I concur with Rod Campbell. There are a number of positives, not least of which is operation Sandwood and the grip that Police Scotland has taken of the issue. Credit is due to Deputy Chief Constable Iain Livingstone and his team for gaining trust through the diligent way in which they have gone about their business.
A number of aspects of the case make it unique, so we should maintain an on-going interest in it. I quote from a letter of 26 May from the Justice for Megrahi committee, just to put it on the record. It states:
“We strongly believe that in order to acquire a fair, unprejudiced and truly independent reading of the final police report a special prosecutor must be appointed by a process independent of the Lord Advocate and the Crown Office, and must be seen to exercise his/her decision-making and prosecutorial functions without reference to the Lord Advocate and the Crown Office.”
The dilemma that we have is that, when we use the term “Lord Advocate”, we associate that with an individual. We need to depersonalise the issue and treat it as a process, rather than being about personalities. There is a way to go yet with that process.
The letter goes on to say:
“Since the Lord Advocate’s position and independence as head of the prosecution system in Scotland is enshrined in the Scotland Act, such a mechanism must be put in place by the Lord Advocate himself, failing which, the Scottish Government should seek from the UK Government a section 30 Order in Council to enable the Scottish Government to do so.”
There are challenges but, given that the inquiry is on-going and that it might be some time before it reports, we have time on our side. I certainly concur with Justice for Megrahi that the response that we have had from the Rt Hon Frank Mulholland QC does not meet the terms of what people would understand to be independence. We need more thought to be put into that.