Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports

“Managing ICT contracts in central government: An update”

Wednesday 24 June 2015 Public Audit Committee About 10:15–11:15 Evidence session 64 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

64 contributions
Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Item 3 is an evidence session on the AGS report, “Managing ICT contracts in central government: An update”. I welcome to the meeting Caroline Gardner, the Auditor General for Scotland, and from Audit Scotland, Angela Cullen, assistant director; Gemma Diamond, senior manager; and Morag Campsie, audit manager.

I understand that the Auditor General will make a brief opening statement.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Convener, the report looks at the progress that the Scottish Government and central Government bodies have made against the recommendations in my August 2012 report, “Managing ICT contracts”. Information technology provides the opportunity to transform public services, and the right skills and support are essential in ensuring that such investment delivers real benefits for users and is made in a cost-effective way. After all, failure to successfully manage IT programmes will affect the public directly and indirectly.

We know that managing IT programmes is complex and continues to be a challenge for the Scottish Government and central Government bodies. In our 2012 report, which highlighted problems that Registers of Scotland, the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service and Disclosure Scotland encountered when managing their ICT contracts, we made a number of recommendations to the Scottish Government to help strengthen the strategic oversight of IT programmes and to improve central Government bodies’ access to skills.

The report reviews progress against our recommendations and uses information provided by local auditors in 12 central Government bodies to explore the problems that they encountered in managing ICT programmes and how they resolved them. It highlights that, although the Scottish Government has made some progress in improving its strategic oversight and access to the necessary skills, the approach has not been fully effective and significant progress is still needed.

I will highlight briefly three key themes from the report, the first of which is oversight. Following our previous report, the Scottish Government introduced new assurance and oversight arrangements and developed an assurance framework for information and communications technology programmes to support central Government bodies and gather information for Scottish Government oversight. As part of that, the information systems investment board was given the responsibility of ensuring that bodies followed the framework.

However, we have found that those arrangements have not been effective. The framework was not clear enough, which might have resulted in fewer ICT projects being reported to the board, and the board did not have sufficient staff and information to perform its oversight role. The Scottish Government has recently updated its oversight arrangements and, in February 2015, it created the office of the chief information officer to support the board, but the roles and responsibilities of the board and the office of the chief information officer are still being finalised.

On the report’s second key theme of access to skills, we found, as we did in our 2012 report, that the lack of key skills is a significant problem. Public bodies compete with the private sector for people who have skills that are scarce right across the economy, and some use short-term contractors to fill their skills gaps, which might be costly and requires effective knowledge transfer. In 2012, we recommended that the Scottish Government undertake a skills gap assessment, but that was not done until August 2014. The Government is now developing a new approach of pooling and sharing resources in a digital transformation service. That is an ambitious initiative, and again the detailed arrangements are still being put in place.

On the third key theme of the progress of central Government bodies, we have used case studies to identify and share what has or has not worked around the public sector. It is clear that, although some progress has been made, areas such as defining benefits and managing contractors and suppliers need to be improved. We found that bodies are using appropriate project management techniques and that more bodies are using Agile, but some lack the skills and experience that are needed for such an approach.

The report also provides an update on the three bodies that were the subject of my earlier report. In relation to Disclosure Scotland, we are at the moment unable to comment further on the procurement of the new contract that was awarded in May 2014 because of continuing discussions between Disclosure Scotland and Atos about non-completion of the contract. I will, of course, update the committee in due course as appropriate.

As always, convener, we are happy to answer the committee’s questions.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

For me, the major part of the report is part 2, which begins on page 19 and relates to addressing skills gaps and shortages. As one of the old hands on the committee, I was a member in 2012 when we took evidence on the matter.

As you have indicated, Auditor General, the first key message in this part of the report begins:

“Our August 2012 report highlighted that a lack of skills was a key factor in the failure of central government bodies’ ICT programmes.”

It was a serious issue, and I thought that the Government was taking it seriously. I was therefore shocked to find that two years had passed before a skills gap survey was carried out in August 2014, with an action plan being introduced six months after that. I was shocked because I remembered director general Paul Gray’s response to the 2012 report and his absolute categorical assurance that everything was being done.

Mr Gray gave evidence to the committee on behalf of the Government, with a submission in October 2012. I will quote a couple of lines from it:

“We are working towards an action plan for the Central Government ICT Workforce to be available ... across the sector ... This will be informed by ... data collection on the size of the ICT workforce carried out for benchmarking purposes”,

starting on 1 October 2012, and by

“collection of information on the skills and capability of the workforce and future needs.”

That was in October 2012. I sat back naively and optimistically and took the Government at its word. Was the committee misled by that information? We were given an assurance in October 2012, in a significant four-page response by the director general. I know that you will have seen that paper. We were given a categorical assurance, and I was content with everything that the Government was doing on the matter, so we set the matter aside. Yet you come back to us two years later to say that that categorical assurance is not worth the paper it is written on. It did not take the Government from August to October 2012; it took it from August 2012 to August 2014 even to think about the skills survey, and to produce an action plan six months later.

I ask for your comments on that. I am sure that you will be familiar with the response to your report and to the committee in 2012.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

In my view, the skills gap analysis should have been carried out sooner. That is one of the key messages in my report. It is fair to say that it is not that nothing was done during the intervening period. We know, for example, that the Scottish Government set up a cross-public sector workforce stream in 2013 to address the commitment that had been made in the digital strategy, and that other pieces of work were being done. The skills gap analysis did not take place until last year, which has made it harder for the Government to think about how it addresses the shortage of skills that affects the whole economy. You heard about that in the earlier evidence session. The committee might wish to ask the Scottish Government why it took as long as it did to analyse the skills gap and then to think about the right response to tackling it?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is reasonable. During your inquiry, your gathering of data and your investigations, did you discover why it took the Government another two years to carry out the promises that were given in October 2012 to the satisfaction of the committee?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I am not sure that we can speculate on the reasons why that took as long as it did. We know that some things happened during that two-year period, but the skills gap analysis itself did not happen until the date that was set out in my report, and I think that it should have been done sooner.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I would like an update on ROS. ICT skills were a problem in 2012, which is three years ago, and they are a serious problem now. Are you concerned that there seems to be little alignment between the Scottish Government’s priorities, and indeed the country’s priorities, for ICT specialists and a fall of 25,000 places in FE in recent years? I am talking about HNC, HND and degrees.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We have not considered that in detail. As you know, the “Scotland’s colleges 2015” report primarily considered the reform process. At some point, there might be a case for us to consider the way in which the broader economic focus on digital skills is being developed right across the piece, through the funding council, colleges, Skills Development Scotland and the higher education sector. However, I am not in a position to comment on that now.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But if there is a skills gap in a particular area, you would expect the Government and the director general to be talking to universities and colleges—that is where the skills come from.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is one of the potential benefits of the Government’s outcome approach: to join up all the parts of the public sector so as to deliver what it wants to achieve. We have not considered in detail how well that is happening—or not—at the moment but, as we say in our report, IT skills are a significant challenge for Scottish public bodies and the wider economy, and the skills gap analysis of the internal skills that are lacking took longer to happen than I would have expected following the 2012 report.

10:45

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

When we discussed your previous report, we heard about Registers of Scotland. I have read through the report, and it is not exactly a ringing endorsement that everything is wonderful. It says:

“RoS recognises it needs to have the capacity to maintain service delivery”.

Should we be confident that the ICT systems at ROS are fit for purpose now, given that the organisation has significant additional responsibilities?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask Gemma Diamond or Morag Campsie to comment in a moment on the specifics of Registers of Scotland. Through our report, we have tried to look closely at the progress that the Scottish Government and the bodies have made in addressing our recommendations on strategic oversight and skills, and to give an update on where they are, but we have not done an audit that would allow us to give you a full assurance that everything is now fine. I hope that we have made that clear in the report. We have reported that ROS has made some progress.

Morag Campsie Audit Scotland
link

As we say in the appendix, there have been some issues. There have been some large projects in connection with the Land Registration etc (Scotland) Act 2012 and the delivery of the requirements for the land and buildings transaction tax.

ROS has brought in some new people during the past year, and it produced its digital strategy at the beginning of the year, putting plans in place for some significant pieces of work, particularly the completion of the land register. ROS has been giving priority to those large pieces of work, and it has had to bring in agency staff to deal with its day-to-day running. Along with the local auditors, we are keeping an eye on that.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I noticed that there had been quite a lot of changes of staff, with new staff coming in and more agency staff. I just wondered how stable things are.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

In a past life, I had responsibility for and oversight of very large ICT projects. It seems to be the way of ICT projects that not one of them comes in on budget or on time, or indeed delivers exactly what people want.

In this particular case, I am aware that there is a shortage, not just in the UK but worldwide, of ICT experts, for want of a better word. Auditor General, you have highlighted in your report how that is an issue for the Scottish Government, and that it is an issue across the UK.

How does the unavailability of that level of skill impact on the Scottish Government’s progress in putting in place the measures that it is looking for? Clearly, the Scottish Government has made progress, and it would appear that it is heading in the right direction, but I am at a loss to know what to do about the critical skills shortage.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right to say that this is a complex area, and it does not just affect the Scottish Government; it affects public services right across the UK and more widely, as well as private sector companies. We have seen the problems that RBS has had with its IT systems during the past week or so. The problem is widespread.

We are not suggesting that there is a magic wand that the Government can pull out and wave to make everything okay. As we said in our earlier report, the Government can do more to keep strategic oversight of projects, to identify where things are progressing less well than planned and to step in to avoid the problems crystallising. More could be done to develop the pool of skilled staff that Ms Scanlon was talking about who can work across different public bodies, rather than each body having to grow its own pool of staff.

The impact of the shortage operates at two levels. First, in significant projects such as the CAP futures IT system for the common agricultural policy, on which I have reported to you before, and the NHS 24 project, which we are still monitoring and which we will come back to you on in due course, major investment goes off track, and significant costs are incurred on turning the situation around. There could be an impact on the people who rely on those services or on the payments that they generate. We can see it at that level.

Almost more important, however, is the opportunity cost and what could be achieved with well-managed investment in IT, such as transforming services to make them more responsive to people’s needs and making efficiency savings that would help us to close the gap between the funding that is available, the Scottish Government’s priorities and people’s expectations. The transformation potential is really at risk because of the skills gap.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Do we not come back to the basic point, which you highlighted, that civil servants in such roles get paid substantially less than the market pays? Are public sector bodies working round that by hiring contractors, at a higher price, in order to compensate? I do not know what else they could do.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

To an extent, you are right that they are doing that, and we make that point in the report. We also highlight the importance of bodies that do that ensuring that they have good arrangements for transferring knowledge and skills from the contractor to the in-house team so that they do not lose all the expertise and experience as soon as the contract ends.

Something else that can be done, which the Government is aiming to do through the new digital transformation service, is to build those skills among in-house staff, working with the FE sector and Skills Development Scotland to set up modern apprenticeships in the right areas. That is a long-term thing and it is not going to fix the problem overnight, but it could generate some of the necessary skills over a longer period and avoid the reliance on expensive short-term skills from the private sector.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

My other question is on paragraph 30. I was quite surprised to see the comment about the—what is it called?—information systems investment board not getting responses from Government departments. That seems pretty outrageous, does it not?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

We are working hard to avoid using acronyms this morning, convener. I know that you do not like them, so we will try hard to stick to that.

We were concerned that the information systems investment board, which was set up as a key part of the Government’s oversight, was not in a position to carry out that role effectively, for two reasons. First, the guidance was not clear about which projects fell under its remit in relation to calculating the cost of projects and determining the risky ones that should be included. Secondly, the board did not have the capacity to chase up the bodies that were not submitting the information that was required, and we think that that significantly limited its ability to carry out its role.

The Government has recognised that and it is changing the arrangements under the oversight of the office of the chief information officer. Again, however, it is taking longer than we expected to put something in place, given the changes that were put in from 2012.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

You comment on staffing in that area. Is it primarily techies?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The new arrangements under the digital transformation service are still unfolding. I will ask Gemma Diamond, if I may, to give you more of a feel of how that is coming together. It is still work in progress.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

The office of the chief information officer was created in February. It is quite a small office of only four staff. The digital transformation service, which is part of the digital directorate, is just being established and it is going through the arrangements to recruit staff. The Scottish Government will be able to provide an update on that later, as the new arrangements are still being put in place.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

Okay, so it is very recent. My concern from reading the report was that the information systems investment board was not getting responses from Government bodies. We need to ensure that that happens, because it is clearly a key part of the work.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

It absolutely is. We think that the new arrangements have the potential to resolve that. The framework is clearer and there will be dedicated staffing in the office of the chief information officer and the new digital transformation service, but we are not yet in a position to say that it will work in practice. As Gemma Diamond said, it is still developing as we speak.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

You mentioned how complex ICT programmes are, and in paragraph 75 of your report you say that Government should consider how best to manage them. I would guess that that statement has been made in various reports since 1999, when the Parliament began. Various reports have said that ICT projects involve complex arrangements and that we need to get a grip on them. We have seen challenges for the UK Government in relation to the roll-out of ICT programmes in the health service.

Is there a need for more thought about that? Governments say, “Let’s have a new digital approach to this” and all sorts of buzzwords are used. Does there not come a stage at which we have to think, “We’ve tried all this before, for so many years”? We have discussed the issue ever since the internet was invented.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The specific comment in paragraph 75 is about the project management technique that is used for a specific IT project. There is not a one-size-fits-all arrangement that is the best one to use for every central Government project. That is an issue that needs more skills at a local level and more support through the Scottish Government.

The wider point is that Governments, here and more generally, are not very good at this. That has been reported repeatedly in Scotland, at UK level and more widely. The changes that the Government proposes to put in place through both its oversight arrangements and the digital transformation service have the potential to make a difference. As I say in a carefully worded phrase in the report, the project is ambitious—doing it will be difficult. The problem is that nobody knows what the right answer is; private companies are not great at it either, in many instances.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Could it be that, by the time we reach the stage at which we try to take plans forward, the technology has overtaken them? The pace of technology is a challenge—things are running on a twin track with the Government on one track and the technology on another, and the technology has overtaken the Government at every opportunity.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There is an element of truth in that, but I do not think that it helps very much given that we know that Government cannot simply opt out of the opportunities that come from technological changes. We all expect it as citizens and service users—people across Scotland do. In order to make the savings that are needed, we all need to make much better use of technology in future.

However, there is a need to make the investment in having skills and processes that are as good as we can afford as a Government, to provide a set of public services in Scotland that get the most from technology and to minimise the chances of things going wrong. Until now, the Scottish Government’s approach has not demonstrated that it can do that.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

I want to ask about the case study on page 22 of the report, which is about the common agricultural policy futures programme. Caroline Gardner raised that matter with the committee on 29 April and sent a letter that was in the papers for that meeting. At that time, the IT delivery partner costs had gone up from £28.8 million to £60.4 million—a 111 per cent rise. Was the reason for that increase the turnover of staff as stated in the case study? Was that what went wrong?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

There was a wider range of things going on. The committee might recall that I produced a section 22 report on the matter towards the back end of 2014. Without going into the detail of that, the skills gap was a problem. Challenges were also caused by the complexity of what the European Union requires and by the broad scope of what the Government planned initially as part of the CAP futures programme. All those things contributed to the increased costs.

I will produce another report for the committee later this year on progress on that programme, on the back of the Scottish Government audit. A significant amount of public money is involved, and the programme is of great concern to members’ constituents; we are watching it closely. That was one element, but not the only one, in that particular case study.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland Islands
link

The case study mentions that the programme had to fill two key senior programme management roles using fixed-term contracts; I think that you alluded to that in your answers to both Colin Beattie and the convener. I am trying to gauge where the project really went wrong, because a 111 per cent rise in costs is pretty concerning by any standards.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

At this stage, I would rather refer the committee back to my section 22 report that set out that and a range of other factors. We are continuing to monitor the programme and we know that there are continuing challenges for the team. I do not want to jump into that midstream without having a formal update for the committee to found on.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I want to go back to the skills gap and what Caroline Gardner said in her opening remarks about competing with the private sector. That issue seems to come up constantly in the report, and Colin Beattie mentioned it, too. Bodies such as the Scottish Qualifications Authority and National Records of Scotland have not been able to retain skilled staff because of the huge difference in costs. I see that not so much as a skills gap but as the result of salaries being low compared with the private sector. Is that analysis correct? Salaries in the private sector are double those in the public sector.

11:00

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that that is a symptom of the wider problem, which is that there is simply a UK-wide, and probably a global, shortage of those skills. The public sector is more constrained in salary terms, for reasons that we all understand, so when people are competing for a skilled project manager or a data analyst, the private sector tends to win out more often than not. There is not a quick answer to that, except to go through the sort of process that we talked about earlier of developing a pool that all public bodies can call on, rather than each body needing its own skilled people, and investing in the training and development of those people for Scotland as a whole, so that it does not turn into a bidding war.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

The point that I am trying to make is that the private sector does not seem to have a big problem, even though those skills are paid for through the public sector, by people going to university, for example. The private sector does not seem to be short of those skills, whereas the public sector is. We constantly hear comments about shortages of those skills, but the private sector can harness them and employ those people.

Even if we had a huge pool of skilled staff, would they go into the public sector when they would get double the money in the private sector?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

That is a really good point to explore.

I refer you to exhibit 6 on page 21 of the report. There is a table that shows, first of all, the skills gap. Those are the skills that are missing within Scottish Government and the public bodies, according to their own survey of what they need. The right-hand column shows the skills shortages—the private sector, too, struggles to recruit and retain people with those skills.

That is not to say that nobody has those skills, but those who have them tend to move from job to job in return for another pay rise or better terms and conditions. That contributes to why some of the programmes in which a private contractor is involved can still struggle. People are moving on because their skills are in short supply, and they are moving repeatedly. The only answer to such shortages is to invest in more people who have the skills, to develop them and to ensure that they are available in the economy more widely. Pay is a short-term fix, but you are always vulnerable to the next person with a bigger chequebook making a better offer.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Even if we have a huge pool, we are not necessarily guaranteed that those people will work in the public sector.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I think that you need to be able to—

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

For me, the most important phrase in the report—it was highlighted earlier—is in paragraph 75:

“there is no one size fits all solution.”

Prior to being elected to Parliament, I worked for an IT company, at a lower level than Colin Beattie. As soon as a piece of kit left the factory, it was out of date—that was just the nature of the business—and things have moved on hugely since then. From my perspective, the huge challenge for any public body—in Scotland, across the UK or anywhere else—when it comes to an ICT solution is a bespoke solution is needed. One size fits all simply cannot happen, because every organisation is different and every public body is different.

The private sector can get it wrong, too, and ICT also costs the private sector huge amounts of additional finance. No organisation will ever get it correct, because of the complex nature of devising an ICT solution. I do not think that everyone—not only here, but outside the Parliament, too—fully appreciates that these are bespoke solutions for individual organisations.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right in saying that we are often talking about bespoke solutions, either because nobody else needs to provide the service in question, or because the policy direction does not lend itself to an off-the-shelf solution. That is absolutely a fact. It affects the way in which banks develop their IT systems, as well as the way in which major retailers and the internet-based businesses that are so important these days develop theirs.

On the other hand, I do not think that that is a reason for the Government to say that it is all too hard and either that we will not do it at all or that we accept that it will all go wrong. Getting good governance and good oversight in place and doing what we can to build that skills base and to make sure that it is available to all public bodies, rather than each having to have its own, could make a difference against that difficult background.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Exactly. I do not challenge what you have said at all. I absolutely agree with it. At the same time, people need to appreciate the wider view.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Sure.

Angela Cullen Audit Scotland
link

May I add to that, convener? As the Auditor General mentioned in her opening statement, we have used case studies in the report to highlight points. There are a lot of case studies in this report compared with some of our other reports, and some of them highlight things that perhaps did not go well or why problems have been experienced. We have also highlighted issues for individual bodies at different stages of projects that we thought were interesting and that others might want to look at and think about.

Picking up those lessons and sharing them more widely is a different way of doing things that I had not thought about. We appreciate that one size does not fit all. We are trying to direct bodies to particular examples that they might want to think about.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

To return to Sandra White’s point about competition between the public sector and the private sector on recruitment, did the Auditor General find any evidence of more innovative examples of recruitment—perhaps encouraging people to spend part of their career, or a shorter time, in the public sector, or attracting people to the public sector through things other than pay?

Some people may be prepared to work in health education because they value the benefits that that would have for society and for their careers. Other benefits might be location—people who would not otherwise be based in Scotland might want to work here for a while. Were there any examples, or is there more that could be done?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I will ask Gemma Diamond and Morag Campsie in a moment whether we have any specific examples. Before that, it is worth saying that one of the Government’s aims for the digital transformation service is to do exactly that sort of thing—to think about how people could be given new and unusual career paths. That might mean bringing in modern apprentices and giving them the chance to get early experience of different types of project, or bringing in people for an exciting project to transform the way that e-health, for example, operates. The aim would be not to do that in a way that relies on each body bearing the risk itself, but to do it at a Scotland-wide level.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

We know that, as part of the workforce stream for the digital strategy to promote working in ICT within the public sector, the Scottish Government is trying to do exactly that. It is about not just pay, but the other benefits that go alongside it.

As the Auditor General said, the digital transformation service is looking to bring in people to work on a number of very interesting ICT projects across a number of bodies and provide a career pathway for people, to encourage them to stay within the Government sector for longer.

Drew Smith Lab Glasgow
link

That would be welcome. Is there also an opportunity for people who do not want a career in the public sector but would be prepared to spend part of their career there? I am thinking in particular of people working internationally who might be prepared to come to Scotland to work on a specific project for a period of time, because they believe that it would enhance their CV and they would get benefits other than monetary reward.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

You are right. There are two dimensions to that. At the moment, it is primarily happening through the contracting route that we talked about earlier. Mr Scott talked about the CAP futures programme, in which the programme director and senior people have been on short-term contracts. It is very important in those circumstances that we do what we can to make sure that they transfer their skills and experience to their team, so that we are not back to square one when they leave.

More generally, as part of the digital transformation service, there is a real place for thinking about whether there are people in their 50s who are coming towards the end of a career in the private sector who might want to give something back by working for a lower salary for a period of time to change the way in which public services are delivered. There is an opportunity there. I am not sure that we have seen much concrete evidence of that so far, but it is the sort of thing that I would expect the Government to be planning into the digital transformation service and the approach that it takes.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

A lot of what I wanted to discuss has been covered, so I will try not to jump on top of what has already been said. One of the things that struck me as I was reading through the report yesterday evening was the skills shortages, and I had got the impression, before I listened to today’s evidence, that some of the problems involving timescales and the like are simply a result of skills shortages. The other thing that struck me, given what we might call the dubious reputation of some public contracts that have gone out in the past and the issues concerning the senior management of those projects, was that the people running such contracts might not know what is required technically but might perhaps experience a degree of interference.

That is one of the things that I was a bit concerned about in the previous report that you brought to the committee; there had obviously been some poor management practices, which were highlighted in that report. How do you feel about what you have seen now? I see a degree of improvement, particularly with the likes of the case studies that you have included to illustrate good practice, as well as some of the things that have not happened. Has there been any evidence of interference where there should not have been?

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

Could you elaborate on the sort of interference that you are thinking about?

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

It is simply to do with clarity about where the project is and where it needs to be at a particular time. A sudden and different policy decision could cause the project to veer off and cause problems for those who are trying to implement it.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

I do not think that that has come up as a major issue in the work that we have done here. You are right to say that there have been some improvements, but the areas in which we think that there has not been enough progress are, first, the arrangements for oversight, problem solving and support when things are behind, through the information systems investment board and, secondly, the work that is required to understand what skills are missing and to start investing in developing those skills in the public sector. A problem can arise with projects when the requirements change or, particularly under the agile project management system, when it becomes clear that you cannot do what you had originally planned to do because the technology will not support it or it is too complex, and you then have to reshape your plans to meet the timescale and resources available. We have seen that happening, but I would not see that as interference in the way that I think that you are asking about.

Gemma Diamond or Morag Campsie may want to add to that.

Gemma Diamond Audit Scotland
link

No, we did not see any evidence of that.

Colin Keir SNP Edinburgh Western
link

I just thought that some of the projects that are mentioned in the report had not been as quick as they could have been because of X, Y or Z.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

Let us have a brief final question from Mary Scanlon.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry for going back three years, but we were promised by the Government then that it would have a strategic oversight of significant ICT programmes. Part 1 of the report states that that strategic oversight led to

“an ICT assurance framework in February 2013”

that

“was not clear enough and has not enabled the Scottish Government to fulfil its oversight role.”

That is total failure. Paragraph 2 states:

“The Information Systems Investment Board’s (ISIB) role was to oversee the implementation of the framework but it did not have sufficient information or capacity to perform this role effectively.”

You could not make that up. As if that was not bad enough,

“It did not receive all the ICT investment and assurance information required from ... government bodies”.

That is total incompetence and failure.

Promises about a strategic oversight were made three years ago. I will not rehearse the arguments that were made then involving ROS and BT and the need for a central strategic overview. It seems that one part of the Government cannot talk to another, and the Government has a framework that, in the Auditor General’s words, is not clear enough to enable the Government to fulfil its role. If you were giving marks out of 10, you would barely give that a score of 1. It is really serious failure.

On the skills gap, the Government can look to the universities, the FE colleges and its apprenticeship programme, and it can talk to SDS. There is a huge role there. It is all very well to sit back and blame one person or another or the fact that the private sector pays higher salaries, but it only does that because of supply and demand. We have insufficient people coming forward.

Are you disappointed about the outcome of the promise of strategic oversight that was made on the basis of the four organisations that you looked at last time and the problems that they had? Are you disappointed with what we have here, which is in my view just total incompetence?

11:15

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

As the report says, and as I said in my opening remarks, the progress that has been made on governance and oversight of the investment and on addressing the skills gap is not as good as it needs to be.

There were a number of problems with the framework. There was a lack of clarity about how to calculate the costs and risks of the projects that should be under its remit. The new guidance addresses that, but we have yet to see its effect in progress. The staffing of the board was not sufficient to enable it to chase up the information that was not submitted on time, and the time that was taken to do the skills gap analysis was longer than it should have been. The reasons for that are best explored with the Scottish Government.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The Government departments did not even talk to each other. They could not get information from other departments.

Caroline Gardner Auditor General for Scotland
link

The establishment of the board was a good first step, but as always it needs to work effectively in practice. The guidance on how the framework should be applied was not clear enough about which projects were in and which were out, and not enough staffing was available to the board to let it chase up the information that it needed but did not have. That is the finding of my report.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am grateful for your diplomacy. Thank you.

Paul Martin Lab The Convener · Glasgow Provan
link

I thank the Auditor General and her team for their time this morning. I remind colleagues that we will discuss the subject in private later, under agenda item 7.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 141
  3. 10:15 Section 23 Reports Evidence session · 64
  4. 11:15 Section 22 Report Committee business · 15
  5. 11:15 Section 23 Report Committee business · 18

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.