Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”

Wednesday 28 October 2015 Public Audit Committee About 09:00–12:30 Committee business 844 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

844 contributions · showing 1–200
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Agenda item 2 is oral evidence on the Auditor General for Scotland’s report, “The 2013/14 audit of Coatbridge College: Governance of severance arrangements”. I confirm that all evidence will be in public. The committee expects witnesses to answer questions to the best of their ability. I advise witnesses that, should the committee deem it necessary, we may recall them to follow up on any matter that arises during the evidence taking.

All the people from whom the committee is scheduled to take evidence at this meeting and future meetings are here at the invitation of the committee. We welcome the assurances that we have been given that nothing said in evidence will be treated as breaching any confidentiality agreement. We have correspondence from the successor college to Coatbridge College confirming that. It is important to confirm that witnesses are free to answer questions that we put to them.

However, I point out that should any witness refuse to answer a question, we have the option of formally requiring them to return to answer our questions. In those circumstances, if any person who has been required to attend to provide evidence refuses or fails to answer the questions, they may be guilty of an offence.

I welcome our first panel of witnesses, who are from the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council: Laurence Howells, chief executive; and John Kemp, director of access, skills and outcome agreements. I understand that Laurence Howells has a short opening statement to make.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I thank the committee for the opportunity to provide evidence on the section 22 report on Coatbridge College. As the Auditor General’s report shows, we were concerned at the time about the approach that Coatbridge College was taking to the voluntary severance arrangements for the senior management team. We were very active in expressing those concerns to the chair and the principal of the college, and indeed to the whole board. As the AGS report says, we put those concerns in writing, we met the chair and the principal, and I took the rarely used step of exercising our power to insist on addressing the college board meeting.

I wrote to the college chair on 24 October 2013 asking that the college should not commit to the deal that was proposed to the principal until it had provided us with assurances that the arrangements were in accordance with good practice and represented value for the public. We were therefore dismayed that the college went ahead with the deal anyway.

We considered the scope for legal action to be taken to recover the money that had been spent, but after taking advice we concluded that the prospect of successful legal action was remote. We also considered whether we should withhold funding from or financially penalise the college after the event and concluded that, since those who had been involved had moved on, any financial penalties would simply damage the new college and impact on the staff and students of New College Lanarkshire.

Within the powers available to us at the time we could not prevent the college board from taking those decisions. However, since April 2014, all colleges have been required to seek approval from the SFC before taking such decisions. The new arrangements greatly reduce the risk of similar situations arising in the future. We are not complacent, of course. We need to be mindful of how we operate those powers and how we learn lessons from the events covered in the report.

I am happy to answer any questions that the committee has.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I am looking for clarity on some issues that we should put on record for the committee. First, can you confirm that you are the accountable officer for the Scottish funding council?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes, I am.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You are responsible for issuing funding as required, from the £1.5 billion provided to you per year.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can you confirm that your salary is within the bracket of £110,000 to £120,000 per annum?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

As part of your job, you have a significant responsibility to ensure best use of public funds. Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

In terms of the allocation of funding to Coatbridge College, ultimately you were responsible for ensuring that best value.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Were you concerned at any time that funds for the mergers process may have been allocated outwith the set parameters for severance payments?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

As you can see from the evidence, we were very concerned that the payments were not being made within the guidance that we had provided, that the proper processes had not been followed by the college board to evidence that they were value for money and that proper records were not being kept, so yes, we were concerned. However, it was within—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you ask the college to stop making the payments? You said that you were concerned, but did you at any time say, “No, you can’t make those payments, because they are beyond the parameters that we have set out. We ask you not to do that.”

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In my letter to the college on 24 October 2013, I asked it not to commit to the proposed deal until it had provided certain assurances.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can you confirm that those assurances were that the proposal would be passed by the external and internal auditors? Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You said that you would only commit up to 13 months’ salary.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

However, you said that the board itself could decide whether it wanted to extend the payment outwith the parameters of the 13 months. Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes, provided that the board could evidence that it had done that through a proper process and that it had—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What would the proper process be?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The proper process would be for the board to consider a business case, for—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

What would the business case say?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The business case would need to show that there was a good value-for-money reason for—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can you give me an example of a situation in which the board could have concluded that, yes, it was best value for money and it should pay that amount of money? For all we know, such a case could have been made. You did not say, “Please do not provide that amount because it is well outwith the parameters.” You waited until the decision was taken and then you said that you were pretty appalled by the decision. What were you appalled by? What concerns you?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Let us be clear. The reason that we—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Sorry, Mr Kemp. I will bring you in shortly, but I am asking Mr Howells to answer those questions.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We were clearly concerned about the arrangement that was being made. However, it was for the college to make the decision and it needed to justify it. It is clear from the correspondence that we did not feel that we had heard any justification for the decision. Nevertheless, it was for the college to make that decision. We went as far as we could within the powers that we had at the time.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I can see from the exchange of correspondence that you were involved in the process, Mr Kemp, so this is a question for you. When were you advised that the BACS payment was made to Mr Doyle? What date was it?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I think that it was on 25 October 2013. We had appeared at the board on 23 October. We followed that up with a letter on 24 October and we were advised by the incoming chair on 25 October.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You were advised on the evening of 23 October that the decision had been taken to increase the payments.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We were not advised on the evening of 23 October. We attended the board and made a presentation to it. The board did not tell us on that evening what the outcome of the discussion was.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

When did you find out?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We followed that up with a letter on 24 October and we found out—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Given your concerns, did you not phone the college to ask what decision it had taken?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

You can perhaps follow that up with Mr Gray later. We made several attempts to contact Mr Gray to find out the outcome of the meeting, but the eventual response that we got was from the incoming chair, Tom Keenan—on 25 October, I think.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you call the college the day after the meeting to say that you had heard that there was a board meeting the previous night? Did anybody advise you about what happened at the board meeting? You did not hear from anybody that a decision had been taken.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We contacted the college the following day, but the main contact was with—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Nobody in the Scottish funding council was aware of the decision.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We were attempting to find out what had happened. I was not at the board meeting, but Laurence Howells and my colleague Sharon Drysdale were there and they made a presentation. I think that part of the decision was taken in the remuneration committee prior to the board meeting, so its members were not present at that discussion at the board meeting. We followed it up the following day with the person who had been chair, but he had stood down at that meeting and did not respond. We got a response from the incoming chair the following day.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The BACS payment had already been made by that point.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Was it in Mr Doyle’s bank account or was it being processed?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I could not say whether it was in Mr Doyle’s bank account, but—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The reason for my questioning on this is that we have seen ministers use legislation recently in respect of Glasgow Clyde College. Was that considered in this instance? You were obviously concerned. There were governance issues across the whole year in respect of the college; it was not something that just popped up that particular October. From your exchanges it is clear that you were obviously concerned throughout the whole year that there might be governance issues. Did you not think that you could possibly use the legislation that the minister used effectively recently at Glasgow Clyde College to close down the board, appoint new board members and ensure that the process would be carried out properly?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

On the timing, it is worth saying that the issue was first discussed by the college in January. It had sought advice from the funding council and we wrote to it on 24 January with that advice, which you have seen. We were not aware until October that it had not taken that advice.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So you had no issues about governance. You were happy with governance at Coatbridge College for that entire year. From January until October you had no concerns. Is that right? That is not what your correspondence says.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

On the issue of the severance payments, we had no indication until early October that the college had not taken the advice.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Was that not the point when you could have approached the minister? Did you ever approach the minister to say that you were concerned about what was going on at Coatbridge College?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We did not approach the minister. We kept Scottish Government officials informed of the process.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We kept them informed of the process in relation to the merger generally and in relation to the—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Did you say that you were concerned about the college?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I could not say that we said that we were concerned about general governance of the college. We were certainly concerned about the progress of the merger and about—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You wanted Mr Doyle to move on, did you not? Did you want him to move on? Was he getting in the way of the merger process?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We wanted a successful merger. I am sure that we wanted that to be done well and we wanted it to create the college that we wanted. It was for the different parties to decide at the end of the day who would be the principal and how that would come about. Our primary concern remained the best way to organise college education in Lanarkshire.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes—I would concur with that. The concerns that we had about Coatbridge College between January and October were about the progress of the merger.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So there were no governance issues at all.

I have a final question. I can see that your exchanges, which you would argue are pretty robust, refer to ensuring that the deal was agreed with the external and internal auditors. Can I take it that you had contact with the internal and external auditors during the process? Is that something that you would do?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We can follow this up in writing, but my recollection is that one of my colleagues contacted the auditors of not just Coatbridge College but other colleges on that guidance.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It was written into the SFC’s guidance in 2000 that such arrangements should be passed over to the external and internal auditors. Should you not have contacted the external and internal auditors to make sure that the deals were agreed by you? Is it your understanding that the deals were not passed to the external and internal auditors?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Clearly, the external auditors picked up as a matter of emphasis in the report—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

On the contact that you had with auditors about your experience of the issue, were both internal and external auditors aware of the severance agreements that were being proposed? Were the agreements passed by the auditors, which is what Mr Howells said in his correspondence that he wanted to ensure?

09:15

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Our guidance is that they should be. The process is that the college should make a business case and pass it by the auditors. I do not think that it did that—not at the time.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So the auditors were not made aware. It surprises me that you would not know that.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We asked the college to assure us that it had those assurances—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I would expect you to follow that up and say, “Listen folks, we want to make sure, so we will contact the internal and external auditors to ensure that they are happy with what the college advises, given that we are talking about a serious amount of public money—significant six-figure sums.” Did you not do that?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Well, maybe we could have done more to talk to the internal and external auditors. When I wrote, I asked the college to assure itself and to talk to the internal auditors, and I asked it to report that back to me explicitly. That did not happen: the board went ahead and made the payments.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Could you have stopped the payments being made? Audit Scotland told me that technically you could have done that.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We could have stopped payments to the college by us, but as far as I am aware we could not have stopped the college making payments to Mr Doyle.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You could have done that if you had intervened in the way that ministers intervened in relation to Glasgow Clyde College. Why did you not do that?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The process of what has happened at Glasgow Clyde College has been fairly lengthy. What we are talking about took place over a couple of weeks.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

It did not. It took place from January to October. We can see that from the exchanges that took place. Even if it had taken place over a couple of weeks, it should have been of concern to you. You said that you were appalled at the decision that was taken to award the enhanced severance payments. Surely over a couple of weeks you could have said, “Minister, we’re really concerned about this and we want you to get in there and use the legislative measures that allow us to take over the board.”

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It is important to be right about the timescale. We gave guidance in January on severance, in response to a request from Mr Gray. We had no indication until early October that the guidance had not been followed. We did not see the minute of the remuneration committee’s January meeting until October. During the intervening period, although we had concerns about progress on the merger—with Coatbridge being in the merger, then out of it, and so on—we had no indication that there was an issue about how the board was dealing with the severance guidance.

On whether the powers that were used in relation to Glasgow Clyde College could have been used in this context, the upshot of the issues at Clyde was that the board was replaced. In the case of Coatbridge College, the chair and principal were going anyway.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I have a final question for Mr Howells. The merger process was a significant one. You knew throughout the process that severance payments would have to be made. Should you not have realised at the beginning of the process that there were potential conflicts of interest if principals dealt with the issue and that there was every possibility that colleges would award severance payments well above what you were proposing?

Surely we have to put in preventative measures. It is a bit like saying to the kids, “We’ve left a box of matches on the table top, but don’t play with them”, and then just leaving the kids to play with them. You cannot leave yourselves open to potential abuse. You did not use the powers that were available to you to prevent abuse. Have you reflected on that?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed. I guess that we could have—

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

The horse has bolted, has it not?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The horse has bolted. I guess that we could have emphasised even more strongly our severance guidance and we could have been even more active in supervising colleges in making such deals—of course, with hindsight, I would have wanted to do that.

I keep coming back to the point that when we were aware of the issues we were very active, as you can see from the documentation. I guess that my expectation was that the college board would listen to the advice, including the advice that I gave when I talked to the board directly, and would act accordingly.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I want to raise two main issues, given that no member here represents Lanarkshire. Who was in charge of the merger process, nationally?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In terms of the merger process, well, ultimately—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It was announced by the Government and every party supported it. Who was in charge? Were you the accountable officer for the merger process?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes. It was SFC’s responsibility to implement the process.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. Why did you have difficulties in Lanarkshire? Why did Coatbridge College agree to the merger, within a month disagree to it and within six months agree again? What happened there?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I think that Dr Kemp would be better to answer that.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

From the beginning, when regionalisation was announced, Coatbridge College had been in favour of a merger of all the colleges in Lanarkshire. It had said so and had come to the funding council and made a case for merger. However, it had done so without consulting any of the other colleges in Lanarkshire, so part of the issue was that there was no consensus among the four colleges in Lanarkshire on the way forward. Three of them wanted to have a federation. Coatbridge had publicly stated that it wanted a merger of all four, but it had not discussed that with the other three.

The merger began after a period in which federation had been being explored for some time. Motherwell and Cumbernauld then announced that they wanted to merge, and Coatbridge came in, given its previous support for merger.

When Coatbridge came in a month or so after the merger had begun, the other two colleges were quite concerned not to go backwards. They had started a process, set up working groups and made some decisions about the shape of the merger, and they did not want to go backwards on that.

Once Coatbridge joined the merger, there was some friction between the three colleges about the extent to which things that had already been decided should be unpicked because Coatbridge was now in. That friction was discussed at the meeting of the merger partnership board in February and, as a result of that, Coatbridge left the merger.

I was at that meeting. My view was that the issues were not so significant that they should have led to Coatbridge leaving the merger. In the months after that, we sought to bring Coatbridge back in, but it took some time before an arrangement could be reached that would bring it back in. It did not decide to join again until late summer.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Let us try to keep the answers shorter and more succinct.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I am just trying to make you understand why there was friction between the two sides.

The key point is that, although we had a role in supporting the mergers, they were carried out by autonomous institutions that decided that they wished to merge. We did not control the process in the sense of having the power to insist that anyone merge.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Well, Laurence Howells has just said that he was in control of the mergers and that he was the accountable officer in control of the mergers. We need to be clear about that.

What I am trying to understand is why Coatbridge College opted in, then opted out and then came back in again. I will ask you again: was Coatbridge College an impediment to the mergers, was it looking for something that the other colleges did not agree with and were the severance payments part of the negotiations within the mergers?

I cannot understand why none of the 33 senior staff at Coatbridge was employed at New College Lanarkshire. What happened there? The word “takeover” rather than “merger” was used. Was that the case? Was there bad feeling that led to the severance payments? Did the staff perhaps think that, as they were not getting anything out of New College, they would just go for the severance payments, because they had nothing to lose? Am I reading it right?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I cannot speculate on why staff in Coatbridge College chose voluntary severance instead of jobs in the new college. I think that you are correct that, of the senior staff, none of them sought—or obtained—jobs in New College Lanarkshire.

However, the issues that led to friction between Coatbridge College and Cumbernauld and Motherwell colleges were about the progress of the merger—how the workstreams were operated and the speed of the merger. They were not about voluntary severance; we were not aware of that issue until fairly late on.

For the sake of completeness, I just want to say that once the severance issue came up as part of the due diligence process in early October 2013, the other two merging partners clearly had some concerns about it. Here was an apparent agreement to a particular severance deal that was not part of the Lanarkshire colleges merger deal and that left a liability that could—had it gone ahead for the whole of the senior management—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. Before I go on to my second question, was there any change in the severance arrangements at Coatbridge College between January and July, when the college agreed to opt in again?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Between January and July we were not aware of the severance arrangements at Coatbridge. We found out only in early October, as I said.

We had given guidance in January, the remuneration committee had made decisions and deals had been offered—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. You have taken me cleanly on to my second point.

Mr Howells, to whom at Coatbridge College did you, as the accountable officer, give guidance to say, “Stay within this scheme, which has been perfectly acceptable for the other colleges in Lanarkshire, and don’t go above that level”?

To whom did you give the guidance that was not given to the remuneration committee?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

At several points in the process we gave that guidance directly to the chair, and obviously—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So John Gray received that guidance.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes. Obviously, when I addressed the board, I summarised the guidance to it, and—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But you were not at the board until October. I am talking about—

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Earlier in the process, the guidance had been on our website, and the colleges’ principals had had it drawn to their attention.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So John Doyle and John Gray had the guidance on keeping within the level of severance payments in January and February.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is quite clear from the information that we have, including the Auditor General’s report, that the guidance was not given to the remuneration committee. Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Not having been at that remuneration committee—

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Well, it is confirmed in the Auditor General’s report, and I presume that you would agree with that.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed, yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

If an accountable officer withholds information from a committee that is making major decisions on hundreds of thousands of pounds, what word would you use to describe that?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The word that I have used—I would say that I am dismayed by that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am not looking for your opinion. I am looking for the word that would be used.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I do not think that that is appropriate.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Well, can I tell you what is appropriate? I looked in the dictionary yesterday, and withholding information is called “deceit”. That is the definition in the dictionary.

The Scottish public finance manual uses

“The term ‘fraud’ ... to describe a wide variety of dishonest behaviour”

including

“deception, forgery, false representation, and concealment of material facts”,

and states that

“It is usually used to describe the act of depriving a person of something by deceit”.

I do not want to take up all my allocated time, but we have the evidence from David Craig and others to say that the remuneration committee did not have the information that you gave to the college. The committee therefore made a decision to give the principal 30 months’ salary and whatever else to top it up.

The committee made that decision as honestly as it could, assuming that it was working with the guidance. The committee members were not dishonest people—they were not given the information that you gave to John Gray and John Doyle.

Do you agree that that critical piece of information, which has led to us all being here today, was concealed from the remuneration committee, and that that is why the committee made the decision that it did?

The information was withheld, I should say.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Withheld—yes. I think that that is true. Again, part of my reason for attending the board was to ensure that I had spoken to every board member and that they had heard it from me.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Right. I will leave it there for now.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I want to pick up on a point that the convener made in connection with the actual payments. Presumably there was a transfer of funding from the SFC to the college in order to facilitate the payment. When was the decision taken to make that payment?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We would have made that payment retrospectively, some time in March 2014, because those deals were run on a claims basis. Retrospectively, a £1.3 million contribution would have been claimed by the college.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

When you say “retrospectively”—

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The events would have happened and the payments would have been made. We would have paid the money the following year.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

So you physically made the payment in March.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We received the claim in March; we probably made the payment a little later than that. Do you know when, John?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I am not sure when we actually made the physical payment, but the claims were made the following year, towards March, which was later than usual for the mergers.

09:30

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You obviously had a lot of concerns about the scheme that was being proposed. It could not take place unless you made a payment and it is the timing of that payment that I am concerned about. You said that your concerns arose in October 2013. Was the payment made before then, and if so, on what basis—against what business case?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We did not make the payment to the college until the following year.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

That was a payment based on the Lanarkshire voluntary severance scheme, about which we did not have concerns. That scheme went up to broadly a one-year—13-month—payback. We only paid the amount that would be allowed under that scheme. We did not pay the excess amount in the case of Mr Doyle.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But if, when you reached the conclusion that there was a problem in October 2013, you had said to the college that in the circumstances it was inappropriate to make the payment, would the college have gone ahead?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In effect, we told the board that we did not think that it had created the case to make the payment; we did that at the board meeting. As you heard earlier, the board made the payment a couple of days later. We could, retrospectively, have said to the college that we were not going to contribute to that particular item. We chose not to do that because by that point—a year on—the people responsible had moved on.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You went to a board meeting on 23 October 2013.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

What might have happened if you had said at that meeting that you were not going to pay?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In addition to the concerns that I was expressing at the time, I could have said that I would not pay if the board operated the scheme on that basis. I guess that at that point I was trying to say, “Here’s the guidance; please follow it. If you follow it you will have a proper scheme.” I was hoping at that point to persuade the board to make that decision.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

When you left that board meeting, what was your impression of what had been decided? What did you think that the board was going to do? You did not stay for the whole meeting, obviously.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed. My impression was that I had been listened to, and my expectation was that the board would take the advice and act accordingly.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Would you say that there was an issue about the due diligence process in relation to the payment from the SFC? Were you satisfied that you were paying against a scheme that was compliant?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

I emphasise that our payments were under the Lanarkshire scheme and that we only paid up to the amount that was claimed under the Lanarkshire scheme. We were happy with the Lanarkshire scheme—it had broadly a one-year payback of the kind that we were supporting. We were always clear that we would not pay the payments in excess of the 13 months for Mr Doyle.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That is understood, but I would have hoped that, as part of the process of due diligence, you might have taken a more robust stance. In retrospect, do you think that that would have been appropriate?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

With hindsight, perhaps we could have behaved differently. Our judgment at the time was that if we did not pay any of the VS it would not make any difference to the college’s actions. Indeed, we attended the board meeting on 23 October and by 25 October the payment had been made. Any action that we took then not to pay even the amount payable under the Lanarkshire VS scheme would only have damaged the new college. That was the balance that we were considering in deciding whether to pay.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

But if it had been made clear on 23 October that your payment was contingent on the overall plan being compliant, would we not have been able to avoid a lot of the trouble?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It is possible that that might have added influence. We could have been even more robust at that meeting. We could have added that to the conversation. As I said, my expectation was that the college board would live within the rules.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I have looked at the correspondence that you had in October 2013, and some of it is, as has been referred to, relatively robust. However, you did not get responses despite repeated attempts to contact people. Did that not make you suspicious? Did it not make you concerned? Were you not worried?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed, and that is why there was an escalating level of concern and why I insisted on addressing the board. A board meeting is an opportunity for me to ensure that the entire board knows what the situation is.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Were you aware of when the board was going to make the payments?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

That was not part of the discussion.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

In our correspondence, we asked it not to commit to the payments.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Did it respond to that verbally or in any other way?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

There was silence—it just ignored what you had put to it.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Obviously so, because then the action was taken.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You have talked briefly about the guidance that was issued. My understanding is—I think that I have a copy of the guidance somewhere in my pile of paper—that you sent out a circular in 2000. Was that the last time that you sent out any reminder on remuneration?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

On 24 January 2013, the chair of Coatbridge College contacted Mark Batho, the then chief executive of the funding council. That same day, Mark Batho sent out an email, enclosing the guidance, with a paragraph that explained the emerging practice across the sector on one-year paybacks and so on. Therefore, in the case of Coatbridge College—and in many other colleges, too—the chair was sent, right at the beginning of the process, the guidance and an email explaining how it should be applied and what the emerging practice was.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Was it your expectation that that information would be shared with the board and the remuneration committee, and that the guidance would be complied with?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Good morning. The Scottish funding council is the accountable body and Mr Howells is the accountable officer for the guidance and for college due diligence, including on mergers. I am concerned about how the Scottish funding council guarantees that you do due diligence to your best to ensure that responsibilities are carried out properly and timeously.

We have heard that you did not hear from the college for a number of months on the merger, and you have mentioned that you were actively raising concerns. Does the Scottish funding council receive the minutes of the meetings held by colleges that are going through a merger? Do you go along to meetings? Is that part of your job?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We are involved in many ways during a merger process. There is usually a partnership board or something of that nature that we would attend, and we would assist the college to make progress. That is a normal part of how we do business.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is a normal part of the job. However, the evidence—both written and oral—shows that months passed when you did not hear anything at all. I know that that raised concerns, but not to the point where you went along to the meetings or ensured that someone attended them, or insisted on receiving the minutes of the meetings.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Just to be clear, the issue that we did not hear anything about for some time was whether the remuneration committee had dealt with our severance guidance. Throughout the merger process in 2013, we were in constant contact with the two colleges that were merging. We were also in contact with Coatbridge College—we made many attempts to encourage it to reconsider its decision—

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I do not mean to interrupt, but that raises another issue. The only area that you did not seem to have any information about was the severance payments. Did the Scottish funding council meet Mr Doyle to discuss the severance payments prior to the board meeting?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

During the summer of 2013, when Coatbridge College was considering rejoining the merger, I met Mr Doyle and had phone calls with him and the then director of finance at Coatbridge College about the arrangements for rejoining the merger. At one of those meetings, there was discussion about what VS scheme would apply. By that time, the other two merging parties had pretty much developed a VS scheme, which was the one that was eventually used. I recall at least one meeting at which Coatbridge College suggested that the VS scheme for the merger should cover a period of up to 21 months. My response was that the SFC would fund up to one year only and that the usual practice in mergers had been broadly in line with our one-year funding.

Therefore, there were some discussions about the VS scheme for the whole merger and all the staff, but there were no discussions about a VS package for the principal or the senior management team. We were unaware until October that the remuneration committee had taken a decision on that in January.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

You said that you had a meeting when you talked about the college and the merger, but the VS scheme also came into play in the discussions that you had with Mr Doyle, during which the fact was raised that the 13-month period was the normal one and was your recommendation for the merger with the other colleges. I presume that Mr Doyle and the college’s finance director raised then that they were looking at some other package. Did that not sound alarm bells for you? Should you not have chased that up?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

There were alarm bells around the fact that they were being unreasonable about what we would fund for the merger. In the discussions that I had with them, they were talking about a scheme for the whole staff—it was not a special deal for the senior management team or the principal. In many discussions on mergers, people asked us to fund schemes that were more generous than what we would actually fund. It is not all that unusual for a college to say that it would like us to fund a scheme that goes up to X amount, and for me to say that we will only fund up to a one-year payback. Therefore, what was said was not that unusual, and it did not set alarm bells ringing on the issues that led to the section 22 report.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

You were under the impression that if the severance scheme that was different from the other colleges in terms of the 13 month-period went ahead, the Scottish funding council would pay out £1.36 million—the standard amount that you had advised people of—and the rest of the money would be paid out of the college’s budget.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

So that was your understanding. You were quite happy with that. Maybe “happy” is the wrong word, but you accepted that.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It was allowable within the rules for us to pay a particular amount for a voluntary severance scheme and for a college to pay more than that for the reasons that were in our guidance: if it could make a business case for it and if the college’s auditors were happy with it. You are right that I might not have been happy with what was being done, but it was allowable within the rules.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We would have been very concerned had there been more than one voluntary severance scheme for the Lanarkshire merger. We would not have thought that it was appropriate for one group of staff to be treated differently.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I accept that it was within the rules then, which I know were changed in April 2014. However, were you not concerned by the fact that, of the three colleges, two set a 13-month payback, but the other college, some of whose staff were paid X amount of money, took money from the college’s public funds to pay certain members of staff? You mentioned in your opening remarks that you considered legal advice on whether it was possible to claim the money back or whatever. I do not know what you were told about that, because you did not say, but it seems that you were told that you should not go ahead with legal action. Are you able to tell the committee what that legal advice was and why you could not pursue the fact that one college operated differently for some of its staff in paying out severance pay?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

For the record, the Lanarkshire scheme operated as one scheme for the vast bulk of the staff. However, we were concerned particularly about the payments to the principal in this case, so we asked for legal advice about whether there was any prospect of being able to recover that money. The advice was that there was an extremely remote prospect of recovering the money. That was the basis on which we took the pragmatic decision that putting more public money into pursuing a legal case that was very unlikely to be successful was not the best use of public money.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I will pick up on Mary Scanlon’s question about the fact that papers were not given to board members. Surely any legal advice would be that withholding such information—Mary Scanlon looked this up in a dictionary and elsewhere—would be a case of deceit that could constitute fraud.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The legal advice to us, based on all those circumstances, was that a case would be so unlikely to succeed that it would not be worth the money to pursue it.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Can we get access to that legal advice? Was it from somebody who worked in your organisation or from an external partner?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It was from our lawyers at DLA Piper. We do not have internal lawyers.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

So they provided specific legal advice at that specific time.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Yes.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

When would that have been?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

It was at the time that the situation was going on.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

We can perhaps discuss that further so the committee can reflect on the legal advice.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Howells, your letter of 10 October to John Doyle was very clear that the costs over and above the standard scheme would have to be met from the college’s own reserves. You were actually saying to the college at that point, “What you do is up to you, but you must justify it, and that is the guidance—you have to do that now.”

You then moved on to say more strongly, on 11 October, that you required a response to your letter with the required information. However, you never received that information—at least, we do not have papers that indicate that you received the business case at any point.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We never did.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Mr Kemp, you wrote on 16 October with a very specific request for information. In the meantime, Mr Doyle had said that the college was taking internal and external advice, and that it would provide that to you. Did it ever provide that advice to you?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

After the board meeting—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The college board meeting on 23 October. After the decision had been taken, we received a minute of the board meeting, a minute of the remuneration committee meeting and a letter from the college’s lawyers explaining their view on the legality of what the college had done. I think that that information is in your papers.

However, we did not receive a written response prior to that point. We met with Mr Doyle, Mr Gray and the college’s director of finance. As part of that meeting, we also met specifically just with Mr Gray to discuss the principal’s package.

Some of the response was verbal, but—as you can see from the follow-up letters and our attendance at the board meeting—it did not satisfy us.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Okay.

As a standard practice, you do not receive the minutes of remuneration committees.

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

No.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Should you be receiving them? I understand that the minutes would have to be approved by the board. Nevertheless, a board might intend to do something that would contravene your guidance—and without justification, which was the situation in January 2013. Should you not normally receive remuneration committee minutes, or draft minutes that are sent to the board for approval?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

We need to strike a balance between our completely managing colleges and our setting rules and monitoring whether those rules are complied with. We need to look at where that balance sits, but we would be uncomfortable with a position in which we looked at every board paper from every college, second-guessing whether decisions were right or wrong.

College boards have a role in the process—it is the prime role. If a board’s judgment is substituted too much with that of the funding council, we would be in quite a different place.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am not inviting you to take control of all the colleges. What I am saying to you, and particularly to Mr Howells as the accountable officer, is that you are not receiving information on the basis of monitoring, as Mr Kemp just said—I am not talking about interfering; I am talking about monitoring—because if you do not get remuneration committee minutes, you are not in a position to monitor.

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

Indeed—we potentially need to do more on monitoring the whole operation of colleges. That is something for us to reflect on.

In this particular case, given the changes to the colleges since April 2014, we would be in a different situation, as colleges would have to ask permission before doing such things.

How we monitor the whole operation of colleges, and not just severance and remuneration, is an important question. As part of the SFC’s system we have outcome agreement managers allocated to individual colleges who are responsible for gathering intelligence and identifying points of risk. That is something that we in SFC will think about over the next few months. We will think about how we up our game in that respect.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I know that you asked the college to formally withdraw the more favourable deal for the six. However, you were not in a position to instruct it to do that; you could only invite it to do so. Is that correct?

Laurence Howells Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

At the time, that was correct.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

My final question is about your discussions with Government officials. Can you give us a timeline on that? At what point did you discuss issues to do with severance, in particular? After you first learned about the issue on or around 10 October, what discussions did you have with Government officials before the final decision was made and payments were made?

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The Government would have found out about the issue at around the same time as we did, because it was part of the change team and was involved in the partnership board meetings. It was aware, at the same time as we were, of what was going on and what we were doing about it. The prime responsibility for action lay with us, but the Government wrote to Mr Gray to back up what we were saying and to ask for assurances that proper processes were being followed. We were in constant contact with the Government over the weeks that this was going on.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Right. That was just in the period in October, was it? What about the partnership meetings when Coatbridge was coming back into the process, when the college expressed the view, as you told us, that—

John Kemp Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council
link

The Government was involved in that. The on-going support for the merger involved the Government. On the specific issue of severance, the Government found out at the same time as we did, and it was made aware of all the actions that we were taking.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You said earlier that when Coatbridge came back into the process there were discussions about a separate severance scheme, with a lump sum of 21 months of salary. According to the correspondence, at that stage it was the aspiration or the intention to apply the approach to all staff, but there was to be a separate scheme nevertheless.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:00 Section 22 Report Committee business · 844

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.