To ask the Scottish Government how it is responding to the concerns of the CalMac workforce, who have recently been balloted for strike action. (S4T-01065)
Official Report · Chamber
Caledonian MacBrayne (Workforce Concerns)
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Derek Mackay SNP 7
- David Stewart Lab 3
- Alex Johnstone Con 2
- Neil Findlay Lab 1
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
14 contributionsCalMac’s ferry services play a crucial role in the daily lives of our island communities, and the Scottish Government has made clear its commitment to the continued delivery of a safe and reliable ferry network. We want to protect CalMac employees by ensuring that a fair, affordable and sustainable pension scheme is written into the next ferry service operating contract. I encourage CalMac and the unions to continue with the current process of engagement on proposed changes to the pension scheme and to work together towards an outcome that avoids the need for industrial action. I have had two constructive meetings with the CalMac unions and the Scottish Trades Union Congress in recent weeks, and I have offered to continue that dialogue.
The minister will be well aware that more than 90 per cent of members of the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers at CalMac voted for industrial action as they have genuine and heartfelt concerns over job security, conditions and, particularly, pensions. The Scottish Government owns CalMac. What specific actions is the minister going to carry out to resolve this very unsatisfactory and worryingly poor climate of industrial relations?
We will ensure that the processes that we are responsible for are carried out competently. I repeat that we want to give the assurance to CalMac employees that we continue to support the services by investing in them. We will conduct a procurement exercise that is in keeping with the legislation—the same legislation that the previous Labour Administration would have had to comply with in procuring services—and our guarantees around the pension.
To put the issue in context, we are aware that there is an identified pension deficit, which is up to £59 million following the revaluation of the pension. The trade unions are not resisting reform, and I am very mindful of what their issues are. That is why continued dialogue and meetings undertaken in a constructive and positive fashion are necessary and right. I will do everything that I can as minister to support those discussions. However, our support for this public service is absolutely resolute.
Does the minister share the views of the RMT general secretary, who said:
“RMT members on CalMac feel that they are caught in the crossfire of an unnecessary and damaging tendering battle that leaves jobs, conditions and pensions hanging by a thread”?
Surely the Scottish Government has learned the lessons of the fiasco of the northern isles contract award, when Serco axed a crossing and sacked staff.
I certainly understand why employees would feel nervous when their jobs are subject to a procurement exercise, which is of course the same procurement exercise that a Labour Administration would have to undertake and one that, under the legislation, we cannot escape. That is why we set a very robust specification for the services that we want. We are investing in the ferry network with new vessel provision as well, and we will support employees through the process.
Can I be clear about what is being procured? Regardless of the ownership status of the successful bidder, the ferry services are not being privatised. What is being tendered is a public service contract to operate lifeline services on behalf of Scottish ministers. The operator will have to comply with a service specification defined by Scottish ministers that will, as now, be subject to stringent contract management conditions. All the vessels and ports that are currently in public ownership will remain in public ownership and, together with the Clyde and Hebrides services, will remain under public control by Scottish ministers throughout the contract. This is therefore not privatisation, as some elements of the Labour Party are suggesting.
Shame!
I can hear that that is much to the regret of the Conservatives who are to my right, both literally and politically.
We will protect our public services and conduct the current procurement exercise in a manner that is in keeping with European and other relevant legislation, and we will arrive at the right decision by which to protect the lifeline services. We will also support employees through what I accept is a difficult process.
Will the minister give a guarantee that, in reacting to the action of the trade unions at CalMac, he will also have as his highest priority through the tendering process value for money for the taxpayer and a quality service for the fare-paying passenger?
These issues are about balance. It is a matter of fact that there was a deficit in the pension fund and the Scottish Government has been supporting that. We will look at the assessments and the revaluation once again and, through the employer’s dialogue with the trade unions, continue that discussion, but we will do it in a culture of positivity and a constructive approach in which we encourage CalMac and the unions to talk and to work together so that we can all avoid any industrial action. As I said, I am sure that that climate will lead to a positive outcome in keeping with all the necessary considerations.
Let me get this right. A service that is currently run by the public sector may be run by the private sector, and that is not privatisation. The reality is that the northern ferries have gone to Serco, the sleeper has gone to Serco and ScotRail has gone to the Dutch company Abellio. Is it any wonder that the RMT and its members have no confidence in the minister’s handling of what is going on at the moment?
I say to Neil Findlay that I recall what privatisation looks like as delivered by the Tory Government and it is the ripping apart of public services and leaving them to the private sector. That is not what is being proposed. We are talking about public services and the provision of services as specified by ministers, and they will remain in the ownership of the Scottish ministers and under their direction.
Neil Findlay, as is not unexpected, uses intemperate language. He would do well not to try to stoke up grievance and create a toxic situation for the employees. We should be looking after the employees of CalMac—[Interruption.]
Mr Findlay, stop heckling.
—and working in partnership with the trade unions to arrive at a positive outcome so that we can continue to provide these public services in the interests of the communities that they serve, and we will continue to do that in keeping with the law. Does Neil Findlay suggest that we should break the law? Does he think that that would leave us in a satisfactory position? No—it would lead to challenge, and the people who would suffer if we did not deliver the procurement exercise in keeping with the necessary procurement legislation would be the communities and the staff.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 16 Jun 2015 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Headteachers (Black and Minority Ethnic Backgrounds) Questions · 8
- Caledonian MacBrayne (Workforce Concerns) Questions · 14
- Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Scotland) Act 2012 Statement · 37
- Harbours (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 37
- Marine Tourism Debate · 29
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
- Remembering Srebrenica Members’ business · 6
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.