Thank you, convener.
My report to the committee is about severance arrangements in Coatbridge College. I prepared the report under section 22 of the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000, which allows me to bring to Parliament’s attention issues that arise from the audit of public bodies.
The external auditor of Coatbridge College gave an unqualified opinion on the college’s 2013-14 accounts. That means that she was satisfied that the accounts provided a true and fair view and contained no significant errors. However, she included an emphasis of matter paragraph in her audit report, in which she drew attention to serious governance weaknesses in the voluntary severance arrangements for the college principal, five members of the senior management team and a member of staff in the principal’s office. She also highlighted problems in accessing the information that she needed to conclude the audit. That delayed the audit and the annual audit report so that the accounts missed the statutory deadline of 31 December 2014 for laying before Parliament.
I prepared the report because I believed that serious failures in the way in which those charged with governance at Coatbridge College dealt with the severance arrangements should be drawn to the Parliament’s attention through the committee.
Coatbridge College was one of three colleges that merged to form New College Lanarkshire as part of the wider college reform programme. Thirty-three staff left Coatbridge College before the merger took place on 1 April 2014, at a total cost of £1.7 million. That included the college principal, five members of the senior management team and a member of staff in the principal’s office. The total severance cost for those seven people amounted to £849,842, which was about half the total amount that was paid out in severance in 2014.
My 2013 report entitled “Managing early departures from the Scottish public sector” was clear that, before approving any severance payments, those charged with governance must ensure that the payments
“represent a good use of public money”
and that a clear audit trail is kept. That did not happen at Coatbridge College in the case of those seven individuals, and my report highlights serious failings in governance.
In particular, I draw to the committee’s attention to the following. Those who were charged with governance failed to meet the standards that are expected of public bodies. There was a lack of transparency in the decision-making process. No audit trail was kept. Payments that were made were greater than the college’s severance scheme allowed for. The severance scheme for senior staff offered terms that were significantly higher than those in the Scottish Further and Higher Education Funding Council’s guidance, and higher than those in the schemes of the other colleges that became part of New College Lanarkshire. There is no evidence that the college’s remuneration committee had access to the information and advice that it needed to fulfil its responsibilities. Finally, the college principal failed to take the steps that were needed to demonstrate that his conflicts of interest were properly handled.
Those governance failures have resulted in excess costs being incurred by the college and the public purse. They are also likely to damage confidence in the governance of the college sector, especially following previous failings in a number of other colleges that I have reported to the committee.
As always, we are happy to answer questions from the committee. Unfortunately, the appointed auditor for Coatbridge College, on whose work my report is based, is not able to be with us, so there may be some issues that we will need to follow up separately with the committee. However, we will do our best to answer the committee’s questions as completely as we can.