Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Alzheimer’s and Dementia Awareness (PE1480)

Tuesday 6 October 2015 Public Petitions Committee About 11:30–11:45 Petitions 18 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

18 contributions
Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Agenda item 3 is consideration of PE1480 by Amanda Kopel on behalf of the Frank Kopel Alzheimer’s awareness campaign, on Alzheimer’s and dementia awareness. Members have a note from the clerk and submissions on the petition.

I thank Shona Robison, the Cabinet Secretary for Health, Wellbeing and Sport, for staying with us; indeed, I appreciate her taking so much time out this morning to help us look at the petitions before us. For this item, she is accompanied by David Fotheringham and Mike Liddle from the integration and reshaping care division of the Scottish Government.

I invite the cabinet secretary to make some opening comments, after which we will go to questions.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

Thank you, convener. I welcome this opportunity to come back to the committee and speak about social care, in particular Amanda Kopel’s petition on charging and dementia awareness. I have met Amanda to discuss her campaign on a number of occasions, most recently on 25 September, and I pay tribute to her tenacity in pursuing this issue in memory of her late husband Frank.

At that meeting on 25 September, I explained some of the work that we as a Government have been doing to improve the fairness of and consistency in social care charges. Over the year, my officials have been working with Professor David Bell from the University of Stirling on a full assessment of the costs involved in a number of different scenarios related to social care charging. We have completed that work and are now using its findings to look at the budgets for the spending review period and to work out, in partnership with local government, precisely what the best options are to make the system of charging for social care fairer. That aim will be at the heart of any changes that we make, because the system has to be fair to everyone with a long-term condition who requires social care.

Amanda Kopel has widened her petition from its original focus on those with Alzheimer’s or dementia to include those with other degenerative diseases such as motor neurone disease. We must ensure that any charging system is for people born with a range of conditions, not just those that I have mentioned, and that any changes that we make to the charging system are fair to all service users. That is the focus of our attention. Moreover, any change must also be sustainable. After all, we cannot make changes to the system without ensuring that they will be affordable further down the line.

11:45

In addition to the work that I have mentioned, we have over the past year worked with our partners in local government on some changes such as ensuring that those who are assessed by their doctor or consultant as being in the last six months of a terminal illness are not charged for the care that they receive at home. That has been an important step forward in improving the fairness of the charging system, as it ensures that those with only a short time left are able to spend time with their loved ones without worrying about paying social care bills.

Nevertheless, there is more to do. The Government is treating the issue as a priority, and we will be looking at the best ways of improving the fairness of the charging system for all service users.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

Thank you, cabinet secretary. I will kick off our questions. Do you in principle support the petition’s aims?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

In principle, the petition calls for something that I agree with—a fairer charging system—but we cannot have such a system for only specific conditions. You will understand that, if we were to say, “We’re going to have a fairer charging system for this list of conditions”, people would say, “Wait a minute—that’s not fair” and highlight another list of conditions. What we have had to do, and what we are doing, is to look at how we can make the system fairer for everyone.

The bones of the petition relate to having a fairer charging system, and Amanda Kopel will get agreement from me on that. We are working on what such a system should look like; as you will appreciate, there are various models and various things that we could do. What we need to do is to come up with the fairest, best and most sustainable model, and of course we have to get agreement from local government on taking that forward.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I understand that, but that is a consideration that we always have to make. If everything was a priority, nothing would be. The fact is that we do have priorities. There are lots of areas in the health service and social services where support is given to one group in our community but not to others. Those are choices that we have to make. They are difficult ones, but they are made regularly. Could we not accept that the example that has been brought before us is one of those areas that require to be a priority? Arguments might well be made for other areas, and we can hear them, but if we accept the principle in relation to Alzheimer’s, we can deal with that problem and move things forward.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

I am worried that if we were to say that, for example, we were going to have a fairer charging system but it would apply only to people with Alzheimer’s, such a move could be legally challenged by someone with another condition who would say, “Why have you selected only people with Alzheimer’s or dementia?”

To be fair to Amanda Kopel, I think that she has recognised that, which is why, when I met her recently, she talked about people with life-limiting conditions. She recognises that the focus has to be broader than just people with Alzheimer’s or dementia, and that is why we are focusing on how we reform the system and make it fairer to all service users who currently have to pay charges.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

As I have said, we accept that such considerations have to be made. How long do you think it will take to finalise your deliberations?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

We are in the midst of the spending review period and as yet we have not heard what our budgets will look like in the light of UK Government decisions. Indeed, we will not hear about that until November.

In advance of that, however, a lot of detailed work is going on around the priorities for social care, and that is forming the basis of our discussions with local government. There are three elements to that work: fairer charging; progress on the living wage; and social care capacity. As you will appreciate, those are all social care issues, and we want to make sure that we can move forward on all of them. We need to get agreement with local government on that and, as far as the spending review is concerned, we need to make sure that we can afford whatever we do not just for one year but for the entire spending review period.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I accept that such decisions are very difficult. However, the fact is that in a whole host of areas we already differentiate not just between certain conditions and others but, within those conditions, between people of a certain age and others. As you will also understand, it could be argued that differentiating in that way within illnesses and conditions could also be open to challenge; for example, people over a certain age can benefit from financial support, while those who are below that age cannot. That, too, might be seen as discriminatory. Therefore, allowing someone with a particular condition but not someone else with a different condition to receive support requires a judgment to be made at some point.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

I think that it would be very difficult to take that approach. You would no doubt get people sitting before you, saying, “Hang on a minute. You made personal care free for those with Alzheimer’s and dementia, but what about multiple sclerosis, motor neurone disease and cystic fibrosis?” Before long, the committee would get a petition that focuses on one of those conditions and says that the system is not fair.

Instead of waiting for that to happen, I have taken the approach that any changes to charging must be based on the principle of fairness and applied to everyone who is entitled to receive care. If we do not do that, we will get into a very difficult position. To be fair to her, Amanda Kopel has, as I have made clear, recognised that you have to look at other life-limiting degenerative conditions, not just at one.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

I think that the case that you have outlined is reasonable, cabinet secretary. I understand what you are saying.

However, just to be clear, am I right in thinking that, in the work that you have done, you have isolated a series of conditions to which you think the new charging regime should apply to in order for it to be fair and that you are now waiting on budgetary confirmation in order to go forward, or are you saying that the budgetary confirmation will determine the list or the inclusivity of the basket of conditions—if I can refer to them that way—to which the new regime would apply? Are you saying that the regime would just have to be universal and that, irrespective of the condition, it would have to be available for absolutely everything? I am not quite clear what you are trying to narrow down.

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

We are absolutely trying to avoid lists of conditions, because we will always miss one, and that will be the condition that will form the basis of the next petition to this committee and to me, saying that the system is not fair. We are trying to avoid that scenario.

Of course, people will always have to meet eligibility criteria for care, which means that this will always be about people who require care rather than about people having a condition and wanting care. Those eligibility criteria and requirements for care will always be there. However, we are trying to get to a position where the system is fairer to everybody who at the moment has to pay charges, which in some cases can be considerable. Indeed, for those under 65 years old, it can be quite challenging.

That said, there are various models for and ways of making charging fairer. For example, we can look at free personal and nursing care for the under-65s, and we can also look at the threshold at which people start to pay charges. What I am saying is that we have not reached our final conclusions on what is the best option, what we can get local government to agree to deliver and what is sustainable and affordable. At the moment, we are considering those options and discussing them further.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

If I understand you correctly, you are talking about a universal provision, subject to eligibility criteria, that would not be specifically condition related, because you want to avoid that scenario. The matter of the threshold is the subject of another petition that we are pursuing and which has been with local government for quite some time, but that is not an issue for today.

I return to the convener’s question about when you expect progress to be made. You have identified budgetary constraints that will become clear this year. Is that or is that not the point at which you will know what you are going to be able to do and at which you will be able to make a decision on about how things will progress?

Shona Robison SNP Dundee City East
link

What we decide to do and what spending decisions we make will be part of the spending review. Those announcements will be made in due course.

The problem at the moment is that we can anticipate what the landscape will be and make decisions based on that, but we will not be entirely sure about what the landscape will look like until decisions are made elsewhere and we know what the budgets are like. Despite that, we will be reaching positions about where we would like to get to and what our priorities are in the spending review. Obviously, the spending review process is quite detailed and involves not only my directorate but a dialogue with other directorates and local government.

We have done a considerable amount of work, which forms the basis of how we make those decisions, but within that there are choices to be made about what options we choose. Although all of them have merit, some might have more merit than others. We need to come to final conclusions on that.

Jackson Carlaw Con West Scotland
link

From what you are saying, is it reasonable to expect that, before the dissolution of Parliament next March, we will have an understanding of what the Government feels that it will be able to do?

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

That has been helpful, cabinet secretary.

As members have no further questions, does the committee agree to wait until a future meeting so that we can collate information and then come to a decision about how we should take forward the petition?

Members indicated agreement.

Michael McMahon Lab The Convener · Uddingston and Bellshill
link

I thank the cabinet secretary and her officials for joining us, and I suspend the meeting for a few minutes to allow them to leave.

11:58 Meeting suspended.

11:59 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 132
  3. 11:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 18
  4. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  6. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  8. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 12:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.