I recognise the arguments that Margaret Mitchell makes. They are similar to points that have been made to us by the Law Society of Scotland and others. I will point out a couple of things.
First, the Scottish Legal Aid Board estimates that for an appeal on conviction and sentence a Glasgow solicitor—I appreciate that this does not address the Inverness point that Mr Finnie raised—could earn fees and outlays of anything from £400 to £600 and more. That would depend on the time that was spent on preparing, travelling for, waiting for and conducting the appeal. If they represented a client from the original defence of case through to appeal at the sheriff appeal court, a solicitor could easily be paid more than £900 per client.
Solicitors are paid in the round for criminal legal aid work, of which summary appeal certificates represent less than 1 per cent of criminal legal aid expenditure. Over the past three years, summary appeals against sentence have averaged around 660 per year and appeals against conviction around 160 per year, in comparison with 86,191 grants of legal aid and assistance by way of representation—ABWOR—for summary criminal work in 2013 to 2014. That puts in perspective how small the proportion of cases that we are talking about is.
10:15
On the choice of representative when sanction for counsel is granted, solicitor advocates will be able to access substantial detailed solicitor’s fees for the preparation and conduct of summary criminal appeals. Unlike counsel, of course, they can provide representation as solicitors in the lower courts, without prior sanction.
We have already begun a much wider discussion with the Law Society and the Faculty of Advocates—and the Society of Solicitor Advocates, which will be important, too—on how solicitor advocates are treated and paid in comparison with counsel. I assure the committee that we will look closely at the regulations’ impact on solicitor advocates, but I make the point that we are talking about a very small proportion of cases.
I challenge the assertion that the fees are untenable. We are talking about fees of £400 to £600, or up to £900 for representing a client from the original defence of a case through to appeal at the sheriff appeal court, which are reasonably substantial figures, and an hourly rate of £54.80 for appearance at the sheriff appeal court, which compares favourably with the minimum wage.