Constance, Angela

• Addressing the Harms of Health Misinformation Motion
  S7M-01200 · 17 Sep 2026
• Improving Lives Through Delivering for Scotland Motion
  S7M-01003 · 02 Sep 2026
• Investing, Protecting and Renewing Scotland’s NHS Motion
  S7M-00228 · 03 Jun 2026
• Crime and Policing Bill - UK Legislation Motion
  S6M-21179 · 24 Mar 2026
• Prisoners (Early Release) (Miscellaneous Amendment and Transitional Provisions) (Scotland… Motion
  S6M-20793 · 12 Feb 2026
• Community Policing Motion
  S6M-20730.1 · 11 Feb 2026
• Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 (Exclusions and Exceptions) (Domestic Homicide and S… Motion
  S6M-20637 · 02 Feb 2026
• Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021 (Characteristic of Sex) (Amendment and Tr… Motion
  S6M-20601 · 29 Jan 2026

Divisions where they voted against their party's majority position.

• Growing Scotland’s Economy
  26 Nov 2025 · they voted No, party voted Yes
• Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution
  30 Oct 2025 · they voted Abstain, party voted Yes
• Planning
  11 Jun 2025 · they voted No, party voted Yes
• Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill
  13 May 2025 · they voted No, party voted Yes
• Free School Meals for all Primary Pupils
  11 Sep 2024 · they voted No, party voted Abstain
• Pausing the Short-term Lets Licensing Scheme
  13 Sep 2023 · they voted No, party voted Yes
• Cost of Living
  26 Oct 2022 · they voted No, party voted Yes
• Scottish Government Handling of Ferry Contracts
  29 Sep 2022 · they voted No, party voted Yes

Of the motions they've lodged that went to a vote, how often did the chamber agree.

Of the 44 motions that went to a vote, 97.7% were carried.

MSPs who voted the same way most often across shared divisions.

• MacAskill, Kenny SNP 100.0% 752 shared
• Allard, Christian SNP 100.0% 400 shared
• Salmond, Alex SNP 100.0% 469 shared
• Adam, Brian SNP 100.0% 221 shared
• Burgess, Margaret SNP 100.0% 750 shared
• Mackay, Derek Ind 99.9% 1,228 shared

MSPs they vote against most often.

• Thomson, Ross Con 17.8% 213 shared
• Kerr, Stephen Con 18.1% 915 shared
• Findlay, Russell Con 18.7% 873 shared
• Gulhane, Sandesh Con 18.7% 909 shared
• Webber, Sue Con 18.8% 914 shared
• Dowey, Sharon Con 18.9% 1,004 shared

Composite of voting agreement, sponsorship overlap, and Hansard topic affinity. Weighted 50 / 25 / 25.

• Kidd, Bill SNP 65.5
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 38 · topic 25
• MacGregor, Fulton SNP 65.0
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 28 · topic 33
• Gilruth, Jenny SNP 64.0
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 27 · topic 30
• Lyle, Richard SNP 62.9
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 30 · topic 22
• Paterson, Gil SNP 62.3
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 28 · topic 22
• Nicoll, Audrey SNP 62.0
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 0 · topic 50
• Campbell, Aileen SNP 61.8
  vote 100 · co-sponsor 20 · topic 28
• Mackay, Rona SNP 61.7
  vote 99 · co-sponsor 9 · topic 40

Words and phrases this MSP uses far more often than the chamber average (TF-IDF over their Hansard contributions).

Rebellion rate (vs party majority) per session.

• Kidd, Bill SNP 274×
• Lyle, Richard SNP 222×
• MacGregor, Fulton SNP 211×
• Martin, Gillian SNP 205×
• Paterson, Gil SNP 183×
• Stevenson, Stewart SNP 179×
• Torrance, David SNP 174×
• Arthur, Tom SNP 172×
• White, Sandra SNP 167×
• Gilruth, Jenny SNP 157×

• Findlay, Neil Lab 136×
• Gibson, Kenneth NPA 105×
• McMillan, Stuart SNP 104×
• White, Sandra SNP 95×
• Kidd, Bill SNP 82×
• Gilruth, Jenny SNP 79×
• Paterson, Gil SNP 78×
• Doris, Bob SNP 66×
• Campbell, Aileen SNP 65×
• Allan, Dr Alasdair SNP 59×

• General Question Time Chamber
  12 Nov 2026
  Ms Haughey makes a fair point. As we are a Parliament of minorities, the Government of course has an open door. The Deputy First Minister stresses day in, day …
• General Question Time Chamber
  12 Nov 2026
  I have outlined our current and present investment in general practice, but it might be of interest to Miles Briggs that core GP funding is distributed through…
• General Question Time Chamber
  12 Nov 2026
  Responsibility for planning and delivering local services rests with NHS Lothian, which monitors population growth and change in demand and works with practice…
• General Question Time Chamber
  10 Nov 2026
  Yes, I will do that. For the avoidance of doubt, I repeat what I said earlier: I am crystal clear that I expect services in Elgin and, indeed, in Inverurie to …
• General Question Time Chamber
  10 Nov 2026
  It is not an either/or. We are doing both: we are investing in general practice and in primary care. Neil Gray, my predecessor, delivered a historic additional…

Government

• Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care · 20 May 2026 — Unknown
• Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs · 30 Mar 2023 — 20 May 2026
• Minister for Drugs Policy · 20 May 2021 — 30 Mar 2023
• Minister for Drugs Policy · 22 Dec 2020 — 19 May 2021
• Cabinet Secretary for Communities, Social Security and Equalities · 18 May 2016 — 28 Jun 2018
• Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning · 21 Nov 2014 — 18 May 2016

Committee

• Equalities and Human Rights Committee Member · left 31 Aug 2020
• Committee on the Scottish Government Handling of Harassment Complaints Member · left 22 Dec 2020
• Public Audit and Post-legislative Scrutiny Committee Substitute Member · left 03 Sep 2019
• Finance and Constitution Committee Member · left 22 Dec 2020
• Economy, Energy and Fair Work Committee Member · left 03 Sep 2019
• Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee Member · left 15 Dec 2010
• Justice Committee Member · left 20 May 2010
• Public Petitions Committee Member · left 26 Jun 2008

18 total · showing most recent.

• Voluntary · 08 Jun 2026
  My sister in-law is employed by VOX Scotland, a charity and advocacy group with an interest in mental health policy which sits within my portfolio as Cabinet Secretary for Health and Care. [Registere…
• Voluntary · 08 Jun 2026
  I am Chair of the River Almond Water Quality Improvement Group. [Registered 17 July 2026]
• Voluntary · 08 Jun 2026
  I have the occasional use of a property in Argyll which is owned by Logievale Holdings, a business owned and operated by my husband.
• Voluntary · 08 Jun 2026
  I have the occasional use of a property in Argyll which was previously owned by Logievale Holdings, a business owned and operated by my husband. On 17 July 2026, ownership of the property was transfe…
• Controlled transactions · 08 Jun 2026
  No registrable interests.
• Controlled transactions · 08 Jun 2026
  No registrable interests.
• Gifts · 08 Jun 2026
  No registrable interests.
• Gifts · 08 Jun 2026
  No registrable interests.

Party

• Scottish National Party · 07 May 2026 — Unknown
• Scottish National Party · 06 May 2021 — 08 Apr 2026
• Scottish National Party · 05 May 2016 — 04 May 2021
• Scottish National Party · 05 May 2011 — 23 Mar 2016
• Scottish National Party · 03 May 2007 — 22 Mar 2011

Seats

• Almond Valley · 07 May 2026 — Unknown
• Almond Valley · 06 May 2021 — 08 Apr 2026 (Dissolution)
• Almond Valley · 05 May 2016 — 04 May 2021 (Dissolution)
• Almond Valley · 05 May 2011 — 23 Mar 2016 (Dissolution)
• Livingston · 03 May 2007 — 22 Mar 2011 (Dissolution)