link
To ask the Scottish Government when the Crown Office was first notified of the allegations of mortgage fraud against Christopher Hales. (S4T-01133)
Official Report · Chamber
Topical Question Time
link
To ask the Scottish Government when the Crown Office was first notified of the allegations of mortgage fraud against Christopher Hales. (S4T-01133)
As the Crown has made clear on a number of occasions recently, the case of Christopher Hales was first brought to its attention by the Law Society of Scotland at a meeting on 18 December 2014.
link
We understand that the Law Society told the Crown Office informally about the Christopher Hales case in December 2014, then in April 2015, and then formally in July 2015. Does the Lord Advocate believe that there should be an investigation into the process of communication between the Law Society and the Crown Office, given that additional opportunities for alleged mortgage fraud could have arisen due to the delay? Will he order such an inquiry?
Noting when the Lord Advocate instructed the police to investigate—and if, as we understand, that was within six days of receiving the report—has he set a deadline for the police to submit a report to the Crown Office? If that is not already the case, will he consider so doing?
A number of questions have been asked of me. I will deal first with the last question. It is correct that, on 3 July 2015, Police Scotland was instructed to investigate the allegations that were the subject of the Scottish Solicitors Discipline Tribunal. The report was received on that day and was considered by the Crown Office. Six days later, I think on 9 July, formal instructions were issued to the police.
I cannot set a timescale, as these are complex matters, but I can say that the serious and organised crime division of the Crown Office is in regular contact with both the Law Society and Police Scotland, which is dealing with the matter, to monitor progress and to assist in a number of legal matters that have arisen as a result of the investigation.
As to whether I think that there should be an inquiry or whether I should order an inquiry, first, I do not have the power to order an inquiry; and, secondly, I do not think that there should be an inquiry. Let me explain why, and let me take members through the timeline of interaction between the serious and organised crime division of the Crown Office and the Law Society. There are quarterly meetings at which a large number of matters are discussed, including issues of whether the Law Society will make a referral in relation to a solicitor who has been struck off or who is the subject of a disciplinary finding made against them.
The Crown Office was first advised of this issue on 18 December 2014. The Crown Office was advised that the matter was under consideration of a referral to the Crown. The Crown noted the findings of the Scottish Solicitors Discipline Tribunal and noted that neither the clients nor the properties involved were named at the meeting.
The next time the matter was discussed was, as the member rightly mentioned in her supplementary question, in April this year—28 April, to be precise. The issue was raised again, and it was noted that it was still under consideration of a referral by the Law Society to the Crown. Again, neither the clients nor the properties were intimated at the time.
Following those meetings, the Crown was in contact with the Law Society to discuss what needed to be obtained—what evidence needed to be obtained, what files needed to be obtained and who had them—and a whole host of other matters. Given that there is a live investigation, it would not be productive to get into those details. I hope that Jackie Baillie will accept from me that preparatory work was undertaken with the Law Society to deal with the matter if and when there was a formal referral.
As indicated, the referral was made on 3 July 2015. On 1 July 2015, the Law Society advised us that it required to get authorisation from the guarantee fund sub-committee to formally refer the case to the Crown Office. That is a Law Society procedure.
We must understand what we are dealing with. We are dealing with a criminal investigation in which a person’s liberty could be in jeopardy, so these things cannot be dealt with quickly or by word of mouth. There is a process. That process was carried out by the Law Society, and authorisation was given for a referral by the guarantee fund sub-committee. Once that authorisation was given, the referral was made on 3 July 2015. That was a formal referral from the Law Society containing a whole load of information that the Crown would need, and the Crown has, of course, worked or been in contact with the Law Society about matters in anticipation of the referral being made.
As indicated, the referral was received on 3 July, which was a Friday. I think that the police were instructed the following Thursday.
The first time the Crown was made aware of the clients and the properties was on 3 July 2015. The Crown was not aware of the clients and the properties prior to that. There would be client confidentiality and data protection issues, but that is not my problem, or that was not my issue, of course; that is a matter for the Law Society in its dealings with the issue. However, I have spoken to the persons who were at the meeting and have had sight of the notes of the meeting, and I can assure members that the first time the Crown was made aware of the identity of the clients and the properties involved was 3 July 2015.
link
The public would probably not understand why it takes more than a year for the disciplinary tribunal to notify the Crown Office. Our concern should always be that, in the intervening period, vulnerable people could have been caught up and exploited in alleged mortgage fraud.
It appears from press reports that three lawyers, not one, have faced disciplinary action by the Law Society. In all cases, there has been a common denominator. Was the Crown Office aware at any stage of those additional cases and were connections made by the Law Society that were notified to the Crown? Given the seriousness of the allegations, has the Crown Office taken any steps through the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 to freeze the assets of any of those who might be implicated?
To deal with the last point first, the Crown has not yet taken steps under the proceeds of crime legislation. It is premature for that to be done or considered. In any criminal investigation, the Crown always has potential proceeds of crime at the forefront, but there has to be established criminality before steps can be embarked on.
On other solicitors who may or may not be involved, I have to be very careful about what I say, but I can tell members that, in relation to the referral on 3 July 2015, as far as I am aware—I read the referral this morning and I will check it after these proceedings are concluded—only one solicitor is referred to. However, Jackie Baillie has placed me on notice, and I will certainly make inquiries into that matter.
link
In what circumstances would the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service ask Police Scotland to investigate any other person connected with the solicitor subject to the Law Society’s judgment?
I have given consideration to that matter, because that question is highly relevant. The referral to Police Scotland relates to the solicitor who was the subject of the Scottish Solicitors Discipline Tribunal finding. The police has been instructed to investigate the property transactions relating to that finding, which resulted in the solicitor being struck off.
Police Scotland has a duty in any criminal investigation to follow where the evidence takes it. If, during a police investigation, evidence arises that other persons have been involved in criminality, such as fraud or whatever crime, I have complete faith that Police Scotland will act and do the right thing, as will the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.