Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 11 June 2015 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

To ask the Deputy First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of this glorious day. (S4F-02862)

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

The First Minister is in the United States on Government business and has asked me to answer questions on her behalf.

Later today I will travel to Glenrothes to chair a further meeting of the Tullis Russell task force.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

A worrying report published today confirms that two thirds of North Sea operators have been forced to cancel projects because of the recent fall in the oil price. That is bad news for the industry, for the economy of the north-east and for thousands of oil workers and their families. They need to know what the future holds for Scotland’s oil and gas industry. Can the Deputy First Minister confirm when an updated oil and gas bulletin will be published?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

I can confirm that. The Government is considering the implications of the United Kingdom Government’s budget back in March, which contained substantial changes to the taxation arrangements for the North Sea oil and gas sector. Once we have confirmed the extent of those changes and their implications, which will flow through into, we hope, investment decisions made by companies, given that there has been such radical change in the taxation regime for the North Sea, the Government will publish the next version of the oil and gas tax bulletin.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

I did not hear a date there. The Scottish National Party Government has had time to do the work, but there has been one excuse after another. That is the fourth time that somebody in the Deputy First Minister’s seat has refused to do that. Once upon a time, we could not move for SNP oil bulletins. Since the collapse in the oil price, we have had nothing but radio silence. That may be because the collapse in the oil price has demolished the SNP’s economic credibility. We now know that the SNP seeks to amend the Scotland Bill to push for full fiscal autonomy within the UK, something that right-wing Tory back benchers will cheer, because it means the end of the Barnett formula.

Can the Deputy First Minister tell us what the oil price would need to be to balance the books under full fiscal autonomy?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

The Government publishes an annual oil and gas bulletin reflecting the changes to the North Sea oil and gas tax arrangements. The UK Government made very substantial changes to the taxation regime back in March. We want to see the implications of that in the oil and gas sector. That is necessary, because there is every opportunity for companies to change their investment decisions, as the UK Government has accepted that it got the taxation regime so badly wrong in 2011 that it has now changed those arrangements.

When it comes to the issue of full fiscal autonomy, Kezia Dugdale should learn a lesson from the fact that she went on and on about full fiscal autonomy for nine months, all the way up to the general election, and the Labour Party delivered its worst performance in this country in 90 years, with a haemorrhage of its vote and the loss of 40 of its 41 seats. That tells me that Kezia Dugdale is out of touch with public opinion in Scotland.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

The Office for Budget Responsibility published a full fiscal analysis within 24 hours. We have not seen one from the Scottish Government in over a year. We got tired of waiting for the Government to do a fiscal analysis, so we have published our own. [Laughter.]

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

I hear cries of “Mickey Mouse” and “It’s not credible.” Members should listen, because this document has been verified by the Scottish Parliament information centre and independent experts. This is the oil paper that the SNP Government will not print.

The Deputy First Minister did not answer my question, so let me give him the answer. We would need a global oil price of $200 to balance Scotland’s books under the SNP’s plans for full fiscal autonomy. So disastrous is the SNP’s policy that it is predicated on an oil price that has never been reached before. That number has been approved by SPICe. SNP members can laugh all they like, but it is the reality of the situation.

A Labour amendment to the Scotland Bill would establish an independent expert commission to consider the impact of full fiscal autonomy on Scotland’s public finances. It would not have any politicians or Government employees as members. The Scottish people would then have, once and for all, a full expert analysis of the impact of full fiscal autonomy. Can the Deputy First Minister tell us whether the Scottish National Party will back that amendment?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

It would be interesting to see what degree of discussion there has been between the Labour Party and the Conservative Party about taking forward that amendment, because that is just what I saw on Monday when I was in the House of Commons—the continuation of the better together alliance between the Labour Party and the Tories over the Scotland Bill. I would have thought that the Labour Party might have learned a lesson from its participation in the better together alliance, which has been described as a disaster for the electoral performance of the Labour Party in Scotland.

If Kezia Dugdale is interested in taking forward a rational and considered discussion about full fiscal autonomy, she need only look at her back benches. In the Devolution (Further Powers) Committee’s debate in the chamber, Alex Rowley said:

“The Scottish Government has put a stronger case, and has a case, for full fiscal autonomy.”

His next sentence is where the problem arises for the Labour Party. He said:

“I am keen to move away from the politics of fear and have that discussion.”—[Official Report, 21 May 2015; c 76.]

What the Labour Party does when it comes here, week in, week out, is peddle the politics of fear. That did not work in the general election and it will not work now.

Kezia Dugdale Lab Lothian
link

In all that anger and posturing, I think that the answer was no. This is a finance secretary who is afraid of the verdict of impartial economists and is running scared of the consequences of his own policy. What are those consequences? Some £7.6 billion of cuts over and above what the Tories are offering. Why? Because the truth of full fiscal autonomy is known by his colleagues in Westminster. The SNP’s constitution spokesperson said that it would be “a disaster” and the new SNP MP for Midlothian described it as “economic suicide.”

This is less about North Sea oil and more about the SNP’s snake oil. The Deputy First Minister is trying to punt us something that he knows to be dodgy. For the sake of Scotland’s schools and hospitals, should the Deputy First Minister not just abandon this disastrous plan for full fiscal autonomy?

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

It is interesting, listening to Kezia Dugdale’s question, that she uses language that falls into the category that her leadership rival, Kenneth Macintosh, identified when he talked about the negativity of the Labour Party defining itself against the Scottish National Party. [Interruption.]

John Swinney SNP The Deputy First Minister and Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Constitution and Economy · Perthshire North
link

That approach has been tried month after month, and it has not worked for the Labour Party.

Fiscal autonomy is about building on the powers of this Parliament—powers that, over the past 16 years, have seen an improvement in Scotland’s economic performance that has taken our gross domestic product from sixth in the United Kingdom to third, behind London and the south-east, and an increase in productivity from 96 per cent of UK levels in 1999 to being in line with UK levels in 2012.

The moral of the story is that, where we can exercise distinctive economic policies in Scotland, we can transform the economic performance of our country. For me, that is what fiscal autonomy is all about. It is about enabling this Parliament to take the decisions that are right for Scotland, not to be at the mercy of a Tory chancellor who comes along one Thursday and takes £100 million out of our budget without a by your leave. I want this Parliament to decide our own economic future, and the Labour Party should see the opportunity of that for the people of our country.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Child Safety Questions · 6
  2. Parking on Pavements (Legislation) Questions · 8
  3. Rail Services (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) Questions · 4
  4. Homelessness (Glasgow) Questions · 10
  5. Local Road Network Questions · 8
  6. Bank Branch Closures (Bank of Scotland and RBS) Questions · 6
  7. Police (Charging for Community Events in Fife) Questions · 4
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  9. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  10. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  11. Budget Revisions (United Kingdom) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Personal and Social Care (Payment Arrears) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  13. Colleges (No Compulsory Redundancy Policy) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Home-Start Members’ business · 22
  15. Employee Rights and Access to Justice Debate · 126
  16. Decision Time Decision time · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.