement policy and revised enforcement guidance. Those key documents provide transparency on the way in which SEPA will make enforcement decisions, and they set out not only what SEPA expects of regulated businesses, but what regulated businesses can expect from SEPA.
It is important to recognise that the new measures are part of a wider framework of environmental protection and that they will not be used in isolation. SEPA will continue to refer significant, persistent and deliberate offending to the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service for consideration of whether to prosecute, and close working between SEPA and the COPFS will be a key aspect of successful operation of the new framework.
The partnership working between SEPA and the COPFS will be underpinned by guidelines from the Lord Advocate, which will be issued shortly. Those guidelines will ensure that the new enforcement measures will be applied consistently and proportionately as part of the range of sanctions that are available, including prosecution.
Stakeholders have played a vital role in helping to develop the new enforcement measures, so I take the opportunity to thank all those who responded to the consultation or engaged through other means. The positive feedback that we have received has been vital in shaping our proposals, and I encourage stakeholders to continue to engage as we deliver the rest of the better environment regulation programme.
I am happy to answer questions.