Written Question · S7W-03608 · Session 7
What its position is regarding whether responders to its recently published consultation on fisheries management measures in relation to Ma…
The question
To ask the Scottish Government what its position is regarding whether responders to its recently published consultation on fisheries management measures in relation to Marine Protected Areas and Priority Marine Features will be able to make a fair and informed assessment of the options it presents, in light of the fact that there is no (a) inclusion of the potential economic and social benefits of a managed transition to low-impact fishing methods, such as those involving static gear use and (b) clear assessment of the extent to which each management option is expected to contribute towards achieving Good Environmental Status for benthic habitats and seafloor integrity.
The answer
The Scottish Government considers that consultees have sufficient information to provide informed views on the management options presented. The consultation is supported by a range of assessments, including a Strategic Environmental Assessment and a Socio-Economic Impact Assessment, which set out the likely environmental, social and economic effects of the proposals and the evidence underpinning those assessments.The Socio-Economic Impact Assessment (SEIA) assesses the potential economic and social impacts of the proposed fisheries management measures and proposed PMF management areas. It focuses on current fishing activity, including landings, employment and fishing effort data, to estimate the effects of the proposed measures at site level for MPAs and at a regional level for proposed PMF management areas.The assessment primarily considers economic impacts on commercial fishing activities, social impacts on individuals, communities and society, impacts on ecosystem services and economic impacts on the public sector.The methodology follows the Scottish Government’s guidance for undertaking SEIAs for MPAs in inshore waters, which was co-developed through stakeholder engagement. In assessing each management option, the SEIA considers the extent to which fishing activity may be displaced and whether affected vessels may be able to continue operating elsewhere without significant economic, environmental or social impacts.The purpose of the SEIA is to assess the reasonably foreseeable impacts of the proposed management measures on existing activities. It was not designed to model future sectoral transition scenarios or predict the extent to which fishers may adopt alternative fishing methods.The SEIA focuses on assessing the reasonably foreseeable impacts of the proposed measures on existing fishing activities, rather than modelling potential future transition pathways within the sector.
In the Official Report
No contribution in the Official Report cites S7W-03608 by reference.