To ask the Scottish Government for what reason it is delaying publishing details of the draft budget. (S4O-04548)
Official Report · Chamber
Draft Budget (Publication)
Portfolio Question Time Finance, Constitution and Economy
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 3
- Siobhan McMahon Lab 2
- John Mason SNP 1
The record
6 contributions
The United Kingdom spending review will not be published until 25 November 2015, therefore we will not know what block grant is available to the Scottish ministers and delivery partners until that date.
Under the current devolution settlement, around 80 per cent of the Scottish budget is directly determined by decisions taken in Westminster and the application of the Barnett formula. That means that we have no alternative but to await the outcome of the UK spending review before publishing the draft budget. That has, of course, happened before. The Scottish draft budget was delayed, with the agreement of the Scottish Parliament, at both of the previous two UK spending reviews, in 2007 and 2010.
Scotland is not unique in being placed in this situation. Wales and Northern Ireland face the same problem. That is why on 21 August Jane Hutt, Arlene Foster and I jointly wrote to the Chief Secretary to the Treasury to express our dissatisfaction at his failure to consult the devolved Administrations before the chancellor’s announcement.
I am sure that the cabinet secretary agrees that any delay in publishing the details of the draft budget will have a serious knock-on effect on our local authorities and other public service partners. I understand that the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities said:
“in terms of financial planning and decision making”
the timescale
“is not the ideal situation”.
It is vital that there is sufficient time for proper scrutiny of the draft budget proposals, particularly now that the Scottish Government will be able to set a Scottish rate of income tax for the first time. What reassurance and certainty can the cabinet secretary provide to people who deliver our crucial public services such as schools, hospitals and social care, who are being kept in the dark and are unable to plan their budgets for next year?
I acknowledge that the situation is not ideal, but it is not a situation of my making. As I said, we depend on the UK Government’s decisions for around 80 per cent of the Scottish budget, so it would be premature and foolish to publish our budget before having that information. I am pretty sure that that position is understood by our social partners. Indeed, I welcome COSLA’s approach in this respect. I thought that COSLA’s response to the likely timescale for the budget was entirely pragmatic and understandable.
Parliamentary scrutiny is a matter for parliamentary committees and is not for me to determine, but, as I have always done throughout my tenure as finance secretary, I will make myself available to interact with parliamentary committees in any way they choose as they scrutinise the Government’s budget.
Does the cabinet secretary agree that the situation fundamentally shows that the Westminster budget system is hopelessly out of date, lacks respect for the Scottish Parliament and other Parliaments and needs to be seriously improved?
It is up to Westminster to decide on its budget process; that is not a matter for me. However, a key point that I make to Mr Mason is that the situation demonstrates that the scrutiny over financial issues that is habitually exercised in this Parliament is significantly greater and more thorough—I make no complaint about that; it is a good thing—than is the case in Westminster. The arrangements are entirely out of kilter because of that, and I hope that we can make available as much opportunity as we can do for this Parliament to scrutinise the Government’s budget, when it is published.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 9 Sep 2015 →- Finance, Constitution and Economy Questions · 1
- Draft Budget (Publication) Questions · 6
- Havelock Europa (Potential Job Losses) Questions · 4
- Scottish Rate of Income Tax Questions · 6
- European System of Accounts 2010 Questions · 6
- Welfare Powers (Devolution) Questions · 6
- Business Rates (Review) Questions · 4
- Private Finance (Public Projects) Questions · 6
- Tourism (Greater Glasgow and Clyde Valley) Questions · 4
- Higher Education (Tuition Fees) Questions · 4
- Scottish Futures Trust (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Draft Budget (Timetable) Questions · 6
- Growth Fund (Small and Medium-sized Enterprises) Questions · 4
- Elgin High School Replacement Questions · 4
- Economy (Performance) Questions · 6
- HMNB Clyde Questions · 4
- Social Responsibility Levy Questions · 4
- Austerity Measures (Economic Impact in Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Housing and Wellbeing Debate · 81
- Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exclusions and Exceptions) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2015 [Draft] Debate · 15
- Business Motions Business motions · 2
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Her Majesty the Queen Debate · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 11
- Seal Deaths and Population Decline Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.